News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by sjg007 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:29PM (#22750517)
These farm workers live in bunk houses basically and are trucked in on school buses. Most of them are migrant laborers or undocumented immigrants.

Those conditions are not safe.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by tw04 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:19PM (#22751148)
There's a big difference between "the job can't be done safely" and "the way the job was done previously wouldn't be safe if they continue doing it that way".

There's literally no step in "picking strawberries" that can't be done while maintaining social distancing. It will increase the cost of labor, and force humans to be treated like... humans. But farming isn't inherently unsafe re: coronavirus.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by anoonmoose on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:50PM (#22751515)
You say "increase the cost of labor" like it's nothing. Fact is, industries like this couldn't be operated on the up and up in the US- people wouldn't buy the product at the price it'd need to be sold for.

I'm not saying this to justify the current conditions, I'm just pointing out that it's this or an eradication of the industry.

edit: an eradication I'm totally fine with.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:04PM (#22751698)
If the industry can't survive by following the rules then the leaders of that industry who profited from illicit behaviors should go to prison for decades and their assets should be sold off to pay damages to the effected. The industry can correct itself or die off. If no one wants a product at a humane price then the industry should go extinct in a functioning society.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by gridlockd on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:58PM (#22752336)
> The industry can correct itself or die off. If no one wants a product at a humane price then the industry should go extinct in a functioning society.

Okay, but is there a functioning society? Is there some welfare system where these people could take refuge?

I don't think so. These workers come all the way from some place where their situation wouldn't be any better, otherwise that's where they'd stay. Should the industry go extinct, they'd be strictly worse off.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by tw04 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:00PM (#22752964)
That's exactly what the southern slave owners tried claiming as well... and some slaves chose to stay because they believed the alternative would be worse. It doesn't mean we should support inhumane treatment of other people so that a handful of "Farmers" can get rich.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by gridlockd on Thursday April 02, 2020 @07:08AM (#22757813)
> That's exactly what the southern slave owners tried claiming as well... and some slaves chose to stay because they believed the alternative would be worse.

That's not my argument. Of course, if a slave owner has to give up on their "property", they're not gonna provide housing, food and equipment to their former slaves anymore. The price of labor kicks in.

Perhaps that price is lower than keeping a slave, perhaps it is higher. There's some arguments as to why free workers are actually cheaper. In any case, that price is always in flux.

You're not going to discover that price while maintaining slavery, because the slaves have no opportunity to name their price. That's why the slave owner's argument is invalid.

By contrast, the workers at these farms do have the choice. Nothing forces them, besides their own economic situation. They have no claim to welfare, no other skill that would pay better.

> It doesn't mean we should support inhumane treatment of other people so that a handful of "Farmers" can get rich.

By and large, farmers don't get rich. They're under price pressure from the store chains that buy their produce. Those store chains don't get rich either, they're under price pressure from consumers. Margins are razor-thin.

We can all stop buying strawberries and let those farms go bankrupt, everything will be strictly worse.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by tw04 on Thursday April 02, 2020 @03:46PM (#22762913)
>Nothing forces them, besides their own economic situation.

Right - starving to death is always an option, nothing is forcing them. Free market at work!

>By and large, farmers don't get rich. They're under price pressure from the store chains that buy their produce. Those store chains don't get rich either, they're under price pressure from consumers. Margins are razor-thin.

It's not 1980, that's a fallacy and has been for a long time. By and large, "farmers" are large corporations printing money.

https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2017/march/large-family...

>The shift has come at the expense of small farms. Small family and nonfamily farms accounted for 46 percent of production in 1991, but by 2015, that share had fallen under 25 percent.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by gridlockd on Friday April 03, 2020 @06:20AM (#22767810)
> Right - starving to death is always an option, nothing is forcing them. Free market at work!

The free market is not a welfare system, though it can contribute a great deal to welfare, by keeping consumer prices down. It can support a welfare system by being sufficiently productive to raise taxes to pay for stuff.

Meanwhile, those countries that do not employ a free market are poor across the board. Wealth is only achieved through corruption. That poverty is then blamed on "foreign intervention". Well, fair enough, but if your system can't handle that foreign intervention, it's still inferior.

> It's not 1980, that's a fallacy and has been for a long time. By and large, "farmers" are large corporations printing money.

