News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life Without Photoshop by matt1 on Saturday February 26, 2011 @09:58AM (#2265643)
Plug: I'm building a web-based mockup tool called jMockups [1], which my long term goal is to supplant Photoshop as the high fidelity mockup tool of choice.

If you have qualms with Photoshop and can entertain the possibility of a better tool coming along, I'd really, really, really love to hear your thoughts on jMockups, what I can do to improve it, and how it can become a tool so phenomenal that it wouldn't make sense for you not to switch from Photoshop. Email me at [email protected].

[1] http://www.jmockups.com

PS: New feature you might like: Instantly convert almost any website to a mockup so you can redesign it in minutes: http://www.jmockups.com/websiteconverter

Re:Life Without Photoshop by Andrex on Saturday February 26, 2011 @03:06PM (#2266375)
Sounds great, just signed up to try it. Two questions:

1. What's with the "j"? Makes it sound like it was written in Java...

2. Any thoughts of turning the website converter bookmarklet into a Chrome extension? Would be cleaner and seem more secure for users.

Re:Life Without Photoshop by matt1 on Saturday February 26, 2011 @04:17PM (#2266550)
1. "j" is for JavaScript. Think jQuery.

2. No need -- the bookmarklet is easier to install and works cross browser. I'd bet that most people competent enough to install a Chrome extension can also install a bookmarklet. Also, seem more secure != more secure.

Appreciate the feedback. Let me know what else I can do to make it better.

Re:Life Without Photoshop by Andrex on Saturday February 26, 2011 @04:35PM (#2266584)
Could I make it a Chrome extension? :P Could be official or unofficial, I have my bookmark bar hidden so an extension would fit better with my workflow.
Re:Life Without Photoshop by jdp23 on Saturday February 26, 2011 @10:09AM (#2265664)
Seems intriguing. How would you compare/contrast with Balsamiq?
Re:Life Without Photoshop by matt1 on Saturday February 26, 2011 @10:23AM (#2265691)
Balsamiq is for designing low fidelity mockups (wireframes) whereas jMockups is for designing high fidelity (pixel perfect) mockups. It makes more sense to compare jMockups to Photoshop than Balsamiq.

That being said, I can pretty effortlessly pivot from focusing on high fidelity to low fidelity. Right now I'm considering adding a toggle button that lets you switch back and forth, but am not sure if I want to go down that path yet. Do one thing well, right?

Re:Life Without Photoshop by selectnull on Saturday February 26, 2011 @03:18PM (#2266414)
I've played with jMockups demo and as a Balsamiq user I can say that one of its best features is "low fidelity", specifically lines that look hand drawn and comic sans font. That combo is what I consider most important in mockups: when you give that to a client, it's very clear that it's not a product, it's a mockup.

If you can make that kind of low fidelity, I think you would have very good mockup tool. Of course, seeing what you have right now, I can understand your thinking in pursuing high fidelity route.

Re:Life Without Photoshop by matt1 on Saturday February 26, 2011 @04:20PM (#2266556)
Thanks for checking it out.

Can you elaborate on your last sentence? Of course, seeing what you have right now, I can understand your thinking in pursuing high fidelity route.

Re:Life Without Photoshop by selectnull on Sunday February 27, 2011 @09:37AM (#2267881)
I meant to say I agree with you saying doing one thing well might be a better choice for your product.

I liked what I saw in jMockups, I like how it works, and it's pretty fast. But I wouldn't use it as a tool to create mockups that I have to present to a client (that doesn't mean somebody else has the same kinds of clients or same needs as me), for the reasons it looks too real. Like I said, Balsamiq's greatest feature is that mockups look "hand drawn", what you called "low fidelity", one might call it almost childish.

You said jMockups and Balsamiq are less comparable than jMockups and Photoshop. I agree. So maybe you shouldn't pivot from focusing on high fidelity to low fidelity but excel in what you already do.

Re:Life Without Photoshop by matt1 on Sunday February 27, 2011 @03:58PM (#2268935)
Appreciate it -- thanks :)
Re:Life Without Photoshop by jdp23 on Saturday February 26, 2011 @10:29AM (#2265701)
Very clear explanation, and agreed on doing one thing well. It'll be a lot easier to to leadership in the high-fidelity mockup segment, and then use that as a base to expand if it makes business sense.