Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by Ono-Sendai on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:34AM
(#22737875)
You mean pi should have been defined as the ratio of the circumference of a circle to the radius, instead of to the diameter? Probably, yeah :)
Better yet, I think the unit of angle we should use is the 'full rotation' ('rot'?)
So instead of 360 degrees, or 2pi radians, we say 1 rot.
The many factors of 2pi in common equations imply we got this wrong.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by amelius on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:47AM
(#22738016)
I like this idea of "rot" more than "tau", except "rot" is already a stand-in for "∇⨯" in mathematics.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by Ono-Sendai on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:53AM
(#22738077)
Maybe calling it a 'turn' instead.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by SamBam on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:20AM
(#22738349)
That has been a proposal, and is part of the nice aspects of using τ instead of π.
> The second reason is that τ corresponds to one turn of a circle, and you may have noticed that “τ” and “turn” both start with a “t” sound.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by Ono-Sendai on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:52AM
(#22738071)
Yeah my proposal differs a bit from the tau proposal, although there are some similarities.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by Archit3ch on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:57AM
(#22738121)
But where do you stop? Do we need a name for pi/2? How about pi/12?
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by martincmartin on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:36AM
(#22737889)
I think OP is suggesting that we change the definition of radian, not Pi.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by Ono-Sendai on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:42AM
(#22737956)
it's a bit ambiguous. Of course the radian has that definition for a particular reason, 1 radian being the angle such that the arc length equals the radius.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by SamBam on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:27AM
(#22738436)
I don't believe substituting tau for 2-pi requires redefining either pi or radians. Rather it simply changes what you say you are multiplying by: instead of a circle being 2-pi radians, it's tau-radians. These are both saying the same thing, without changing pi or radians.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by martincmartin on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:37AM
(#22737902)
Radians are useful because the derivative of sin is cos, derivative of cos is - sin, limit (sin(h)/h) as h -> 0 is 1, etc.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by cpa on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:38AM
(#22737911)
Some people call it tau! https://tauday.com/
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by leetcrew on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:32AM
(#22737858)
because then the formula for area would be (pi/2)r^2?
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by SamBam on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:34AM
(#22738523)
Indeed, that's an advantage. If you use tau=2pi, you'd then you'd see how the area = 1/2 τr^2 is actually conceptually similar to KE = 1/2 mv^2 (and similar for PE, distance fallen in gravity, etc. That 1/2 is actually important.)
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by vesinisa on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:44AM
(#22737977)
The famous Euler's identity
e^(i * π) = -1, where i is the imaginary unit
would not in fact hold if we changed the definition of the radian. It's just the mathematically natural way of expressing arguments to trigonometric functions.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by niklasbuschmann on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @12:37PM
(#22739364)
I think Euler’s identity becomes more elegant when using 2π instead of π:
e^(2πi) = 1
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360...
by epage on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @02:55PM
(#22741096)
The form I was taught:
e^jpi + 1 = 0
The reason for this form is that it doesn't just contain an imaginary unit and the two most popular constants but the additive and multiplicative identities.
EDIT: I meant redefining pi instead of the radian.