Just because they're larger today doesn't mean they are printing money. It's a highly competitive business. Of course a large farm can be a bit more profitable due to economics of scale, but there's always pressure from the bottom, because the threshold to market entry isn't that high.

Just try to accept that nothing is wrong with business profits per se. Let's say farming businesses have a 12% profit margin[1]. That's the price you pay for them to take the risk of running the business, and to do so efficiently. The profit margin reflects the real price of that service, just like the price of labor. Absent of any monopolies, it's a fair price. You couldn't get it any cheaper by, say, making the government do it. To the contrary.

[1] https://farmdocdaily.illinois.edu/2018/08/operating-profit-m...

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by anoonmoose on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:36PM (#22752737)
Fine by me.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by groby_b on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:13PM (#22751807)
Then people shouldn't buy the produce. There's no universal law saying you're entitled to your strawberries.

If this approach is unsustainable (and it would be), then there are a lot of other things that need to change. What doesn't need to happen is us shrugging our shoulders, saying "meh, farmworkers need to suffer, it's too expensive otherwise"

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by anoonmoose on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:37PM (#22752751)
As said elsewhere- fine by me.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by grey-area on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:53PM (#22751560)
What price do you think strawberries would be with better conditions? I think the market would support double the price, there would just be lower sales.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by gridlockd on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:03PM (#22752386)
With strawberries, you'd think that the retail market price is already pretty close to the price that yields maximum profits.

However, the wholesale price may be far lower than that, because of oligopsony.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by triceratops on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:59PM (#22752341)
It's a fallacy to say "people wouldn't buy the product because it's too expensive" when the product is food. People kinda have to buy food, no matter what. If every food producer is subject to the same regulations, every food retailer's prices will go up.

Countries tend to protect their agricultural industry from foreign competition fairly effectively, particularly for staples.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by anoonmoose on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:38PM (#22752758)
We ain't talking beer or bread, we're talking about fresh strawberries. Not exactly a staple.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by triceratops on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:54PM (#22752903)
If every fresh strawberry producer is held to the same standards, people will either buy the strawberries at the new price or go without. The strawberry industry isn't going to be wiped out.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by borkt on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:49PM (#22750754)
My wife works with 14 H2As who serve only one property for 9 months a year in about the best possible situation and it is definitely true that they live in bunk houses, but for better or worse you find this everywhere in the world, even singapore[1]. In 10 years of working in the ag industry though, every place she has worked they have always been documented, whether FLC or H2A. The majority I've worked with while helping out during harvest are looking for some order and steady pay to send home while avoiding cartel chaos in Michiocan; they are all upstanding individuals, some who even had professional jobs back home, for example one is a dentist.

It is very uncommon in our experience to find undocumented workers in these regulated environments, though you will still find plenty at the even city sponsored "day laborer" centers, or working for the crews that end up selling their fruit on street corners in cities. From what we have hears, 20-30 years ago there was a much larger truly undocumented immigrant issue.

[1] https://sg.news.yahoo.com/blogs/singaporescene/hidden-slums-...

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by danans on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:07PM (#22750984)
> but for better or worse you find this everywhere in the world, even singapore[1]

What relevance does that have to whether or not these workers should get reasonable protection from coronavirus risks, and treatment if they get sick?

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by bluGill on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:16PM (#22751836)
Note that big farmers tend to be careful about illegal labor. When you have millions of dollars in land, you stand to lose a lot if some prosecuter is looking for an example. Smaller guys don't have as much to lose and can appear sympathetic against the big government so they are more likely to risk it.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by stainforth on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:54PM (#22750822)
"It's bad, but think how much worse it could be"
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by grey-area on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:15PM (#22751079)
Don't do that then.

Maybe we should pay more for strawberries and treat workers better?

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by bluGill on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:46PM (#22753319)
For context, housing is not something they are required to take. The they can live in a tent which is what they were doing 70 years ago when the farmers felt sorry for them living in a tent and built a bunk house for them to live in if they wanted. Bad as a bunkhouse is, almost everyone agrees it is better than a tent and so they live in that. (I love sleeping in a tent, but that is because it is a vacation I do once a year, most of my nights are spent in a house)
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:31PM (#22750540)
Nothing to do with the title - strawberries aren't the risk.

Hopefully masks are there when travelling? And an isolated cohort in a bunkhouse has some benefits. Of course it only takes one.

