Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by ecounysis on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:31AM
(#2275733)
This sort of summarization (read manipulation) of scientific results by news organizations to influence viewership is extremely bothersome. Most people who read that article take it at face value, don't check the sources, and go on with life having been misinformed. I know I would have. Irritating.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by Silhouette on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:49AM
(#2276125)
To be fair, the TorrentFreak article does mention this rather important detail as well, but it certainly doesn't make a big deal of it and the headline is clearly editorialised to the point of outright falsehood.
Looked at the other way around, more than 80% of those surveyed did not mostly or fully accept that pirate copying is ethical (7+ on a scale of 1-10).
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by _delirium on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @02:05PM
(#2276731)
Hmm, going back and reading it again, you're right, the article apart from the headline isn't too bad. I could've sworn some of these details were left out of it initially though. Any good way to check if the article has been updated?
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by aw3c2 on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @09:52AM
(#2275566)
Thanks for the clarification, torrentfreak is a tabloid.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by mambodog on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:06AM
(#2275633)
Torrentfreak is a blog.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by mkr-hn on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:11AM
(#2275649)
A blog can be a tabloid. The word tabloid might have its origins in the paper size used in the first ones, but the term doesn't have to stay there.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by mambodog on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:22AM
(#2275687)
One's expectations of any particular blog should be no more than that of a tabloid (at best), without sufficient prior evidence to the contrary.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by mkr-hn on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:25AM
(#2275704)
I can't tell whether this is a general philosophical statement or a response to my comment. I don't mind either, but I'd need more on the latter for it to make sense as a response.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by mambodog on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:33AM
(#2276044)
I see describing something as a 'tabloid' to be setting it apart as sub-standard, below an acceptable level of quality, in the medium of print. As these standards are much lower (or non-existant) for blogs, it seems a harsh comparison.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by mkr-hn on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @11:44AM
(#2276098)
I don't know why you'd preemptively lower your expectation of a blog. I start with a high standard and move on if the blog doesn't meet it. Why shouldn't this be the norm? There are more than enough good blogs on any subject to skip the bad ones.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by khafra on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @02:47PM
(#2276915)
I agree, life's too short for tabloids unless they're really useful, like the National Enquirer if you're a Man In Black, or Techcrunch if you're a startup entrepreneur.
Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by ffumarola on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @10:16AM
(#2275673)
Thanks for covering that.
When people abuse statistics it makes my head hurt. Would it really have been that hard for them to spell it out, as the original article did, in three distinct categories? It speaks to the fact that the answers to the question rest on a continuum.
I'd be curious to see what the results of this study would be if it were conducted in the US.
1. The study was restricted to Denmark. It was part of a larger study looking at Danish attitudes towards economic lawbreaking: tax evasion, benefits fraud, copyright infringement, taking home company property, etc.
2. The study asked people to rate how acceptable copyright infringement was on a scale from 1 (completely unacceptable) to 10 (completely ok). The 70% figure is everyone who answered anything except 1. But clearly a 2 out of 10 is still not very positive, especially since in context it could simply have meant that someone found it bad, but less bad than e.g. benefits fraud. Only 20% gave an answer >= 7.
3. The study specifically asked about copyright infringement for personal, home use.
---
From the report (rough translation):
Seven out of ten Danes accept to some extent the copying of music and movies without paying for them. So long, mind you, as it is limited to copying for one's own use.
Thus finds the Rockwool Foundation's study of Danish ethical attitudes in 2010.
In the study, a representative sample of people were asked to respond on a scale of 1 to 10, whether it is ok to pirate music from the internet for personal use. Those who believe that this act is acceptable under no circumstances, corresponding to a 1, total 30%.
The rest, i.e. 70%, accept pirate-copying to some degree. 50% give a rating between 2 and 6. They're probably skeptical in relation to piracy, but they seem not to think that it is totally unacceptable. The rest, around 15-20%, rate 7 or higher. This group mostly or fully accepts piracy.
The views are different however for making money on illegal music downloading. The population has a somewhat stricter view on that. In fact, three out of four respond that it is absolutely unacceptable to retrieve pirated music online and resell it to friends.
The difference between the two forms of lawbreaking is also clear in the average for all responses. Piracy for personal use has an average of 3.8 on the scale, while the score for selling to friends is as low as 1.7.