On my 3900X I've seen even single player action titles utilize 16+ threads with overall CPU utilization reaching peaks of 80-90 %.
Yes, it maybe be hard to parallelize game engines, but all major ones heavily use multiple cores. A bunch of years ago (4-5) people would recommend an i3-K dual core for gaming, because you could overclock it to 5+ GHz on air. That was sufficient for many titles back then. (And these i3s would sometimes give you higher FPS compared to the more expensive quad-core options). But a CPU like that is far too weak for newer titles.
> You still can't beat intel at the high end. Both in terms of heat and performance. If you have a task that doesn't parallelize well, you can't beat intel.
In terms of heat, that is, performance per Watt, Intel's high end is quite a bit worse than AMD's. It is true however that you can get slightly higher single-threaded performance out of Intel's highest-end CPUs, but not because they are more efficient (- AMD is better both perf/W and IPC-wise), but just by raw, unadulterated clock speed, pushing them to 5+ GHz. And that causes them to burn a lot of power.
Zen 2 has consistently ~10-15 % higher performance clock-for-clock compared to Intel's best while achieving approximately 60-80 % higher perf/W.
This LTT review captures the massive advantage Zen 2 has in efficiency: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYqG31V4qtA
Under load the system is brilliant (it's 4x faster with the same power usage, makes using my laptop painfully slow in comparison). The power management on these CPUs is incredibly advanced (each core runs at different speeds & voltages), I'm just surprised that it doesn't do better at idle.
The usual desktop (3500-3800 series) chips perform similarly well, it's just the two-chiplet AM4 processors that have been somewhat plagued by problems like this.
which ones? genuinely curious. I have two Intel E5 eight-cores in an old workstation and rarely ever see a game using more than 2-4 threads.
I guess i'm not spending my time on the latest and great AAA games as soon as they come out, but i've spent quite a few (shameful) hours gaming on fairly recent titles.
In fact it’s one of the reasons we made our own game engine.
It's not only that the turbo boost of those Ryzen cpus is high and at the same clock Intel does not have a lead anymore. It's also that recent games are already pretty parallelized. There is no need to wait for the next console generation to see that effect.
Btw, the 3800X is not a good pick. It is just a minimally higher clocked 3700X. If you want 8 cores, get the 3700X, the higher price of the 3800X is just a waste of your money. But for gaming you want to stick to a Ryzen 5 3600.
[0]: https://www.pc-kombo.com/us/benchmark/games/cpu/compare?ids[...
That really depends on the pricing situation, very much like with the 3600x.
Over the months I've seen the price difference between a 3800x and 3700x see as low as 20€, the same with the 3600 and the 3600x.
That's because the 3600 and 3700x are recommended, and sold so often that retailers sometimes end up sitting on large stocks of 3600x/3800x too long and clear them out at discounts.
Imho even for gaming the 3800x might be a pretty good long term choice. The higher clocks are particularly relevant yet you still get the core advantage of the 3700x, without taking the same clock hit.
But if it's all about the budget and price/performance then it's really difficult to beat the 3600.
Now, if it's the same price there is no reason not to get the 3800X over the 3700X :)
> The top 20% of all 3800X processors tested passed their 4.3 GHz AVX2 stress test, whereas the top 21% of all 3700X processors were only stable at 4.15 GHz. Also, all 3800X processors passed the test at 4.2 GHz, while 3700X processors were only good at 4.05 GHz, meaning the 3800X has about 150 MHz more headroom when it comes to overclocking.
That's a minimal difference of course, but right at the clock wall of Ryzen, so AMD has to do binning here to enable the 3800X.
It would not make a difference when judging Intel vs AMD or Ryzen 3000 vs Intel 9000 series.
The source articles for the benchmarks are linked though, often enough they also have those 1% or 0.1% benchmarks.
This sentiment is almost a year out of date. Since Zen 2 launched, Intel has a measurable disadvantage in IPC. Intel's single-thread performance is only partially won back with higher clock speeds at the expense of far greater power usage.
ECS and being able to safely run "systems" within your game concurrently is becoming a thing rapidly as "lists of objects" do not scale.
I just checked Doom Eternal: it's running 81 threads. (Of course, not all of them are always active or doing things concurrently. It's just a datapoint.)
