News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dmayle on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:14AM (#22717739)
(Replying to a trollish comment, but don't want to push it to the top). There was a comment about the salary that CEO Sal Khan takes, with is over $800,0000 per year.

I think Khan Academy is fantastic, and was going to donate until I saw this figure (verified). I think that it's entirely inappropriate to extract that much from the donations.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by elamje on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:33AM (#22717815)
The year is 2050, Khan Academy has raised 2 billion in funding, restructured as a for-profit corporation, and has vendor lock-in with nearly every school and child in the world. Khan academy charges a minimum of $800/yr/student. The CEO takes home $56 million a year. Which do you prefer, 800k, or 50 mil? Do we really want to a world where a brilliant mind, Sal Khan, is not rewarded at all for leaving his hedge fund career to make YouTube videos for next to nothing for many months, if not years? On top of that, he likely had a very real opportunity to turn Khan academy into a huge company, but instead went the non hockey stick, nonprofit route. Being a part of a successful non profit doesn’t mean you need to dip into your employees and your own salary to pay bills. Some of this might just be publicity to show that Khan academy is growing rapidly with remote learning.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by kiba on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:55AM (#22717935)
This whole startup scenario is likely to end badly for Khan Academy, or that the drive for money at all cost is killing Khan Academy's value as an education platform.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by kharak on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:21AM (#22717770)
Yes, truly terrible that non-profit organisations serving the common good should provide high salaries. Founder and employees should just go into banking, because those guys absolutely deserve their high pay.

Imagine, just imagine a society, where doing non-profit could be a valid career option without a disadvantage in the income department. The horror.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by JensRex on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:29AM (#22717801)
Try arguing with less snark.

Every comment like yours attacks the strawman that the CEO and employees should not get paid. Nobody is saying that. But I'm absolutely not going to donate anything while the CEO takes out over 800000 dollars in pay, and it looks distasteful to me to go around begging for donations.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by kharak on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:46AM (#22717884)
I hold the position represented by Dan Palotta in this Ted Talk: https://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pallotta_the_way_we_think_abou...

There is nothing distasteful about non-profit CEOs wanting high pay. We're speaking about the founder of something that has and is helping millions of people around the world with arguably one of the most difficult and important educational needs. Khan Academy wouldn't be here without Khan himself and the world would be lesser for it. I see absolutely no reason why the CEO of such an organizations shouldn't paid in the same manner as for-profits.

I'm snarky, because the implied notion of "people doing good instead of chasing profits don't deserve the same pay/good life" is nothing short of crazy to me.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dirtydroog on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:57AM (#22717945)
There is something distasteful about them wanting high pay and extra donations to cover an unseen expense.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by kharak on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:00AM (#22717956)
And you know already that Khan is going to take the same salary this year? This is just rationalization, be honest with yourself, you simply dislike the idea of Khan getting this much for himself, no matter what.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by lern_too_spel on Sunday March 29, 2020 @12:02PM (#22720021)
$800k is an experienced engineer's salary where Khan Academy is based.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dirtydroog on Sunday March 29, 2020 @12:39PM (#22720328)
Lol, what
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by lern_too_spel on Monday March 30, 2020 @02:41AM (#22725763)
Khan Academy is based in Mountain View. There are plenty of engineers getting that annual compensation at Facebook/Google/Netflix.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by cosmodisk on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:07AM (#22717994)
What do you think his salary should be that you'd feel comfortable to make a donation?
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by JensRex on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:15AM (#22718038)
Significantly less.

This feels like somebody setting up a GoFundMe to pay off their credit card debt. They paid their CEO an absurd salary, and now they need more money. That sounds like a you-problem.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by bbrree66 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:27AM (#22718110)
This is not even close to the same thing. If you don't want to donate, then don't. But this is a red herring.

What you should be thinking about is the value he provides, not the absolute amount he is paid. The net positive effect of him running it and getting paid $800k is much higher than someone else who can't run things as well getting paid $100k. The goal is to maximize the output of the non-profit, not to keep salaries low. What you should care about is ROI on your dollars donated.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by wegs on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:01AM (#22718633)
I think it's a false statement to say someone less expensive will run things less well. I've been at a number of not-for-profits, and that does not match my experience at all.

