Re:What we know about Mac OS X Lion
by sans-serif on Friday February 25, 2011 @01:06PM
(#2263112)
It doesn't make sense only because you put it in terms of some completely abstract and made-up notion of "scrolling the window". Put another way:
One finger drags the cursor up and down
Two finger drags the underlying page up and down
Four finger drags the underlying space left, right, up or down
Perfectly consistent, no? I won't argue that forcing people to relearn scrolling is an uphill battle. But I'm a Dvorak typist.
It's one way to look at it. I'm used to the behavior of the scroll wheel, and also the scroll keys - moving the cursor down will necessarily move the underlying page up to keep it visible, so that equates to 'scrolling down' in my mind. This was completely logical until smartphones came along. Obviously Apple are finding a lot of their users believe (or soon will believe) otherwise.
I am not sure this will feel that inconsistent:
- Page Up scrolls the page down
- Up arrow (eventually) scrolls the page down, too.
Looking at it that way, the only exception is be single finger drag. I guess that 'has' to be that way because otherwise dragging a finger down a bit would be too different from lifting it shortly, then clicking a bit down.
The new scrolling isn't totally incompatible with scroll wheel usage, if you're willing to overthink it a little bit. Imagine that the scroll wheel is resting on the page, and that by applying upward/forward movement to the top of the wheel, you apply downward force to the page, moving your viewing pane higher on the page. Like so: http://imgur.com/245lA
It also runs counter to scroll wheels on mice, which has a physical reason for the direction too.