News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by noonespecial on Sunday February 27, 2011 @03:59AM (#2267549)
There is a serious moral hazard faced by most administrators of the so called "heroic professions" (doctors, nurses, teachers, fire-fighters etc). The trouble is that their jobs involve taking care of people and a significant portion of their personal identity is wrapped up in this. Doctors will work extra unpaid hours "off the books" so patients won't suffer, teachers will buy classroom materials with their own money, fire-fighters will still respond to fires, even with inadequate safety gear etc.

Bureaucrats are more or less free to make whatever cuts they want in these professions because they know that those on the front lines will quietly mutter "I will work harder" and pick up the slack until the stress finally drives them from the profession entirely.

I've never once seen an employee of the DMV run out to kinkos and spend their own money because the copier was broken.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by mslate on Sunday February 27, 2011 @05:58AM (#2267656)
These "heroic professions" also share another common characteristic: they can do no wrong.

Doctors? They self-regulate the size of labor supply in their fields, inflating their salaries. Why do you think we have a doctor shortage? You really think there aren't enough smart people to do the job? No, the AMA controls the number of med school graduates each year by limiting the number of accredited medical schools. They also lobby governments to legislate that nurses can't perform medical procedures (all towards the not-so-discrete goal of preserving their six-figure salaries).

Teachers? They can't be fired thanks to tenure policies. This was the biggest issue with public schooling when I grew up, and [continues to be](http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/16/nyregion/16rubber.html?_r=...). Survive three years and you have job security for life. If my workplace hired and fired based on seniority, we would have gone bankrupt years ago.

Firefighters and policemen also can do no wrong--aside from amazing pensions they have great job security and the power to help those they know more than others in the event of disaster (e.g. Katrina).

For every example of those in the "heroic professions" doing the right thing, you have the same careerism and self-preservation that those in private industry strive for. But in many people's eyes, they can do no wrong.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by RBerenguel on Sunday February 27, 2011 @06:52AM (#2267696)
In part I agree with you. Tenure (which here in Spain is different: all public workers that got their job through examination can't be fired!) is a big problem. There are a lot of amazing teachers (I've had a lot in my life, since school through university), but there is a lot of lousy teachers (also had a lot of these) that do nothing and can't be fired. And the ones who love teaching (a few of my friends are math teachers) have to suffer more or less what the article says. Education always takes the blame, regardless of the quality of the teacher. Also, they have an increasing responsibility: parents no longer "educate" children (how to behave well, be quite, listen, be respective), it is something that now school teachers and HS teachers have to do, without any level of help from a lot of parents. A simple example, is that when a child gets some kind of "fine" (bad grade, a written note to her parents, whatever), most parents blame the teacher and don't believe "their little child" misbehaved.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by angus77 on Sunday February 27, 2011 @07:16AM (#2267715)
Are you sure that's "most parents"? The ones that have a good yell at their kids in the bedroom for their behaviour are the ones you won't hear about, and I suspect they're the majority. I know I don't expect schools to rear my children.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by MediaBehavior on Sunday February 27, 2011 @08:50AM (#2267821)
I don't know of a study that has quantified the "most" allegation. But what I have heard from relatives who teach (or resigned from teaching) in public schools is that a large enough number of parents take this approach and seem to come to the parent-teacher conference with the "my great kid is entitled to grade X" attitude... that teachers' authority/professionalism gets undermined.

Even worse when administrative does not have your (teacher's) back.

If you doubt that the Peter Principle still applies, spend some time in faculty meetings and check out the admins. There are exceptions, of course. But IMHO (observation) the "No more A-holes" rule is more honored in the breach than the observance.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by vacri on Monday February 28, 2011 @05:43AM (#2270826)
What you really mean is not "these professions can do no wrong", but "the media finds it difficult to blindly tar these professions the way it does to others".

Doctors can do no wrong? Is that why malpractise has help skyrocket the cost of medicine in the US? Doctor shortage a machiavellian plan to keep salaries high? Pull the other one. Yes, I do think that there aren't enough people with the smarts and the motivation to be a doctor - in fact I think that there are less of them than actually are doctors.

Policemen can do no wrong? Yes, in law courts they're seen that way, but I can guarantee you that plenty of people see police as doing plenty wrong. Police cop plenty of abuse.

And Teachers can do no wrong? Tenure or not, teachers cop it from students, administration and parents.

Firefighters can do no wrong? Meh, firefighters have the soft option. Cool toys and generally don't have to deal with the general public if they're not paramedics. Stick it to 'em :)

But really, the 'can help friends in Katrina' argument you make is just desperately clutching at straws. Not sure how this is a prime motivator for emergency personnel (I know a few, and this is not why they work in their respective forces) or as a 'can do no wrong' argument.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by potatolicious on Sunday February 27, 2011 @04:09AM (#2267557)
It applies to a lesser extent to what we do also - if I had a dollar for every time coders and designers were shortchanged on time by management, but we pulled extra hours anyways; 'cos goshdurnit, we take pride in doing things right.

It also reminds me of why I left the passion that led me to software - gaming. I did a lot of amateur game dev all through high school, even networked a fair bit with the local game studios and got some valuable mentorships out of the deal. But if there's any part of the engineering profession that screams of management abusing your love for your work, it's game development.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by neilk on Sunday February 27, 2011 @11:38AM (#2268157)
You're right that people have that attitude, but pride in one's work is more advantageous in our industry. We expect our jobs to be relatively short-term (five years at most). And with every job completed, even for failed projects, we learn something new, and probably portable. I don't need my former manager to prove that I know what the "this" keyword does in Javascript.

It's a lot harder to tell whether teachers are any good. I guess this is why they willingly submit to systems that privilege seniority.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by geekam on Sunday February 27, 2011 @09:43AM (#2267900)
Reminds me of Atlas Shurgged. Who us John Galt!?
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by nhangen on Sunday February 27, 2011 @11:59AM (#2268202)
I'd like to see someone explain why they downvoted the parent. Is it because everyone dislikes Rand, or because of the comment itself?
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by scrod on Sunday February 27, 2011 @02:31PM (#2268651)
I up-voted it because I thought it was supposed to be ironic.