Compensation should be set at a level where people don't need to worry about money, with a reasonable but basic standard of living. In the Bay, unfortunately, that's around $200k. On the other hand, compensation should not be set at a level where people are there for the money. You want people to be there because they are passionate and care.

$200 will bring people just as competent as $800k, but (1) your burn rate is lower (2) people are there for the mission (3) you can ask for donations in good faith.

Depending on part of the country, you can step that down significantly, in turn.

If you do want to invest extra money on people, a better place to spend that is stability and benefits (in the way universities do). I'd gladly take a job for $200k with a lifetime guarantee of doing meaningful work over one at $800k without that guarantee.

I actually think a lot of the bad decisions by Khan Academy are related to misaligned incentive structures. Khan tries to keep a pretty deep moat protecting business models. The platform isn't open source. Partnerships are hard to come by. Research partnerships are exceptionally difficult (Khan data is a proprietary resources). There's a cult personality. Etc.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by lotsofpulp on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:25AM (#22718803)
> Compensation should be set at a level where people don't need to worry about money, with a reasonable but basic standard of living. In the Bay, unfortunately, that's around $200k. On the other hand, compensation should not be set at a level where people are there for the money. You want people to be there because they are passionate and care.

This is not realistic based on my experience with what motivates people.

> I'd gladly take a job for $200k with a lifetime guarantee of doing meaningful work over one at $800k without that guarantee.

Nature doesn’t offer guarantees on a lifetime timescale.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by govg on Sunday March 29, 2020 @10:43AM (#22719381)
You're joking if you think 200k will get you someone who manages an entire group like Khan Academy. That's the amount of money new graduates make out of their college in FANG, and in no way is what Khan does comparable to a generic software developer.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by bbrree66 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @11:25AM (#22719731)
Most of what you're saying is nonsense and unsubstantiated.

> I think it's a false statement to say someone less expensive will run things less well. I've been at a number of not-for-profits, and that does not match my experience at all.

This is a favorite of people trying to disprove something. Just because it doesn't apply all of the time doesn't mean it's incorrect. It applies most of the time. And your experience is anecdotal and thus low value. In the majority of cases, people who get paid more are more skilled at getting the desired results. This is how capitalism works.

> Compensation should be set at a level where people don't need to worry about money, with a reasonable but basic standard of living. In the Bay, unfortunately, that's around $200k. On the other hand, compensation should not be set at a level where people are there for the money. You want people to be there because they are passionate and care.

This is fairyland non-sense. Let's stick to reality and not your idealizations. Notice how many times you use "should". According to who? Why?

> $200 will bring people just as competent as $800k, but (1) your burn rate is lower (2) people are there for the mission (3) you can ask for donations in good faith.

Unsubstantiated nonsense. Again, let's stick to reality.

> If you do want to invest extra money on people, a better place to spend that is stability and benefits (in the way universities do). I'd gladly take a job for $200k with a lifetime guarantee of doing meaningful work over one at $800k without that guarantee.

Again, nonsense. What is this based on? No one cares about your personal preferences. It's irrelevant. As I said, your logic is weak. You can't hear something and say "that's not true for me"! And think that disproves anything. You're over-indexing on your own beliefs and it's clouding your thinking.

> I actually think a lot of the bad decisions by Khan Academy are related to misaligned incentive structures. Khan tries to keep a pretty deep moat protecting business models. The platform isn't open source. Partnerships are hard to come by. Research partnerships are exceptionally difficult (Khan data is a proprietary resources). There's a cult personality. Etc.

Again, nonsense. Please provide some facts, from the real world, that substantiate these claims. You're living in a dream where all that matters is what you personally think and how you want things to be and are completely disconnected from reality and facts. You're just finding made up points to confirm the bias you already have. E.g. "There's a cult personality". What does that even mean? It's a made-up statement because you feel the longer your list of things is the more evidence you have.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by vowelless on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:31AM (#22718133)
You really think 800k is “absurd” money for what he does? Boy, I have news for you.
[dead]
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by barry-cotter on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:50AM (#22718563)
EdX is also a non-profit.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by jrs235 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @11:08AM (#22719587)
Thank you. I did not know that.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by fragmede on Sunday March 29, 2020 @12:12PM (#22720115)
With a more revenue driven model (aka stop giving anything away for free), Kahn Academy would be deriving a lot more revenue from the added traffic. They are still giving away a significant amount of value away for free and asking for donations back.

