News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by scotty79 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:07PM (#22633147)
> "... Tell people to stay at their homes, get depressed, commit suicide, domestic violence. Who knows? Child abuse, children losing their education, ..."

This is so funny. It kind of reminds me warnings about anticipated dangers of early trains:

Critics of early steam-spewing locomotives, for example, thought “that women’s bodies were not designed to go at 50 miles an hour,” and worried that “[female passengers’] uteruses would fly out of [their] bodies as they were accelerated to that speed”—which, for the record, they did and will not.

https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/67806/early-trains-were-...

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by ggggtez on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:32PM (#22633669)
So you are saying that you know for certain that keeping children home from school... cannot deprive them of an education? And keeping billions of people home, unable to socialize for months, with no end in sight... won't increase depression and anxiety? I'd like to know how you came to those conclusions...

Frankly, the discussion about trains has nothing to do with anything, and should be disregarded. "Once upon a time someone was wrong about something, therefore this person is wrong about an unrelated thing" is silly.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by scotty79 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:11PM (#22633887)
I'm pretty sure kids will be fine despite spending more time with their parents. Vast differences in educational requirements of different countries assure me that possibly whole years of primary education are worth nothing. Besides, main concerns when it comes to closing schools clearly showed that schools are not so much places of education but most importantly storage pens for children so they don't bother their adults.

People who seek knowledge have internet.

And keeping billions at home to socialize just with people who live with them and with people who they can call and connect through internet won't increase on average depression and anxiety any more than going out currently does.

I came to this conclusion by living at home as vast number of people do.

His statements reminded me of the train scare because people had wild theories because they didn't know any better.

This guy should have lived at home and should know it's not some hostile environment you are barely able to spend a night in but must escape every morning or you'll surely go insane. Home for most people is the most cozy place in the world and it's filled with their most favorite people, pets and items.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by viklove on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:50PM (#22634164)
> unable to socialize for months

This is so far from the truth, and it's surprising considering where you're posting. Discord, Skype, Facetime, Facebook, Twitter and Reddit are all places where people can socialize during a quarantine. You're not analyzing the problem properly.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by wyattpeak on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:35PM (#22633686)
These are not anticipated dangers. These are well-documented dangers. Keeping depressed people away from human contact is damned dangerous. Locking people up in houses with abusers for weeks on end is damned dangerous.

That's not to say that quarantining is necessarily the wrong move. But these are very legitimate concerns, and need to be kept in mind in decision-making.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by scotty79 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:15PM (#22633908)
Vast majority of people are not depressed, are not abused and do not live with their abusers. If your home is unsafe for you that's an individual case by case problem that should be resolved locally and individually, not something that should be taken into account while shaping global policy.
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by wyattpeak on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:40PM (#22634069)
I don't understand your logic. If you believe that policy* shouldn't be influenced by considerations like depression and abuse, why do we have policy about them at all?

The majority of people aren't depressed, yet we have all sorts of public facilities to help them. Do you think we shouldn't?

* You say global policy, but none of this is global policy - it's all national policy.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by scotty79 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @11:14PM (#22634343)
Policy that attempts to help with depression pertains to depressed not everybody.

Policies that affect everybody don't take into account special needs of various groups because there are so many groups with conflicting needs.

You make one general policy and if that poses some challenge for some special needs group you make another policy for them.

"Stay at home" for everybody. That causes problems for abused? Then make additional policy that ramps up services and education that helps people get away from their abusers. Who knows maybe even occasional contact with police that enforces quarantine will bring their abuse to attention?

Maybe depressed will need special allowances for leaving the house? Maybe not.

What about all the introverts and socially anxious people that will be relieved that their employer is now forced to offer them remote job?

But we can't have global decision that vastly improves something for everybody blocked just because in its unamended form it might worsen conditions for some people.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by MikeAmelung on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:18PM (#22633920)
Vast majority of people weren't at risk from this disease until we collapsed the economy, sooo...
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by scotty79 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:27PM (#22633973)
All people were at risk from this disease since it first popped up in bats.

Since then, for all humans, it was and it is just a question of when not if.

And few smart humans knew this even before this virus came into existence.

And economy is completely secondary.

Covid being leading cause of death in Italy now has nothing to do with any covid induced economy collapse.