Re:London Stock Exchange hauled offline after major data pro...
by jrockway on Friday February 25, 2011 @06:29AM
(#2261837)
Clearly the problem stems from writing a finance-related application in something other than VBA-running-inside-Excel. "Linux"... what will they think of next!?
(I'm being sarcastic, but people say stuff like this every day and aren't. That's what's scary.)
Re:London Stock Exchange hauled offline after major data pro...
by aidos on Friday February 25, 2011 @07:46AM
(#2261969)
There's a lot of ignorance going on in the articles out there. I know nothing of the internals of the project but it was commissioned to replace a system that has frequent outages (including a major one last week). Teething issues, while not desirable, are inevitable at such an early stage of the project. It's bound to be an incredibly complicated system.
I feel for the devs working on it. Bet they didn't have a fun morning....
Re:London Stock Exchange hauled offline after major data pro...
by SoftwareMaven on Friday February 25, 2011 @11:00AM
(#2262552)
Any time you are dealing with a system with that many users, you are going to introduce a lot of chaos (in its mathematical sense). Chaos is nearly impossible to test for because there are just too many permutations.
You are (probably) right that any particular piece of a trading system would be easier to build and test than the examples you gave, but in aggregate, I think it would be much more difficult.
Re:London Stock Exchange hauled offline after major data pro...
by spitfire on Friday February 25, 2011 @12:51PM
(#2263046)
No it isn't. It's a matter of maturity and mindset. The avionics industry has it - they use Ada and formal methods,
most of the rest of the software development world doesn't. and they pay the price. Honestly I questioned the competence of the LSE when they outsourced their development for the first windows based trading system to a consulting shop.
Simply put, they outsourced a core, critical part of the UK's financial infrastructure to boobs. However, I do see some hope in haskell and ocaml entering the financial market.
Re:London Stock Exchange hauled offline after major data pro...
by CWuestefeld on Friday February 25, 2011 @10:54AM
(#2262528)
I'm not sure about that. The testing problems are different, but not harder.
An exchange has to deal with massive scale, but isn't hugely complex (relative to a spacecraft, which deals with fault tolerance and integrating many different inputs; or the mathematical complexity of medical imaging).
It seems to me that most aspects of scale aren't too difficult to emulate, given sufficient computing resources to generate the load.
Re:London Stock Exchange hauled offline after major data pro...
by viraptor on Friday February 25, 2011 @12:36PM
(#2262970)
The last paragraph is quite interesting - 3 different exchange platforms having problems in the same week one after another. While this might be just a coincidence... maybe someone knows how to crash the systems?
Re:London Stock Exchange hauled offline after major data pro...
by akadien on Friday February 25, 2011 @10:58AM
(#2262543)
I suspect malicious activity or automated trading systems could be the source of problems, in addition to engineering. Don't assume it's automatically Linux vs .NET.
(I'm being sarcastic, but people say stuff like this every day and aren't. That's what's scary.)
I feel for the devs working on it. Bet they didn't have a fun morning....
You are (probably) right that any particular piece of a trading system would be easier to build and test than the examples you gave, but in aggregate, I think it would be much more difficult.
Simply put, they outsourced a core, critical part of the UK's financial infrastructure to boobs. However, I do see some hope in haskell and ocaml entering the financial market.
An exchange has to deal with massive scale, but isn't hugely complex (relative to a spacecraft, which deals with fault tolerance and integrating many different inputs; or the mathematical complexity of medical imaging).
It seems to me that most aspects of scale aren't too difficult to emulate, given sufficient computing resources to generate the load.
http://www.computerworlduk.com/news/it-business/3262766/lond...
[1] http://www.computerworlduk.com/news/open-source/3260727/lond...
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2262882