Someone set-up a GoFundMe for their credit card bill, which they ran up buying supplies to make masks for doctors in need. You are saying that, because they treated themselves to Olive Garden once for dinner, instead of only ever eating the cheapest thing off the McDonald's menu, that they need to repent. Meanwhile, actual fat cat CEOs are eating at $250/person steakhouses while raping the Earth.

800k is a lot of money, but it's really not for that sort of position. CEOs regularly make tens or hundreds of millions of dollars. The ones that famously don't, like Steve Jobs or Mark Zuckerberg, are able to do so because they are already obscenely wealthy.

Have you heard of the phrase "throwing the baby out with the bathwater?" Because that's what you're proposing here.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by lotsofpulp on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:25AM (#22718097)
“They” would be fine getting even higher pay elsewhere working for private interests. The losers would be the general public who benefit from the education.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dmayle on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:31AM (#22717807)
Thank you. This is exactly what I meant, as well.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by lern_too_spel on Sunday March 29, 2020 @12:01PM (#22720010)
> it looks distasteful to me to go around begging for donations.

Where do you think the money comes from to run the organization? They don't monetize their users. Asking for donations is a significant part of Sal Khan's job.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dmayle on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:27AM (#22717798)
It's not about paying a salary. I've worked in non-profits before, all of the employees themselves are taking pay cuts to work for the greater good. He's asking people to give up their money in order to provide this service. A salary half that size provides an extravagant lifestyle, what he's taking is exorbitant.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by kharak on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:37AM (#22717835)
What CEO's and many other people in for-profit industries are getting, is also quit exorbitant. But that's generally accepted.

Why do some people go nuts if they see non-profits demanding high pay? Khan Academy has done something unique, helpful and truly excellent, but how dare Salman Khan wanting a cut similar to for-profits. (If it is similar, properly still less).

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by mikekchar on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:55AM (#22717939)
I think the key here is that most people equate "non-profit" with "charity". The idea is that as much money as possible is used to fund the services provided by the entity. However, there are many businesses run as non-profit entities that are not in it to provide a charity. It's just that the entity of the company is designed to take no profit. Often these entities invest heavily into growth as opposed to taking profit (and often this is even the stated goal of the organization).

If you take donations, it sounds like you should be a charity, but there are lots of examples of organizations that rely on donations, but are not charities. Basically anybody living off Patreon, for example.

Having said that, I don't think it is wrong for a donator to decide that they don't want to donate because one person is taking the lion's share of the wealth. In fact, there are for profit organisations that I will avoid simply because they don't seem to provide a service other than to line some fat cat executives' pockets. People are free to choose how they want to spend their money.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by toto444 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:09AM (#22718003)
Some economists show in the paper linked below that being not for profit can be seen as a commitment for quality since you have removed from the company the incentives to exploit your consumers.

Abstract :

Entrepreneurs who start new firms may choose not-for-profit status as a means of committing to soft incentives. Such incentives protect donors, volunteers, consumers and employees from ex post expropriation of profits by the entrepreneur.

https://scholar.harvard.edu/shleifer/publications/not-profit...

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dillonmckay on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:59AM (#22718266)
I disagree with that. Most US universities are non-profits and use undergrad revenues for real estate development.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by mikekchar on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:51PM (#22723514)
While absolutely true, a good counter example are various co-ops that are run as non-profits. Often they can not only be the best place to get high quality good, but also the only place, since they are driven by what their members want rather than trying to make the highest possible profit. However, wherever there is a lot of money, you will find people who are trying desperately to shove that money into their pockets.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by threatofrain on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:47AM (#22717890)
But Khan Academy is a non-profit. In a business, the relationships between various parties are structured in a locally rational manner. When someone offers $1000 to a business they expect value back.

Khan Academy is soliciting donations, an avenue of human interaction which asks us to suspend this local rationality and instead transact on hope and trust. That's the difference to me between a business transaction and a donation.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by gnomewascool on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:45AM (#22718199)
But Khan Academy is already providing immense value to students — actually now they're (arguably) providing 150% more value than normally.

Hence, you're not being asked to "transact on hope and trust".

The main difference between donating to KA and a typical business transaction, is that the value of the goods/services provided does not necessarily go to the person providing the payment.

