I will repeatedly and loudly criticize the US government response to COVID-19 so far as inept, particularly the FDA in the early days. Brittle laws combined with their failure to move quickly hamstrung our chance at containment.
Under normal circumstances though, health and safety oriented regulatory bodies such as the FDA play an absolutely essential role in protecting us from bad actors. The only reason I have confidence when purchasing medications of any sort is because of them. They also protect our food supply from all sorts of misguided and dangerous production practices.
Even in an emergency situation, they have an essential role to play in preventing bad actors from popping up left and right peddling snake oil. There certainly needed to be more flexibility and speed in responding to the current crisis, and I'd argue that states ought to have _significantly_ more autonomy in a number of areas, but that's a far cry from calling them irrelevant.
(As an aside, I was disappointed that none of the states defied the federal government in this instance. I had hoped for a state-level authorization for established medical labs to develop in house tests, and a subsequent court case challenging federal law on the matter. As far as I understand, the FDA only derives its authority from the frequently abused interstate commerce clause.)
Yeah, seriously. Every state is happy to defy DEA with marijuana. You'd have near universal support for defying FDA in this instance, and it would be a welcome breath of fresh air for the states, who have honestly been continuously disempowered by the federal government.
Does it though? There's a perception that government agencies are impartial watchdogs, but this belies the reality that governments have agendas of their own. The FDA is so politically removed from the people it was created to ostensibly protect that there's now little incentive for it to relieve real suffering today. A brief example:
My brother and thousands of people suffer from type-1 diabetes. We have had the technology for years now to create an artificial pancreas, but FDA and EMA regulatory procedures have stopped any device from being sold. People are creating their own DIY systems because no commercial, professionally-developed, reasonably-priced alternative exists yet.
This isn't snake oil. There are solutions for many people's ailments available today. And the FDA is a massive giant standing in the way of people living healthier, unencumbered lives.
Treat people like adults. On the whole they're pretty good at figuring out what's best for themselves and taking care of each other.
If I want to treat my (illegal war) PTSD, depression or anxiety with novel treatments like 2CB, LSD, or MDMA, that is my choice. It immoral to restrict my supply with the barrel of a gun.
That's exactly what makes them the most vulnerable. They are, in extreme conditions, desperate for a medicine and they'll lose sense because of that.
The fallacy that patients cannot act rationally in the face of adversity is a common excuse for compulsory regulatory bodies. While there is value in having a centralized body like the FDA provide consumers with qualified advice on drugs and food, a certification authority can provide that information for individuals to use at their own prerogative.
If you want that policy to change, it'll have to happen at the voting booth, not because some FDA bureaucrat decided it.
Like you could have looser requirements to enter the market and then penalize/ban companies/people that make bad/unsafe tests. (yes, I'm proposing that people involved in marketing useless medical tests be banned from doing it a second time. Might be hard to structure it, but the goal is clear enough).
https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2018/06/21/we...
And let’s see if my nastier, more cynical Derek-Against-Humanity prediction comes true: that the next wave will not be just people who have seized on this plan opportunistically, but who have targeted it right from the start. Who will pick out terrible diseases for which there are no therapies at all, the better to insure a supply of completely desperate patients and families, and provide them with utterly useless therapies at stiff, stiff prices. Utterly harmless therapies, though – don’t want to get sued while you’re raking in the bucks. I’m talking polysaccharide therapy for pancreatic cancer, antioxidant phytonutrients for Alzheimer’s: in other words, corn starch and grape juice. What the hell. The customers are going to die, anyway. Why should they die with their money as well?
Is that really so bad in 2020, when we have access to the information we actually need to learn about snake oil?
But should we expect the FDA itself to be immune to such manipulations?
Zero efficacy times a thousand equals...
That seems like a bad example to support your point. Nigerian scammers don't strike at random like lightning. If you aren't really stupid or really greedy, there is zero chance that you'll get scammed by those guys. They target people with poor cognitive abilities and people who are greedy enough to think they can scam the scammers.
They run dragnets looking for the rare individuals who vulnerable to their scheme. They are powerless if tasked to target a specific person unless that specific person by chance happens to be the sort of person their scheme works on.
I'm usually all for individual responsibility, but health is one of the rare things where you can't just rely on people being rational. It is very difficult to expect rational decision making based on evidence when it comes to a dying cancer patient desperate to find a cure. And it's very easy to see people profit from that.
Try starting with something less dangerous first like rolling your own ciphers for use in end-to-end encryption.
Is it fair to die in State X because it had more inept leaders than State Y? This isn't about long term economic or social policy, this is about an exponentially growing pandemic that doesn't respect borders.
Yes, which is to say it isn't fair. You're example argues for higher level oversight and uniformity of regulation, say at the EU level, not even more balkanization of them.
And consider the current circumstances: Yes, things are relaxed in an emergency. How would that be any different? State-level, or any level of oversight, would also be relaxed in an emergency. All that shows is that sensitivity to risk changes (decreases) when there is a crisis. It doesn't invalidate the greater level of care taken when there is the time to take it.
Also, no matter what level you impose oversight & regulation, patients will not be in a position to determine their desired level of risk. If it happens at the state level, there can still be plenty of people who would like a different risk threshold: They won't get it though.
Finally, it ignores the fact that what might be in the best interest of a more local jurisdiction (say, it costs less money) it might be very much against the best interests of others. A jurisdiction that decides it's comfortable with higher risk does not exist in a vacuum: It's comfort with higher risk would also bleed over into neighboring areas.
Far better to have a uniform set of guidelines and make exceptions on a case by case basis in emergencies, rather than make everything an exception, which would make coordination & consistency during a crisis a complete nightmare.
The big difference here is that the speed of finding the right drug can make or break trillions of dollars and thousands of lives, so it's critical for the FDA to focus on the COVID-19 illness.
Let entrepreneurs, doctors, and patients decide their individual risk level. I would rather have more options than less.
Edit: as an alternative to any knee jerk critism (I said "some"), why can't states handle this and the best emerge? I'm a big proponent of localism.