News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by thulecitizen on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:51PM (#22624251)
> the Primary Dealer Credit Facility (PDCF) [...] the cash-for-trash facility, where Wall Street’s toxic waste from a decade of irresponsible trading and lending, will be purged from the balance sheets of the Wall Street firms and handed over to the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve

Yay let's subsidize Wall Street using public funds! "We can't afford universal healthcare", but we can totally - yet unnaturally - bail out (mostly rentier) capitalist businesses that have been reckless and parasitical.

Why not just let them die?

Has anyone watched the movie Margin Call?

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by runawaybottle on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:58PM (#22624301)
The root issue you are describing never gets the public’s attention during normal times. It’s an emergency right now, so we have to do it, but look - fuck the average person, they don’t give a fuck when things are fine. They don’t vote on real issues, and when shit hits the fan, I honestly don’t know anymore. It’s a seriously undereducated and literally unconscious public. We’ll forget about the underlying issues by summer.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by randomdude402 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:10AM (#22624384)
Agree.

There was a Reddit thread a day or two ago asking something along the lines of, "How is this pandemic going to change the future forever?"

People had some really wild ideas about how the population at large was going to have these revelations about globalization, the economy, their expenditures, travel, caring about one another, UBI, social norms, voting habits...

I don't know if these people were too young to notice around 2008 or what, but my prediction is that people will be only too happy to be able to be served a cheeseburger and a beer in a restaurant or bar, where they will bitch about the past few months for a couple weeks before promptly forgetting any of it happened.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by runawaybottle on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:12AM (#22624396)
Right, like if you think society is going to ponder ‘hey remember when our society went to shit because we all stopped going to restaurants for a month? Haha, weird, what a fragile economy/social system, wonder if we should figure that one out’ - not gonna happpen.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:43AM (#22624548)
This one's a bit interesting, because everybody is staying home. Disproportionately many people, who still have jobs waiting for them when this is over but aren't doing them right now, so right now they have time to organize.

That hasn't really happened since the internet has existed.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by thulecitizen on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:03AM (#22624339)
What a great story to justify robbing other people. Keep telling that to yourself if it helps you sleep at night.

In my experience, this sounds like grandiosity talking.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by runawaybottle on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:08AM (#22624371)
You’re suggesting an alternative that compounds the current collapse. The end goal of that is just total collapse.

This is the alternative you are suggesting? I enjoy making straw man arguments, it’s my favorite usually.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by thulecitizen on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:19AM (#22626744)
> The end goal of that is just total collapse.

So then you agree that capitalism with it's overly parasitic rentier/usury mechanisms is a ponzi scheme, waiting to collapse?

After collapse, hopefully we have a transition to a p2p mutual credit paradigm.

"They assert a belief in ‘free markets’ and want us to believe that economic policies are extending them. That is untrue. Today we have the most unfree market system ever created. It is deeply corrupt because its leaders claim it is the opposite of what it is becoming."

"How can politicians look into TV cameras and say we have a free market system when patents guarantee monopoly incomes for twenty years, preventing anyone from competing? How can they claim there are free markets when copyright rules give a guaranteed income for seventy years after a person’s death? How can they claim free markets exist when one person or company is given a subsidy and not others, or when they sell off the commons that belong to all of us, at a discount, to a favoured individual or company, or when Uber, TaskRabbit and their ilk act as unregulated labour brokers, profiting from the labour of others?

Far from trying to stop these negations of free markets, governments are creating rules that allow and encourage them. That is what this book is about."

"…today, a tiny minority of people and corporate interests across the world are accumulating vast wealth and power from rental income, not only from housing and land but from a range of other assets, natural and created. ‘Rentiers’ of all kinds are in unparalleled ascendancy and the neo-liberal state is only too keen to oblige their greed.

Rentiers derive income from ownership, possession or control of assets that are scarce or artificially made scarce. Most familiar is rental income from land, property, mineral exploitation or financial investments, but other sources have grown too. They include the income lenders gain from debt interest; income from ownership of ‘intellectual property’ (such as patents, copyright, brands and trademarks); capital gains on investments; ‘above normal’ company profits (when a firm has a dominant market position that allows it to charge high prices or dictate terms); income from government subsidies; and income of financial and other intermediaries derived from third-party transactions."

- Guy Standing

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by lettergram on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:56PM (#22624290)
These are loans not bail outs. Low interest sure, but not outright handouts. Additionally, a lot of the customers these companies lend to are about to default. Those low interest loans will not save a company if they can't also survive those defaults.

Not saying companies weren't irresponsible or that it's "unfair", but it isn't the worst proposal.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by BoiledCabbage on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:34AM (#22624806)
What's do you call a loan than never has to be repaid?
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by thulecitizen on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:00AM (#22624321)
It's funny how the most capitalist people I know can't see the hypocrisy when I use their neo-liberal arguments of 'meritocracy' and 'pull your boots up by your bootstraps' to show the contradiction in their arguments for a government funded bailout.

Wall Street loves socialism for bankers!