There is an understandable worry about over-payment of executives, but I don't think that the "threat model" is significantly different between for-profits and non-profits. You could argue that in the case of for-profits, competition will weed out companies that over-pay their executives, but internal, corporate politics is likely to trump the market mechanism — at least that's what seems to be happening. As a result, I don't think that it makes sense to excessively harp on executive pay at non-profits you donate to, or at least not more so than you care about the pay of the CEO at a company whose products you buy.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by inimino on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:23AM (#22718078)
> When someone offers $1000 to a business they expect [...]

> [...] transact on hope and trust.

These two things are not as dissimilar as you seem to think.

There is nothing irrational about donating to a non-profit, and nothing irrational about paying high salaries to irreplaceable employees or executives.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by hnarn on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:05AM (#22717985)
> Imagine, just imagine a society, where doing non-profit could be a valid career option without a disadvantage in the income department. The horror.

I don't feel like I should have to explain this, but the difference between a non-profit and a profit driven corporation is that:

1) The NPO is likely doing some kind of activity for the greater good, which means that the more money you take out for administration and profit, the less good you can do.

2) The Corporation is likely doing some kind of profit-driven activity for the primary benefit of increasing the value of the company. Corporations generate profit by their very nature since their purpose is not primarily to solve (profit-wise) unattractive problems or to perform charitable work: the purpose is primarily to generate profit.

Anyone that understands the difference between these two should be able to draw the conclusion that:

1) If an NPO is burdened by excessive expenses, such as administrative cost, it will have less money to spend against the objective of "greater good".

2) If a Corporation is burdened by excessive expenses, such as bonuses, salaries or is otherwise mismanaged financially, this only affects the corporations capability of making a profit.

It should be plain to see that the complaint against NPO salaries is not equivalent to a complaint of a for-profit corporate counterpart.

Since I was immediately downvoted I'd also like to add that this logic also applies to questioning public expenses. Taxes are allegedly levied to supply common services and serve the "common good", would you also argue that politicians should be salaried on par with profit driven corporations, in the name of ensuring competence of public officials, even if that means less common good can be taken out from your taxes?

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by kharak on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:17AM (#22718045)
Strongly disagree. The more money is in being part of a NPO, the more talent will go into NPOs. Hence, your first point 1) isn't as clear-cut as you make it out to be.

Right now, if I'd want to work for a NPO, it would only come with a severe pay cut. So I stay with FPOs, although I believe that many NPOs are way more important in what they are doing.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by yomly on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:16AM (#22718041)
Right, but this mentality leads to greater good type causes to require martyrs amongst other types of people. A failure mode of this is brain drain - see most civil service jobs in the west or NHS doctors in the UK. Additionally can create brain drain which the beleaguers the original cause.

I guess you can see personnel as an investment towards the cause too

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by tadzik_ on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:28AM (#22718120)
From what I gathered, while his salary is 800,000, the costs of IT are about 5M. With 250% of the regular load, while it probably won't go up to 12.5M, the costs likely increase by so much than his salary is still pretty much insignificant.

From the other perspective: they provide, apparently, an invaluable service. While the entire world struggles with keeping the education going, people apparently need Khan Academy 2.5 times as much as they did before. And you think the CEO now deserves less pay than he gets, at the time when we need him more than we ever did before?

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by vowelless on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:28AM (#22718113)
I think he is being underpaid by at least a multiple. I wish we valued teachers like him more. He should be making athlete level money.

I support Math for America that provides stipends to smart teachers. It has the same premise: good teachers are rare and it’s good for everyone if they stay in education instead of being lured to Google or Goldman Sachs.

https://www.mathforamerica.org/

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by jessaustin on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:43AM (#22718516)
...good teachers are rare and it’s good for everyone if they stay in education instead of being lured to Google or Goldman Sachs.

Is this a common Goldman pipeline? Do they have recruiters hanging around teachers' lounges? The teachers I know who have gotten fed up with all of it have become insurance agents, agricultural extension people, etc. b^)

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by barry-cotter on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:55AM (#22718597)
https://www.thecrimson.com/column/plain-truth/article/2020/3...

