She already had to use MS Teams, Slack, Jitsu and Zoom. Her take was that Zoom was by far the most usable tool. And most of her 20 years younger co-students agree.
Sadly most people don't even know about the problematic status of Zoom. And if one tells them, most do not understand what's so problematic about that.
That’s a bait and switch on the part of the university. “You’ve already paid, but now you have to give up your civil rights against this third party you’ve never heard of to get the service.”
There should be liability for the schools for doing this. A class action, perhaps?
There's a reason why (at least in this part of the world) the educational products receive additional scrutiny and need to comply to additional privacy and security directives.
There are video technologies they can license so that they can keep things running without forcing students into having to enter into abusive third party agreements. They can hire people to set up simple first-party HLS streaming systems—it can be done in a day. There are tons of non-abusive alternatives. Zoom makes malware. Can you imagine being given the option by a university to whom you have already paid tens of thousands of dollars: “install this malware or you don’t get to come to class”?
You could say the same about Amazon and their backlash against workers. “There’s a pandemic, and this company is doing what it can to keep the supplies moving, and your reaction is “sue them”?”
Yes, that is the appropriate reaction if they break the law.
A pandemic does not justify abusive, coercive behavior. If anything, it makes it more abusive.
When the alternatives don't work, it doesn't really matter how secure the alternatives are.
Bad security design is unacceptable and this is sort of indicative of a large dissonance when it comes to SV startups. "Disruption" isn't ignoring requirements - if you are able to under price your competitors because you fail to adhere to good practices (or, more importantly, regulations[1]) you're not building a lean and useful product - you've just built a half-assed competitor that can undercut prices because it is incomplete... You're selling something as a competing solution when it only does half the stuff.
There is a lot of good to be said about identifying the 90/10 value components of a problem space and discarding expensive features that would just add complexity for little value - but if those features are requirements you're just failing to actually meet the points consumers (or markets ala regulations) expect and making your profit off of deceit.
1. Looking at you Uber.
No consequences means their behavior is acceptable. Which means this will repeat until there is a reason that makes this behaviour not acceptable.
I use Zoom regularly. Their video works well. I would like to have AES-256 but also I suspect this is not a casual choice, and I'm not sure it's as clear-cut as you're assuming.
* OK, if you're an encryption expert, you obviously would roll your own to advance the state of the art, but Zoom are quite obviously not encryption experts.
Usually it is: I can spend all this time making things right, or bob here knows how to do this other simple way that is good enough in a week.
Anyone want to wager how many of their computers are now p0wned.cn?
But there are also perhaps hundreds of millions of potential immigrants worldwide who would love to come to the US permanently and have the means to do so, if it were legal. But they cannot get a green card or h1b because those are nearly impossible to get from people in some counties. So they never come.
It does seem hard to decide a fair system here but any decision is just that... A system of laws... They have no meaning unless followed. What's the point of rule of law anyways? It's the answer to arbitrary rule: by monarchs and dictators.
Which is exactly my point. According to the law, these people are illegal aliens and the government has every power to stop them from crossing the border, detain them if they're already here, and deport them to their countries of origin no matter how long they've been here. And they have no legal right to reside in the country. And a lot of conservatives argue that "sanctuary city" proclamations represent a fundamental disrespect for the rule of law.
A lot of people balk at this notion and start arguing that US immigration law is fundamentally unjust and that it's reasonable to make exceptions. And that's a perfectly reasonable perspective, but it's hard to keep that consistent with the idea that taxicab medallions, for example, are some unquestionable pillar of society.
Experience costs more because it pays off.
The example I used is Whatsapp. On the early days, but definitely after their popularity was already high in Europe, you could still impersonate any user on the platform trivially. Their only real security was obfuscation of the client source code, obfuscation of the protocol. Doesn't help much when you still have a Java (J2ME) client that is trivial to decompile. They still became hugely popular.
People quickly forget about this type of issues, or they don't assign blame where it belongs. They will just shrug over it and start believing that it is normal for computers to get hacked from time to time. After all, it appears all the time on TV.
Which comes from being inexperienced as well. And an experienced hand can save you money immediately. Such as selecting a more appropriate programming language to implement the project in. Suggesting an appropriate library to use rather than rolling one's own. Avoiding multithreaded coding disasters. Having a backup system that works. Having a revision control system that works. Knowing that unit tests have an immediate payoff. Avoiding stupid metrics like paying people based on lines of code written. Avoiding rolling your own encryption. Don't transmit passwords in plaintext. Don't do illegal things. Don't leave yourself wide open to lawsuits. Use a real CPA to do your taxes. Keep proper business records so the IRS doesn't hang you. And on and on.
My CPA makes lots of money when some young entrepreneur comes in all terrified that the IRS is auditing him and he kept no records and didn't even file returns.
An experienced hand will tell you to never ignore and never mess with the tax man.
Check out what happened to Will Smith when he paid no attention to the IRS. All his proceeds from "Fresh Prince of Bel Air" went to the IRS as taxes, interest, and penalties.
Zoom (ZM) has a market cap of $40.77B (with a forward PE of 327.31...). Delta (DAL) has a market cap of $18.19B, with a forward PE of 3.91.
Like I said, market cap isn't everything, but I find that astonishing.
If you "waste" time on the real important stuff such as a good design, user security, or the like, you will lose over to a competitor who didn't and therefore was able to spend more time on marketing.
If you waste your time on user privacy you will be totally crushed by that competitor whose definition of "privacy" was "how much can I pester this user until he gives me access to his address book so I can spam his friends?".
I don't think this is good. I think this is very sad. But it is what it is.
I still remember the Whatsapp founders coming into the jabber mailing lists with "please let me configure my server"-type questions, for god's sake.