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by AmericanChopper on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:19AM (#22624435)
To describe the idea of monetary policy as socialism, is not consistent with any definition of socialism that I’ve ever heard.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by jlmorton on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:55PM (#22624273)
I know, personally I think in the midst of the largest world crisis of the past fifty years, the prudent thing to do is let the banks all fail, which will really teach them a lesson about not properly preparing for the totally-predictable near-halting of global commerce.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by totalZero on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:20AM (#22624445)
A bank failure often means that a better bank steps in to buy the failed bank's assets or divisions.

Take a look at what happened to Lehman Brothers in 2008.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by teh_infallible on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:54PM (#22624265)
It’s about as logical as dealing with a health issue by plunging everyone into poverty and destroying all small businesses.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by thulecitizen on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:56PM (#22624283)
Well then we would at least finally get a massive inheritance in the form of the formerly corporate-owned patents!
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by piiswrong on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:56PM (#22624287)
Because they are more important than the goverment. If the big banks die the entire US economy dies with them.

Why Americans would let a few bankers wield such power and be accountable to no one is another question.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by waterhouse on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:03AM (#22624344)
> If the big banks die the entire US economy dies with them.

Can you clarify exactly how this happens? This has been claimed before, that these banks are "too big to be allowed to fail", but I haven't seen an explanation of why, and it is certainly in the interest of the banks to promulgate the idea "if we die it's the apocalypse" regardless of whether it's true.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by piiswrong on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:14AM (#22624411)
Because of fractional reserve banking. 90% of the money in your bank account are in fact credit created by the private banks out of thin air. If the banks fail, 90% of the money in the entire system will suddenly disappear. Imagine that.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by waterhouse on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:23AM (#22624452)
I'm not necessarily a fan of how things currently work, but I believe the FDIC is supposed to insure up to $250k on each bank account. That would seem to mean it wouldn't hurt most people, only people (and institutions?) that put much more than that into individual bank accounts. I suspect most of those would have also put lots into other types of investments, so I don't think anyone would be completely wiped out. That doesn't sound apocalyptic to me.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by dragonwriter on Thursday March 19, 2020 @02:47AM (#22625143)
> I believe the FDIC is supposed to insure up to $250k on each bank account.

Close, it's actually $250K per depositor per ownership category per institution. Multiple accounts in the same category don't add insurance limits.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by manigandham on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:41AM (#22624843)
The economy is far more than just people's personal checking accounts, and many people do accumulate more than that over their life.

The loss of money in the commercial sector means (after a series of cascading failures) we're all unemployed and burning dollars to stay warm.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by vadym909 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:24AM (#22624454)
Why would it disappear. It would be auctioned off to the lowest bidder- maybe the debtor itself.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by mirimir on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:08AM (#22624682)
Can't the government always print ten times as much?
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by whatever1 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:24AM (#22624453)
so the prices of goods/ services will have to adjust accordingly. No issues there.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by AmericanChopper on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:28AM (#22624488)
I have no idea how this became such a popular misconception. Fractional reserve banking allows banks to use a portion of their deposits to make loans. This doesn’t create money out of thin air. It does affect money supply, but in a completely different way. Because deposits are withdrawn from circulation, and loans allow a percentage of that to be returned to circulation. If a bank folded, it would simply have a list of debtors (loan holders), and creditors (depositors). The value of the liabilities may exceed the value of the assets (in which case it would be insolvent), but no money at all will be withdrawn from existence.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by runawaybottle on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:19AM (#22624437)
Banks collapsing in this crisis exacerbates confidence issues. The market operates on perceived confidence. There are already morons, sorry, my misanthropy is just peaking lately, the general public are already withdrawing cash from banks, stocking up on toilet paper. A real intellectual bunch we’re talking about here.

Whether things are solvent or not, right now everything has to look like it’s totally under control. Perception is very critical here.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by waterhouse on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:33AM (#22624511)
So, if a couple of banks collapse and many people lose confidence, then exactly who gets hurt and how? If a bunch of "morons" go pull their money out of a bank, that might ruin the bank, but FDIC insurance is supposed to protect against the worst of that. What's the path that leads to the "entire US economy dying"?
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by runawaybottle on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:46AM (#22624564)
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by notriddle on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:01AM (#22624641)
Yes, I think most folks here know what a back run is. The FDIC was instituted after the Depression specifically to limit the damage caused by bank runs.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by manigandham on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:39AM (#22624833)
Better to avoid the damage in the first place.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:22AM (#22624748)
2008 was a completely different circumstance than this.

People have a tendency to call everything a bank. Lehman Brothers was an investment bank. AIG is an insurance company. They were buying and selling mortgages and credit default swaps, but they weren't savings banks or mortgage banks.

What happened in 2008 was that the mortgage banks (spurred on by government policy) were making mortgage loans to everybody. People with bad credit. Interest only payments. Because the regular banks were selling the mortgages to Lehman Brothers or buying credit default swaps from AIG, so they didn't care if people would default. This naturally caused housing prices to soar.

Then interest rates went up a little and people did start to default. Then people started to notice how uncreditworthy those borrowers were and didn't want to buy those mortgages anymore ("toxic assets"), so banks stopped making them. Which tends to cause housing prices to crash, which tends to lead to more defaults as people notice they're underwater, and so on.