> After your stint at Teach for America, a two-year post-undergraduate teaching program, you decided to leave the academic world behind and work in New York City. Where are you most likely to be employed? Goldman Sachs.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by jessaustin on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:23AM (#22718786)
Offered without comment, I'm not sure what this link to an opinion column is supposed to mean. The quote is a hypothetical example. It seems that T4A is more of a temporary diversion program than a recruitment program anyway. Harvard students, who in a just universe would all become wealthy investment bankers, are encouraged to teach in urban schools for a couple of years. This despite the fact that their Economics and Philosophy concentration probably included very little on pedagogy. This despite the nearly universal (although not necessarily justified) opinion among teachers and administrators that first-year teachers are pretty much useless. This despite the writer's apparent suggestion that the point of the whole thing should be an easier "in" to Goldman.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by barry-cotter on Sunday March 29, 2020 @10:07AM (#22719091)
> This despite the fact that their Economics and Philosophy concentration probably included very little on pedagogy.

This is irrelevant since the effects of a degree in education on measures of student learning is not reliably distinguishable from zero. Training in pedagogy either doesn’t matter at all or matters very, very little.

> This despite the nearly universal (although not necessarily justified) opinion among teachers and administrators that first-year teachers are pretty much useless.

That’s a bit harsh but the only reliable correlate of teacher quality I’m aware of is years of experience up to six years. First years probably aren’t “pretty much useless” but you’d prefer more seasoned instructors.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by decasteve on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:16AM (#22718733)
Do you treat other organizations the same? Neflix pays Reed Hastings 10s of millions. Does that stop you from subscribing?

I still think "donating" is appropriate regardless of what they pay their executives. Just don't treat it as an altruistic charity.

Think of the donation as a pay-what-you-can/want for the service. If you have the means, pay $10 per month and treat it like a subscription while you're using the service.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by grumple on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:33AM (#22718461)
He deserves every penny and more. He’s brought so much knowledge to the world.

For reference, there are many developers making more than that in SV, and they don’t run their organizations.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by DevX101 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:22AM (#22718386)
Khan Academy's budget is the same as a large high school but has the impact at least 500x. Him making 4x a principal's salary I have absolutely no problem with.

His opportunity cost is also very high. Salman Khan could get a job tomorrow making millions in annual comp.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by monkin on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:23AM (#22717776)
> I think that it's entirely inappropriate to extract that much from the donations.

You know, that Stallman lived for years out of donations? And no one was opposite of that. It also worked for WikiMedia etc. It's great business model but people need to stop looking on non-profits like that next corporation. They require far more work and I think leaders of such projects should be compensated well. :)

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by luckylion on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:32AM (#22717812)
To be fair, there's a difference between getting a salary from donations and getting 40x the average income from donations.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by mikekchar on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:01AM (#22717959)
To be even more fair, RMS received hundreds of thousands of dollars in prizes (MacArthur and Takeda awards just to name 2) for the work he did and as far as I can tell he plowed it all back into the FSF. I couldn't quite figure out what he was paid for his work at the FSF, but I'd be fairly surprised if it was substantially more than what he donated himself.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by red2awn on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:41AM (#22717848)
But the value he provides to the world is (in my opinion) more than 40x the average person.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by cameronbrown on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:26AM (#22717787)
Absolutely not. If you don't pay the best, you'll get lower quality teachers and developers.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by srazzaque on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:04AM (#22717979)
There's something to this. Maybe you won't get the most altruistic people, but you'll absolutely get a higher quality cut of the workforce.

I've heard that the Singaporean government has a similar philosophy. Their prime minister is one of the (if not, the) highest paid PM in the world at circa SGD $2m/year.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by cosmodisk on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:13AM (#22718032)
Looking purely at the stats,I'd say they deserve it.Also,the PM and the cabinet had substantial cuts to their salaries some years ago,which was initiated by the PM himself.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by buu700 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:22AM (#22718387)
Adding my 2c: his salary has nothing to do with "fairness" or an arbitrary upper limit on non-profit compensation, but a negotiation based on supply and demand.

For the sake, of argument, let's take it as a given that 1) he could easily earn the same amount or more somewhere else, and 2) if offered $1 less than $800k, he would walk. The question then becomes whether the organization could replace his value for the same or less money. i.e. could they hire someone else for $800k, much less a more "appropriate" salary, who would run things as effectively?

