Re:Ventilators 101: What they do and how they work
by jahewson on Wednesday March 25, 2020 @04:04PM
(#22688017)
What’s a “real engineer”? Railroad Engineer? Civil Engineer? Aerospace Engineer?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ventilators 101: What they do and how they work
by anonsubmit2671 on Wednesday March 25, 2020 @10:47PM
(#22690425)
Don't be cute. Professional Engineer / Chartered Engineer is a "real" engineer. A random coder calling themselves an "engineer" doesn't make them qualified to design and implement life-critical safety systems.
Re:Ventilators 101: What they do and how they work
by _delirium on Thursday March 26, 2020 @01:38AM
(#22690968)
Some countries have that norm, but in the United States, PE licensing is fairly unusual, due to rules allowing corporations to have one PE sign off on the work of a lot of engineers. As a result, even in the case of critical medical equipment, most of the real engineers who scoped, designed, and tested the product are not PEs.
Often the PE is more of a lawyer than an engineer. They typically do have an engineering degree, but are years out from any hands-on engineering work. They do final legal sign-off, and are knowledgeable about statutes and insurance policies, but rely on people with more recent technical experience to do any technical work.
Re:Ventilators 101: What they do and how they work
by wraithm112 on Friday March 27, 2020 @02:31PM
(#22705446)
Sure, I could imagine that is the case in fields like nuclear engineering. All the PEs I know are smart and have technical chops. Though, most of my PE friends are fairly young (early 30s) and are maybe on their way to that destination.
Re:Ventilators 101: What they do and how they work
by mcguire on Thursday March 26, 2020 @01:31PM
(#22695858)
"Some countries have that norm, but in the United States, PE licensing is fairly unusual, due to rules allowing corporations to have one PE sign off on the work of a lot of engineers."
Which is significantly stronger than the state of software engineering.
Re:Ventilators 101: What they do and how they work
by jariel on Thursday March 26, 2020 @11:58AM
(#22694864)
There is such a thing as Software Engineers, but most developers are not that.
Re:Ventilators 101: What they do and how they work
by Kalium on Wednesday March 25, 2020 @07:11PM
(#22689299)
In this case, I think it means someone with the perspective to think things through at a systems level and relevant domain expertise.
So, a medical device engineer.