[dead]
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:19PM (#22752559)
Consider a title that's meaningful. Anyway nitpicking aside, folks all over are still going to work. So you can 'shelter in place' and get your Amazon delivery or groceries delivered or whatever. If they're young and confident, or really need the money, bless them.

As for the useful part of my comment, have you used a drive-thru? Did you see the close quarters and unmasked/ungloved employees there? Meeting a customer a minute for 8 hours?

Picking produce at least puts you in an enormous field away from crowded city conditions with a small cohort of people. Its risky, but likely no riskier than 100 other jobs.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by londons_explore on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:30PM (#22750519)
Strawberry pickers typically work very close to one another with hundreds in the same area of a field at once, with lots of trucks as central points to put the fruit, etc.

Workers also typically live on caravans near/on the fields in very cramped quarters to save commute time/cost.

That could easily be changed to a more distributed method with per-worker wheelbarrows or backpacks, but presumably that would decrease throughput and increase costs.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by agjmills on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:49PM (#22750763)
Personally, and I'd hope this is echoed by everyone:

I'd rather have less strawberries, that are more expensive, than have strawberries picked by someone who died as a result of contracting COVID-19 in a field whilst they were picking strawberries to earn money to feed themselves/their family.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by londons_explore on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:07PM (#22752432)
And are you going to buy a different brand of laptop because the steel that made the springs in the power connector was recycled in a grimy workshop in Ukraine by a 6 year old child?

It turns out policing entire supply chains by consumers isn't viable. Either enforce regulations, or do nothing. The middle ground of trying to shame companies into doing 'good' things just leaves uneven playing fields for companies without a public face to shame.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by doliveira on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:10PM (#22751022)
Words amount to nothing if our wallets won't agree.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by solotronics on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:27PM (#22752636)
Unpopular opinion: the fruit pickers need money also. I don't think eliminating these jobs shifts demand for these folks somewhere else, in fact they probably can't find other work at this time.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by endorphone on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:04PM (#22750951)
It's impossible to make these sorts of judgments without an understanding of what the end goal is. What the off ramp of Coronavirus town is in best and worst cases.

e.g. If a vaccine is realistically a year off (which is realistic, though we clutch onto every bit of preliminary news when in reality most are failures), in the relatively near term we will start to all have to take more risks, and the majority of us will go through COVID-19.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by majormajor on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:24PM (#22751211)
So when shopping... how do you translate that goal into which products to purchase?
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by joejerryronnie on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:07PM (#22750994)
Everybody says this, and then proceeds to buy the cheapest, most convenient products possible.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:12PM (#22751798)
You can blame the customer all you want but you're only deluding yourself. Marketers, criminal farmers, pro business regulations, nonexistent law enforcement, and an economy that favors short term profits over long term sustainability are among some of the reasons why these things continue. It's not the customer buying random strawberries at a grocer that's the problem here.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by ceejayoz on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:25PM (#22751225)
Not everyone; Farmers' markets and CSAs are available, and often quite popular. That said, this is where regulation comes in.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by cma on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:19PM (#22751144)
Maybe they are advocating companies pay the liability, raising the price and incentivizing safer practices. Without some kind of labeling laws saying how many estimated to die per strawberry, you’d have to do a research project on every brand.
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by fock on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:19PM (#22752562)
yeah, because there's no way to tell about labour conditions in the supermarket... (where most of us unfortunately have to shop) I would really like to have shop to tell production cost/per unit like they have to do with price/unit in the EU. Not gonna happen with "Big"-Ag writing paychecks to the MPs though...
Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by op03 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:50PM (#22751511)
Agree. Fast food workers are more likely to come in contact with super spreaders in the network than farm workers.

Would be interesting to see Italian, Spanish, French data on infections by profession.

I'd guess its going to be biased to travelers(travel related professions), travel sector(airports, hotels, stations etc), health workers, seniors/patients already in hospital for something else, and families of all of the above.

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by kitotik on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:45PM (#22750706)
This is one of the more dismissive and ignorant comments I’ve ever seen in HN.

Do you have some subject matter expertise or was this just intuition?

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:21PM (#22752576)
Social distancing is important in all sorts of jobs. What about this one makes that impossible? Looked in the window at your local McD's lately? Is it any different?

(If that comment was some sort of outlier, must not be reading much on HN.)

Re:Farmworkers face coronavirus risk: ‘You can’t pick strawb... by ericsoderstrom on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:15PM (#22751081)
I think OP's comment was more highlighting how dumb the article title is.