News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by closeparen on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:41AM (#22691596)
>Email is still a way better tool for long complex asynchronous opinionated discussions.

Every experienced and/or powerful person I've worked with felt and preached exactly the opposite: whatever happens, absolutely do not ever have a complex conversation over email. Pick up a phone, schedule a meeting, walk over to them, just make the decision unilaterally, literally anything else.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by atq2119 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:15AM (#22691764)
That may be your personal experience, but I doubt that it's universal.

Consider the reported policy at Amazon of requiring several pages of written document for every meeting in order to ensure the functioning of that meeting. That's a pretty strong emphasis on the asynchronously written word.

Apparently they still do have meetings, but that may be simply a vehicle for psychological alignment more than for actual detailed discussion.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by OJFord on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:24AM (#22691810)
Those documents are famously read synchronously in silence at the start of those meetings though.
Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by jessaustin on Thursday March 26, 2020 @10:19AM (#22693795)
I never worked there, but I wouldn't be surprised to find out some managers expect it to be read before the meeting so we can start it on time. Those managers would be likely to communicate that preference forcefully at the start of the meeting.
Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by closeparen on Thursday March 26, 2020 @01:14PM (#22695710)
Oh, there are plenty of cases where people ask me to write documents. They don’t read them though. They’re just props I’m expected to have when explaining verbally in the meeting.
Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by qznc on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:27AM (#22691832)
To make decisions quickly, I totally agree.

If you want to understand the why, it is essential to have it in writing.

If the problem is complex, then one guy writing for 30 minutes can provide more clarity than 5 discussing for an hour.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by growse on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:42AM (#22691931)
Email is a bad tool for discussion.

However, it can be a good tool for information dissemination. (There are better tools - I'd argue that sending information should be pull rather than push, but that's just my preference).

So yes, have a guy write something down for 30 minutes, get people to read it, and then have an actual conversation / chat about it.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by msla on Thursday March 26, 2020 @07:25AM (#22692442)
Email is a bad tool for discussion in that it lasts too long, and too many people can save copies; it's far better to have ephemeral and limited-distribution discussions, so if something obnoxious or actionable is said, nobody is opened up to legal actions.

The modern trend of people believing accusers is pushing against this wisdom, but it's still far better to not have evidence. That said, I'm sure Slack can be persuaded to destroy incriminating logs if the right pressure is applied. One of the benefits of people moving away from self-hosted solutions.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by closeparen on Sunday March 29, 2020 @04:03PM (#22722201)
Every enterprise-friendly messaging system offers configurable retention policies. Messages involving certain roles or keywords may need to be retained for years to comply with regulations, while others can be deleted after a few days to minimize risk.
Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by qznc on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:59PM (#22698415)
I completely agree with you. By writing I was thinking about RFCs not emails.

Have a face-to-face discussion and have a shared written document. If I have to chose between the two, the I would favor the written document though.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by lukethomas on Thursday March 26, 2020 @06:35AM (#22692199)
When collaborating over ambiguous topics where the potential to be misunderstood is high, you need to use the "richest" communication channel possible. Body language, facial expression, and the fast feedback loop can help you quickly establish a sense of common ground.

On the other hand, status updates or sharing of metrics/information can easily be done asynchronously, because the potential to be misunderstood is low. It's also a more scalable approach and persists over time.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by jrandm on Thursday March 26, 2020 @08:27AM (#22692829)
> When collaborating over ambiguous topics where the potential to be misunderstood is high, you need to use the "richest" communication channel possible. Body language, facial expression

I would dispute that body language and facial expression are somehow always correctly interpreted or unambiguous, like most forms of communication.

Written word, or a series of characters in a string, as I think we in a technical forum with many programmers in particular can appreciate, can in fact remove quite a bit of ambiguity if everyone is careful about what they type.

Github has many examples of this in-progress.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by mlindner on Thursday March 26, 2020 @07:43AM (#22692521)
I completely disagree. If the problem is complex you need to have an in person discussion on a white board rather than writing a long winded email that will mostly be filler information that the reader already knows. It probably won't even answer the issue the reader wanted to know either. And now you've wasted 30 minutes.
Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by jrandm on Thursday March 26, 2020 @08:23AM (#22692807)
Have you ever learned about something complex from a book?

That would imply you don't need a whiteboard and 10 minute meeting in order to transfer information to one another.

Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by closeparen on Sunday March 29, 2020 @06:35PM (#22723416)
Interesting question. I've tried to self-study from books alone, and it's never worked. The book always seems to work best in concert with the professor or TA's whiteboarding.
Re:What the last few weeks have been like for the CEO of Slack by qznc on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:53PM (#22698365)
Wasn't thinking about email but more about RFCs.

I have been in such whiteboard discussions. Then I had the same discussion again one week later because another one needed the information. And again. And again.

I have heard from such whiteboard decisions. Then I heard a very different conclusion from the same whiteboard decision. And another. And another.