I've written about how this site handles political overlap here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21607844, and there's lots more explanation at https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que. If, after taking a look at those links, anyone has a question we haven't addressed, I'd be interested to hear it and happy to answer.
quips like "But yeah, maybe it hasn't been implemented properly yet /s" are bait.
"I see political debates here all the time." - then flag them, they are against the comment guidelines?
I sincerely was not trying to bait anyone.
That a central planning economy can be badly and inhumanely run is not, in itself, proof that one cannnot be run well run. It might be the case that it can't, even that it's irresponsible to try; but what you're doing is pointing to mass graves as a kind of emotional reasoning "that is a lot of suffering so don't you dare argue, I win" shutdown tactic.
Marx was not famous for saying "The proletariat are looking a bit porky these days, let's get a dictatorship going, kill all the farmers, starve the proles to death and call it utopia"
When Britain directed India's wheat production to Britain and starved 7 million people, or Churchill diverted Bangladesh's crop production to Greece and 4 million Bangladeshis starved, or Britain bought granaries in Iran (Persia) in the early 1900s and 2 million starved, those weren't local people determining their food supply distribution in a free market; you said in another comment that your definition of Socalism was "the only real definiton, when the government controls the market and no capitalism exists"; by your definition were these micro-instances of Communism?
You're arguing a strawman, and you have a one-word panacea answer:
Capitalism.
A one-word explanaton which covers many countries over many decades with many problems and many atrocities, one thing to blame for all ills and a one-word answer for everything good. That is unlikely to be the best possible understanding.
https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
I had a lot of genuinely new things to say that I'm sure some people didn't know.
It's impossible to keep politics out of the news... I see political debates here all the time.
I didn't pull this out of my ass to bait people, I genuinely wanted everyone to know why Venezuela is in the situation it's in.
If I would have commented in the root thread I could see your point, but I was replying to the GP's topic.
I'm actually glad I did because some people thought Sweden and Norway are socialist countries...