News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by Broken_Hippo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @11:25AM (#22655609)
I don't really understand why that's an argument against it. We do permanent things all the freaking time. Holes in earlobes and tattoos. We remove - and sometimes install - teeth! We patch folks up with metal, install breast and butt implants, install electronics to help hearts and brains. We suck away fat! Not all of these are minor cosmetic surgeries - some are major surgeries and optional!

And besides, if it weren't permanent, why would one go through the pain of the surgery in the first place? I'd actually argue that if the permanence is something that bothers you, this is certainly not something you would personally consider, but it certainly isn't really an argument against it being available for the wider population.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by rsynnott on Sunday March 22, 2020 @07:10PM (#22659656)
Most of the things you mention are fairly safe and have limited impact on the person’s life; the exception would be the heart and brain procedures (some are safe, some not), but those aren’t cosmetic; they’re necessary.

I’d be wary of most cosmetic surgery, but this is probably about the most extreme form.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by Broken_Hippo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @08:30PM (#22660171)
I would personally not do such a surgery myself - it is a major surgery. So is breast reduction, honestly (have looked into it). But I'm not about to say my choice needs to be other people's choice.

But that's really besides the point: Once we die, none of it matters, and that was my point.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by Barrin92 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @02:28PM (#22657266)
>Holes in earlobes and tattoos.

These are methods of self-expression. (usually) people get tattoos because they want to remember something or because they like the aesthetics of it.

Breaking your legs or enlarging your breasts is done (often I'd say, not necessarily always) to attract others and to try to appeal to some beauty standard. There is a huge difference between self-assertion and trying to satisfy others expectations. The former is healthy, the latter is insecurity and making self-worth dependent on how one appeals to others in the most banal way is one of the most harmful things you can do arguably.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by naasking on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:54PM (#22658030)
> get tattoos because they want to remember something or because they like the aesthetics of it. [...] Breaking your legs or enlarging your breasts is done [...] to appeal to some beauty standard

So... Because they like the aesthetic? Some people also get tattoos because they want to look tough, or fit into a certain crowd. You can find unhealthy and healthy expressions of both tattoos and cosmetic surgery. I doubt very much that you have firm numbers that one is far more likely than the other to be a healthy expression of aesthetics.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by Barrin92 on Sunday March 22, 2020 @05:18PM (#22658754)
I mean it's even hard for me to discern what the aesthetic is of making yourself taller. There's not much expression of anything in it.
Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by Broken_Hippo on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:56AM (#22662453)
When my hair was blue (or purple, or bright red, or whatever), I had people tell me that I'd be pretty if only I didn't have that hair color. If only I looked more natural. And that's OK, they didn't need to understand. I was happy with it, and I didn't need those folks to find me attractive nor need their permission.

If breast reduction surgery was cheaper and less invasive, I would have had it long ago. It'd be nice not to have to order bras or go to special stores. Or to fit into normal clothing more often. Plus, I'd be slightly happier with my shape. Not everyone would see the aesthetic of it, nor would anyone really say there is expression in it - but what the frick does that matter? It is my body and my life. I'm not sure how this is any different. It doesn't matter if I would get the surgery or not - I'd not do a lot of things others do.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by naasking on Monday March 23, 2020 @01:20AM (#22661456)
Being a few inches taller changes your perspective of the world. You could go from average height to towering over most people. Don't underestimate the confidence and social and financial benefits that can bring.

Also, if you have to justify what you want to do to your own body by "expression", are you no longer allowed to decide what you want to eat, or whether you are allowed to sun tan? It's an absurd requirement for agency.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by Barrin92 on Monday March 23, 2020 @02:39PM (#22667183)
Desire for confidence and status is exactly what I'm critizing because it makes people's notion of self-worth dependent on how they're perceived by others. What if your alleged signal of status changes because culture changes? Make yourself two inches shorter again?

Any mature conception of expression entails that you ask yourself if you're expressing yourself for your own sake or if you're molding yourself to the expectations of others.

Having genuine autonomy and agency means inquiring yourself if what you're doing is something you actually want, or you only think you want because it confers status. It's not obvious at all that everything you superficially want also makes you genuinely happy or if it's the product of some mimetic desire.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by naasking on Monday March 23, 2020 @03:43PM (#22667921)
There is no coherent notion of "for one's own sake" that includes only values or behaviours that you think are healthy and excludes only those that you think are unhealthy. I could just as easily argue that your criteria for self-expression is maladaptive narcissism.

The question of health is determined by individual outcome, not according to some a priori definition. If the outcome yields positive long-term physical, emotional or behavioural changes, then the person is healthier. This will include decisions based on status, self-expression, or anything else you may approve or disapprove of.

One could argue that perhaps status-seeking reasons typically yield less healthy outcomes when compared to self-expression reasons, but that nuance hasn't been in the discussion so far.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by leftyted on Sunday March 22, 2020 @11:48AM (#22655837)
Because you're going to die and your body is going to decay and those extra inches mean absolutely nothing.
Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by BurningFrog on Sunday March 22, 2020 @01:43PM (#22656840)
By this argument, any activity during your life means absolutely nothing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proving_too_much

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by leftyted on Sunday March 22, 2020 @03:50PM (#22657997)
That doesn't even remotely follow from what I wrote.

But thanks for your very helpful link to wikipedia.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by Broken_Hippo on Sunday March 22, 2020 @11:56AM (#22655895)
Neither does any of the rest of it, honestly. Tattoos decay. It won't matter that you got tooth implants. Your pacemaker won't matter, it'll be recycled or trashed. Most of us will just be forgotten. And that's all OK.

But things like that can mean that while you were alive, you were happier.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by leftyted on Sunday March 22, 2020 @12:05PM (#22655979)
I think tattoos and piercings are stupid for the same reason.

Dental surgeries can make you look normal and improve function. Pacemakers help you live longer.

There are things that regular people can do that will survive their deaths. Mostly, having children. But also having close relationships with other people who will remember you, tell stories about you, and so on. I expect plenty of people on HN will write code that will survive them.

Re:Radical surgery permanently extends your legs by nitrogen on Sunday March 22, 2020 @12:48PM (#22656334)
If it's true that people have a bias toward taller people, then becoming taller might help someone get those children and close relationships you mention. I have no tattoos, but it seems they can also help build camaraderie in the right setting.