If housing prices came down a lot there would be too many defaults, so the Fed responded by lowering interest rates. That gets people to borrow more and bid up housing prices again, but that's only kicking the can down the road unless they plan to leave interest rates low indefinitely... except that's just what they did.

Meanwhile they also had to do something about the companies selling these credit default swaps, which were basically insurance banks bought against having their borrowers default. If AIG went bankrupt then so would all of these actual mortgage banks who they had insured and were about to have claims to file. And if all these mortgage banks went bankrupt -- even though they were the ones being smart and buying these credit default swaps -- investors would start to view mortgage lending as a risky investment in general. That would tend to raise mortgage interest rates, because investors would demand a higher return for this newfound risk. But they needed lower interest rates to keep housing prices from crashing and causing defaults/foreclosures, so they bailed out the dumb investors and insurance companies to save the "smart" mortgage banks who didn't expect their insurance scheme to be so successful that it bankrupted the insurance company.

This time, in 2020, it isn't a question of bailing out some insurance companies. The problem right now is that nobody really wants to borrow more money, despite literally zero interest rates, because they've been so low for so long that everybody is already leveraged to the hilt. But we're also experiencing deflationary forces from this coronavirus, which generally requires some kind of inflationary force to counter it and prevent a deflationary spiral -- commonly done by lowering interest rates to increase borrowing, except that everybody's already tapped out.

So what that leaves is having the government counter deflation by creating new money, and ideally give it directly to real people and not Wall St which has no excuse whatsoever to get it this time.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:58PM (#22624298)
Perhaps “die” is the wrong word. I prefer “nationalized and converted to financial utilities”. Shareholders? Gone! Existing management? Gone! Put adults in charge and have a relationship similar to the USPS or the Fed. Require an open platform so the APIs and underlying back office are solid but innovators can still get access to innovate (Europe mandated this via PSD2).
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by piiswrong on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:00AM (#22624320)
But nationalizing private business is the symbol of communism! How dare you say such a thing!
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by manigandham on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:45AM (#22624559)
Please give some examples where this has worked out well.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:01AM (#22624329)
Everyone is a socialist during a financial crisis.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by piiswrong on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:10AM (#22624387)
but after the crisis do you give it back to the shareholders and let them brood for the next crisis, or do you remain a socialist forever?
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:13AM (#22624407)
Public goods must be protected. USPS does pretty well IMHO, as a similar example. No reason to recapitalize with public shareholders if you don’t need them. The Fed doesn’t have them (their shares are unique and essentially non transferable).
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by totalZero on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:25AM (#22624464)
USPS lost $8.8 billion in fiscal year 2019.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday March 19, 2020 @12:26AM (#22624478)
Public goods don’t have to break even or generate a profit. They still deliver my mail like clockwork, and we’ll cover any pension obligations with taxes if there’s a shortfall because of Congressional action (which is why USPS loses money, due to Congress having unreasonable pension funding requirements specifically for USPS).

If you require a bailout, you had your chance as a for profit concern. Entirely reasonable to run services at a loss as a government entity. Some services are simply expenses.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:53AM (#22624910)
> They still deliver my mail like clockwork

"Makes the trains run on time" is a pretty weak argument when the alternative (e.g. UPS) has a demonstrated ability to do the same thing without losing billions of dollars.

> If you require a bailout, you had your chance as a for profit concern. Entirely reasonable to run services at a loss as a government entity.

Isn't this a double standard? A private entity loses money and requires a taxpayer bailout once, they've had their chance. A government entity loses money and requires a taxpayer bailout every year, cost of doing business?

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by toomuchtodo on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:38AM (#22626850)
We have bailed banks and airlines out repeatedly, not once. UPS is not mandated to deliver to every address in the United States six days a week, such that USPS is.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by signa11 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:54PM (#22624269)
oh yes. "inside job", on similar lines is excellent as well.
Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by manigandham on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:28AM (#22624785)
Margin Call is a fictional movie and the 2008 financial crisis had many companies that died before bailouts. And those bailouts were loans that were paid back in full with interest so the US taxpayers actually made money for once.

None of this has to do with capitalism. Governments exist to look after the citizenship and step in during exigent circumstances like war and pandemics. Of course we want better corporate ethics and accountability, but letting critical companies die now will only lead to further ruin. We want to avoid total societal collapse, not accelerate it.

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by legolas2412 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:46AM (#22624865)
TARP recovered funds totalling $441.7 billion from $426.4 billion invested, earning a $15.3 billion profit or an annualized rate of return of 0.6% and perhaps a loss when adjusted for inflation.

Amazing profit the taxpayers made!

If the bailout was such a good deal, maybe the private industry could do it?

Re:Fed reinstates multi-trillion dollar bailout program for ... by manigandham on Thursday March 19, 2020 @01:53AM (#22624905)
Yes, taxpayers didn't lose any money, made a tiny profit, and the economy was stabilized while preventing catastrophic failure. You consider this a bad outcome?

Public and private sectors work together. Private enterprise is great for growth and freedom but there are emergency situations where the government can help for the good of society. What is so controversial about this?