News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by TomMckenny on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:03PM (#22670699)
Another point of evidence that the author probably omitted out of politeness are the nations that freely violated rules of war yet did not make (much) use of chemical weapons: the nazis on the eastern front and wwii japan.

Also another technology banned because it don't work is the hollow point bullet.

Apparently killing a solider outright is not as destructive as driving him long term onto the medical system. This is also one of the reasons caliber has generally been dropped over time. The 1950s move to the 223 round is pretty explicit on this.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by nordsieck on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:27PM (#22670862)
> Also another technology banned because it don't work is the hollow point bullet.

1. Hollow point bullets aren't banned. The US Army just adopted them recently - M1153.

2. Hollow point bullets are very effective compared to ball ammo. There is plenty of research that's been done on this (see Martin Fackler). However, pistols are much less effective than rifles.

> Apparently killing a solider outright is not as destructive as driving him long term onto the medical system. This is also one of the reasons caliber has generally been dropped over time. The 1950s move to the 223 round is pretty explicit on this.

1. This is a pervasive myth. There is absolutely no evidence of this from primary sources. The goal of shooting people is and has always been to kill them.

2. The reason calibers have dropped over time has nothing to do with making them less lethal. It's because they're lighter and smaller (easier to carry more of them), and they shoot flatter and faster (easier to hit targets).

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by cullenking on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:40PM (#22670930)
Hollow points are against the Geneva convention. The round you linked is only for use in special circumstances to prevent over penetration, Things like terrorist hostage rescue. They won’t and can’t be legally used in general warfare.

There was actually a big argument in the past over match grade rounds that have a dimpled front and a hollowed core, which keeps the weight toward the back of the round. They aren’t effective in hunting for the same reason they aren’t considered a hollow point by the military.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by nordsieck on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:55PM (#22671041)
> Hollow points are against the Geneva convention. The round you linked is only for use in special circumstances to prevent over penetration, Things like terrorist hostage rescue. They won’t and can’t be legally used in general warfare.

You're wrong.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollow-point_bullet#Legality

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by cullenking on Monday March 23, 2020 @10:00PM (#22671072)
Read the second paragraph of that section. And sorry, Hague convention not Geneva. Either way, only special circumstances aka special operations from my understanding, which is more like international policing than warfare.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by masonic on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @02:51AM (#22672617)
The USA is not a signatory to that Hague convention.

I don't know what the effect would be of USA participation in a NATO action using expanding small arms ammunition.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by cullenking on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @09:22AM (#22674596)
yeah I am certainly not an expert and I don’t know why the us military hasn’t used them, but they haven’t, and still aren’t going to from what I can read. I found that rabbit hole while researching hunting ammo, not because I am a military scholar or anything.

Seems kinda odd to me anyway, though I suppose limiting the damage a combatant receives while fighting isn’t a bad thing. Coming up with a stance makes you have to mentally address the concept of good vs bad guys, and I suppose I don’t see enemy fighters as bad people, just people fighting for differing ideals. That makes me tend to agree with rules that limit fatalities and excessive injury.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by int_19h on Saturday March 28, 2020 @05:55PM (#22714610)
The US military has authorized the use of hollow point rounds as needed. They just don't believe that it's necessary most of the time in combat. Which is entirely correct - modern FMJ rifle ammo achieves similar and better terminal ballistics via fragmentation, without sacrificing armor penetration or flight ballistics like hollowpoints. But for 9mm, the equation is different - hence why M1153 is a thing, and is issued broadly to military units.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by austincheney on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:44PM (#22670960)
> 1. This is a pervasive myth. There is absolutely no evidence of this from primary sources. The goal of shooting people is and has always been to kill them.

In a military context that is actually required by law, which I think is the fourth Geneva Convention. Combat forces are required to eliminate the enemy with minimal unnecessary suffering, which means the intention is always to kill and not injure.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by SlowRobotAhead on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @03:45AM (#22672868)
Between hollow points and ball ammo; the hollow points kill more than they wound. That part of the convention was written with feelings and not facts.

Also, does not apply; the US is not a signatory.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by leetcrew on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:59PM (#22671062)
regarding 2), it's my understanding that hollow point is not very effective against targets wearing armor, and also that they are indeed prohibited outside of situations where overpenetration of structures is a concern. seems to fit the pattern.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by nordsieck on Monday March 23, 2020 @10:06PM (#22671123)
> it's my understanding that hollow point is not very effective against targets wearing armor

While that's true, the hollow point doesn't make a difference. Essentially all pistol ammo is bad at penetrating armor. What does make a (small) difference is velocity; you can see this by looking at ratings for NIJ level IIa and IIIa armor.

