The problem isn't Apple, Apple is great when it comes to their stock apps. The problem is all the third party apps you end up installing. They just don't care about your privacy. Half of them will bundle "analytics" that you have no power to turn off and there isn't the same open-source community for iOS that there is for Android.
What I ended up with is an open-source ROM with MicroG (in my case a custom build of AOSP but LineageOS + NanoDroid, LineageOS for MicroG or Elementary OS all work) with open-source apps for most purposes.
This way the only proprietary code running as part of the OS is the device drivers. Everything else is open-source.
Practically, pretty much everything works except for in-app payments. Those will work if you install the modified Play Store that's distributed as part of NanoDroid but that means installing the Play Store as a privileged app, which brings you right back to the original problem.
As for apps, I mainly use Maps from F-Droid (open-source build of Maps.me), OsmAnd, FairEmail, Riot, Fennec, Slide for Reddit and Bitwarden. These are all open-source.
The main closed-source apps I have installed are the local public transportation app (I'm in a country with strong privacy protections, so I trust it), the government-provided weather app and the usual financial stuff.
At some point I'll install a firewall for those too.
I want to emphasise that I don't feel like I'm giving anything up with this setup. The only thing that doesn't really work is in-app payments. I'm using a Pixel phone so I can even sign the ROM with my own private key and lock the bootloader so that nothing else can be flashed.
MicroG does provide a SafetyNet implementation but YMMV.
FWIW, all of my financial apps are perfectly happy running on my phone, even though SafetyNet mostly fails. They don't like root though.
The premium on buying brand new phones is outrageous.
Alternatively you can debloat an android with a desktop thanks to adb, when you don't want to unlock and reset your phone for a new rom.
There are already enough open source alternatives to replace Google software from android phones. Even some who replace Google play services for the apps that need it, while only having minimal contact with Google servers.
Especially with your needs it is really easy to go Google free on the phone you already own. In any other place I would think you just don't know better, but here it just sounds like an excuse.
Just what I wanted.
They’re more similar than they are different.
No, I can't ssh into my phone now, but whatever?
This being said I'm sure OP's statements are just gross exaggerations based on their personal (dis)preference. Even if continuously switching between apps was their day job the difference is so small it's irrelevant. And anyone who's able to operate one of the phones is perfectly able to operate the other.
I've been wanting to get off "Google play services" and into a smaller, cheaper phone. I don't need the huge screen and tons of features like my Pixel 2 XL has, I just need a phone, messaging, maps, and sometimes the internet to pay bills and 400 bucks is a pretty good price for a few years of that vs. I think I paid 1200 for my Pixel 2 XL (and the same for my wife!). With this, I could get one for each of us and a spare for the same price as a single phone and lose the Google privacy-ending bullshit at the same time.