Maybe; I don't know enough to say. I might consider doing some research and putting more thought into the question before donating, but it doesn't seem out of the question for me that keeping on both the founder and someone with his level of experience would be worth that much or more.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by wegs on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:06AM (#22718676)
If Khan Academy did the same thing without Khan, I think it would work better, rather than worse. The personality-cult model is less scalable than the best-and-brightest model.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by buu700 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:10AM (#22718697)
I could see that, but I could also see Khan having unique value in terms of marketing, relationships, vision, and tribal knowledge.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by Upvoter33 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @09:40AM (#22718912)
Looks like most people here think the salary is reasonable. I'd be curious to see the reaction if he were making 8m / year instead of 800k. At what point would it seem like "too much"?
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by capitalist_here on Sunday March 29, 2020 @01:12PM (#22720635)
Think about this: Khan Academy is asking for increased donations right now because of their success. Any other for-profit company in their predicament is benefiting very naturally from revenues increasing with higher demand for their product. That is not true for a non profit structured at aiming to provide a free service.

Should a ceo reduce his income because his company is succeeding? The unfortunate element here is that their fundraising does not scale (or scale well enough) as a function of additional reach.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by amachefe on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:21AM (#22717769)
Are you not the one trolling?

So will the figure be less of it's he is doing the same work for a company?

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dmayle on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:30AM (#22717803)
Jimmy Wales takes $0. I know they're not in the same situation, but even half that salary provides an extravagant lifestyle. I don't think he should be poor, I just think that if he's asking people to give up their money to pay him to do what he's doing, than he should be more frugal with the money he's asking for
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by WanderPanda on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:41AM (#22717854)
He may ask for the money, you may consider his salary and decide not to donate and everybody goes his way. The comments here smell like there is a lot of acute jealousy floating around...
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by ipsum2 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:46AM (#22717889)
I don't think its jealousy. Millions of people became unemployed in the last 2-3 weeks, so it feels disingenuous to ask for money when he's making $800k when people are living off their savings.

It might be better to donate to a local school, food bank, or neighbors who are having a hard time instead.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by KMnO4 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:31AM (#22718451)
Khan Academy is the “local school” right now. Many classrooms are completely unprepared for remote teaching, and Khan Academy is providing relief to the millions of students and teachers having a hard time.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by ckdarby on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:45AM (#22718523)
Reread what you replied to,the same still applies.

It isn't like Khan is some religious cult and those unemployed people think they're now going to "hell" if they don't donate. Unemployed individuals will make a decision to donate or not.

There are also millions who are not unemployed and are WFH making good money, FAANG.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by wanda on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:44AM (#22717874)
Why run KA as a non-profit at all then?

If you run something for the common good, you extract whatever you need to live and to run the thing — not $800k.

At least, that's what I would do if I ran a non-profit, I would take only the money I need to live/perform my duties in the upkeep of the service.

Which would not be anywhere near $800k.

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by agustif on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:48AM (#22717893)
Well, sadly NGO are just financial investment types for people like that, they see they can get away with no IRS and donations and go for it...
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by dsparkman on Sunday March 29, 2020 @08:22AM (#22718384)
Yeah, it may seem high, but at the same time a lot of the content is still content he created. In that context, I think the number is reasonable. We use it as a huge part of the our home schooling at the house.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by abdulmuhaimin on Sunday March 29, 2020 @10:46AM (#22719406)
you make it seem like receiving $1mil salary and donating 100k as much more "noble" and worthy of donation request.

Mind you, even $1mil a year is miniscule compare to what he managed to achieve with the company. So thats already a lot donation that you cant see

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by noja on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:17AM (#22717753)
because....?
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by animalnewbie on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:26AM (#22717788)
He was a hotshot stock broker who would be making 10 times that. 0.8m isbarely respectful for him.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by onei on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:45AM (#22717880)
To me that speaks more about the wage disparity between normal folks and those working on Wall Street, etc. No one needs that much money, and someone willing to take such a pay cut yet still be well above the average only exposes that truth.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by lotsofpulp on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:20AM (#22718060)
It’s not a mystery that “normal folks’” work output doesn’t scale and is limited by time, whereas tech/math/science related work output scales with almost no marginal costs so it’s worth much more money per hour of labor.
Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by sumedh on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:24AM (#22718090)
> No one needs that much money

What if you want to buy more business/investments or fund startups?

Re:Khan Academy requests for donations as their servers are ... by maps7 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @07:32AM (#22718135)
Do you have a source? I will absolutely not donate if he's making that much. He should sacrifice his entire salary until this is over.

I encourage others not to donate too.