This is why pistol ammo that's designed to penetrate soft armor like 5.7mm is so small and light weight - it needs to be really fast. I'm sure the pointed shape helps a bit, but it's the speed that really does the job. That's also why it's garbage compared to normal ammo against unarmored targets.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by int_19h on Saturday March 28, 2020 @05:59PM (#22714641)
Lehigh makes lightweight and faster-than-usual 9mm ammo that can punch through IIIa, as well, without sacrificing terminal ballistics. The only problem is that it's expensive ( comparable to match rifle ammo), because the bullets have to be individually precision-machined to produce the necessary shape.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by leetcrew on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @08:55AM (#22674423)
interesting, I always thought it was less effective than other pistol ammo because it would begin expanding against the vest. TIL.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by Tuna-Fish on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @07:13AM (#22673853)
> Also another technology banned because it don't work is the hollow point bullet.

They work just fine in inducing fragmentation and thus producing greater terminal effects. It's just that armies found out that they can induce fragmentation just fine using a different mechanism that does not have a Hague convention rule against it, and so are using that instead.

Almost all modern military rounds make use of yaw-induced fragmentation, where they are designed to fly stable in air but not in flesh, and so very rapidly yaw in tissue until they are going sideways, in which direction the bullet does not have sufficient structural strength to stay intact, and so fragments. This has essentially the same effect on the target as using hollow points.

> The 1950s move to the 223 round is pretty explicit on this.

This is false. Because of better yaw characteristics, the 5.56 as adopted had similar lethality as the rounds it replaced, at the expected combat ranges. The problems with 5.56 lethality that have been reported were that the M4 carbines adopted later had too short barrels for the rounds the military was using, and the lower muzzle velocity achieved resulted in impacts where the bullets failed to fragment properly.

[dead]
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by TomMckenny on Monday March 23, 2020 @10:19PM (#22671199)
>Are you really pretending the US, Britain, Soviet Union, etc didn't freely violate the "rules of war" also

No but The US and UK are far less notorious and so are not as good examples.

> Also, the nazis aren't a nation

Given the foulness of the topic but limited space, I wanted to emphasize the enormous difference between the Germans and Japanese of today vs 80 years ago. In retrospect, I should have written Tojo instead of Japan even though he is not a country either.

[dead]
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by dang on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @02:06AM (#22672413)
Please don't post in the flamewar style to HN. We ban accounts that do that, and you've unfortunately been breaking the site guidelines in other places too. If you wouldn't mind reviewing them and using HN in the intended spirit only, we'd be grateful.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by scarejunba on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:37PM (#22670909)
It isn't singling out, dude. It's just an example. Obviously from the guys avoiding signing anti-cluster-munitions and anti-landmines you can tell that they're all concerned about their military effectiveness.

Fine, go ahead and say that Admiral Donitz only got away because we used Unrestricted Submarine Warfare just as much as he did. Okay. There we go. Now we're all even.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by FillardMillmore on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:46PM (#22670967)
Give the man his due. That's Führer Donitz to you. Even if it was for a shorter period of time than William Henry Harrison fighting a cold after a a chilly wind.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by fuckface123 on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:25PM (#22670851)
"Nazis" in the context of WWII is commonly understood to mean the nation of Germany under control of the Nazi party.
Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by viklove on Monday March 23, 2020 @11:31PM (#22671602)
I think people just generally have a lot less sympathy for literal Nazis, who the Germans voted into power, and any aggressors in a military campaign. America didn't just nuke Japan out of nowhere, the Japanese opened the door to that when they bombed pearl harbor and attempted to conquer the Pacific.

When the bad guys get what's coming to them, people don't feel so bad about it. And don't pretend civilians are completely innocent in these cases. You blame Americans for voting Trump into power, right? Then you also have to blame Germans for putting Hitler into power, and the Japanese for supporting their leaders' violent colonialism. The conflict was hugely popular on the home front in Japan. Until they started losing, of course.

Japan and Germany were not the victims of WWII.

Re:Why Don’t We Use Chemical Weapons Anymore? by lopmotr on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:19AM (#22671877)
Who ever identifies themselves as the bad guys? Even an aggressor has an excuse for why he believes he's morally right. The US invading Afghanistan for instance was obviously the aggressor but blamed the victim for deserving it. The Nazis blamed their victims too and their victims did do things to deserve it, in some sense. Your simple goodies vs baddies view is wrong.

I agree with your point about blaming voters though. In a democracy, politicians are only a reflection of what voters demand. They don't have much independent power themselves. Even in a non-democratic country, the populace is tacitly supporting their leaders and placing their immediate personal safety ahead of the enemies of their leaders.