They do the ECG and find a really crazy high blood pressure in my heart so they think I have pulmonary hypertension. This kicks off:
- A sleep study
- Lung capacity study
- Restricted travel (they didn't want me to fly - which was a problem with my consulting work)
- A full-on cardiac catheter procedure - which is outpatient, but still a procedure where they put you under twilight sedation and insert large metal sheath into your groin (femoral artery)
Easily a dozen doctors visits, thousands of dollars in additional tests, and multiple weeks of time altogether. Also, non-trivial risks of infection and complication from the procedure.
On top of that, it's a mental thing. Every twinge of a muscle in my chest would cause a spike of concern, I'd sit around worrying about my heart inflating and bursting, etc.
All to (thankfully) find out that definitively 100% that the ECG was a false positive and I'm perfectly fine. One kicker to this though is that I was initially rejected for health insurance at a new job (pre ACA) as I'd had this procedure. It took patiently explaining over and over again to insurance people the above before they would accept me.
Now I just tell them before they inspect me and avoid the whole thing altogether.
You need to think about a tests Postive Predictive Value and Negative Predictive Value. The PPV is the number of people who get a positive test who have the condition divided by the number of people who get a positive test who do not have the condition. When the PPV is low the test can provide functionally no information. Now the important thing to remember is that the PPV changes based on the prevalence of the disease in the population, so a given test could be good for some people and bad for others, all depending on their base risk.
If you know the risk of a false positive and the benefit and risk of treatment, then you have the option of reducing risk: choosing an option with increased risk is a mistake, but a mistake in judgement, not a mistake due to the test.
Not doing unneeded tests has parallels to not doing unneeded logging. The costs may be low, but they're not zero.
Sure -- if you have a problem, it might have been nice to have screened for it earlier, or to have logged more data for that flow; but if a problem is rare, the costs for doing all the tests or all the logs adds up.
In medicine specifically, we often read about interventions that turn out to have not been the greatest idea. Avoiding or postponing interventions in the absence of symptoms seems more prudent than seeking out more interventions in general. There are some things where widespread screening makes sense, and you shouldn't ignore symptoms or family history, of course.
If the test [likely] takes up more resources to run than the [likely] benefit, then don't run the test, I agree.
I wouldn't count that as a diagnostic test at all, though.
Sure, your method works for a lot of cases - but it doesn't work or not very well for orders of magnitude more.
For example, let's say it had been discovered during my scans (which were taking place for unrelated reasons) that I had a minor aneurysm in my brain that had a roughly annual 0.2% chance of rupture. Let's then say I was given the choice of having an operation with a 10% mortality rate. What do I do?
This sort of decision is really tough, because I could easily live another 50 years with such an aneurysm, but the terror of having something like that in your head might scare you into taking a risky operation you logically shouldn't take. Sometimes ignorance of minor problems is a good thing.
(Note: These stats above are plucked out of thin air to make a point, but I know of real cases where the numbers have fallen this way.)
Knowing what might kill you might give you the chance to deal with it, or choose how to live with it.
Either I test positive, and this gives me a treatment program or more knowledge about the situation - and how I can manage it physically and emotionally.
Even given a chance of testing false positive, it allows me to do more appropriate research and weigh up the risks and benefits - something I don't have without that test.
or I test negative, and I gain reassurance that I don't need to worry about this risk.
The worst case (in my view) is a false negative - but that's the same position as I was in without a test.