Intel basically only wins by a non-significant margin at video encoding nowadays thanks to AVX512 which AMD does not implement. AMD wins or is comparable at a lower TDP on everything else.
https://twitter.com/axelgneiting/status/1241487918046347264?...
I’ve been wondering if this will become de facto standard for multi-threaded/multi-core systems going forward.
ECS, the observer pattern, and behavior trees are probably the three main things that answered all the "how on earth do they build something this complex" questions for me.
I just ran across this: https://csherratt.github.io/blog/posts/specs-and-legion/
Specs? At least that's what Amethyst uses.
e.g. in say a jrpg you have "new game/continue" menu -> world map -> battles and character menu and back again.
Edit: oh I misunderstood you - you were asking about behaviour trees. I haven't used them for anything other than controlling game unit behaviour (although not necessarily just enemy ai - one other example is using them to combine a bunch of simple actions into one thing that the user can tell a unit to do - so like an attack move in an RTS is actually "loop (is enemy nearby? -> no -> move towards location -> yes -> attack (which is probably it's own behaviour tree))
That's some dinosaur games from the past. Modern games are using all available CPU cores with something like Vulkan and saturate GPU fully. So Intel CPUs are left in the dust with all the cores you get from high end Ryzens.
There should be a formalized law for this - anything that was once widely known as true (because it was) will continue to be treated as gospel far after it ceases to be the case.
And when challenged by the new norm, the old guard repeat their gospel louder and in greater numbers! So if you hear some technological rule of thumb repeated often enough, you should doubt it even more than if you hadn't heard it at all.
It is not that the Gamers and Prosumers dont know.
But they are willing to trade ~10% of Single Thread Performance for Double the Core at a similar or less price point.
Sounds like a very reasonable decision to me.
Citation needed. Games are about the least "Traditional" software engineering culture on the planet. We've had multicore CPUs for the last two gens of consoles (and I've seen multi-core programming on the Saturn and N64). On PC we've had mainstream multicore since 2009-ish. That's about when I left games. But given the need to win big on consoles, I can't imagine anyone has a main loop anymore that does everything on one thread.
>> traditionally
> anymore
> does everything on one thread
Multithreading is useful for concurrent programming separately from its value in parallel programming.
[0] https://ultra64.ca/files/other/Game-Developer-Magazine/GDM_S...
Most games are lightly threaded, with newer games being much better optimized for 6+ cores.
Even for Gaming, only the 9900K/KS are even in consideration for a good choice, and if you're doing anything besides gaming or quicksync loads, odds are you're better off with AMD. The 3900X is less expensive and does as good or better in most workloads, and even in gaming, most wouldn't be able to tell the difference.
As to best of the best for higher end, the Threadripper has no peer.
There is a free to play game Armored Warfare (crysis engine?), which I genuinely used to test stability of my cpu. 8 threads fully loaded and probably with some form of AVX.
Reviews of upcoming Mount&Blade also note how it loads 16+ threads (mostly for NPC on battlefield).
Arma3 was notorious for being bound by single thread performance and low latency memory.
on a old midrange i5 6500 b5 does a solid 30+ fps on ultra and cpu load doesn't top out so I find the claim that it needs a top of the line cpu very dubious. I'll try armored warfare since it's free.
also, the fps reduction seems more in line with the low end intels having less pci lanes, and not the game being cpu capped.
Very few people genuinely notice the difference. I ran a 3600 while waiting for a 3950X, and if I had it to do over, would probably have just gone 3900X to start with... For the most part, I don't notice the difference, only after I'm running a couple databases and a few services that are active to I even come close to seeing a difference in general use.
I know GPU and Monitor options are similar, and CPU/GPU combination in terms of balance are important. Unless you're going RTX 2080 or higher, then it's much less of a difference in general use anyway.
Games are traditionally single threaded and hard to parallelize.
However: you don't need to be the best, you just need to be at the "agreed upon" high end for game requirements, which is the xbox and ps4 (soon to be next gen).
And so, if you're trying to build a "generation proof" gaming PC in a standard sized case, the 3800X is currently your best bet for a new build (or waiting for zen3). If you're trying to do SFF, Intel may be a better choice.
Regardless: AMD's competition has dropped the prices in the "enthusiast" segment. My next build will be AMD, simply because I don't need the best of the best, but rather, good enough.