News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:34PM (#22607554)
I would have liked to see the article address the potential advantages of stock buybacks.

Are companies with greater ownership more resilient to market turbulence? Are they better positioned to focus on long term growth over short term performance?

Additionally, it is unclear if these companies were neglecting R&D or had already exhausted their viable options. If the economy does turn for the worse, would additional high risk R&D investments still yield returns? Perhaps they were wise not to park capital in R&D

Last, buybacks allowed a large number of shareholders to cash out while the market was at an all time high.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by digitaltrees on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:37PM (#22607595)
It’s literally impossible to exhaust R&D Opportunities. The hard part is going from research to commercialization but the is an almost unlimited amount of innovation still possible.
Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @02:26PM (#22608309)
There may be near infinite opportunities to invest, but that does not mean they can be profitable.

Also, if something is a good investment, it doesn't mean it is a good investment for a given company.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by digitaltrees on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @05:15PM (#22610530)
That’s true and a good general guide but the current incentives for the executive team to under invest in long term health of a business and boost short term profit are overwhelming this rational analysis.
Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:00PM (#22619442)
The incentive for the executive team are set by the board and shareholders, who could easily restructure incentives to favor R&D investment. Whether is this is good for long term profit will be different from case to case.

I worked at a company where annual goals routinely included invest X billion on new technology acquisitions. Some of this money sticks and some doesn't.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by airstrike on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:53PM (#22607831)
> It’s literally impossible to exhaust R&D Opportunities.

It is not impossible, however, to exhaust R&D opportunities with an expected NPV greater than zero.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by clairity on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @02:17PM (#22608193)
that's only limited by how you define the industry you're in. we'd have a lot more to worry about if no NPV positive opportunities existed at all (which would imply an exhaustion of relatively free raw inputs).
Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @02:41PM (#22608526)
>that's only limited by how you define the industry you're in.

I have seen a lot of great companies acquired and destroyed by parent companies in another industry.

It certainly can and is often done well, but is not trivial or risk free.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by clairity on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @02:53PM (#22608692)
no doubt it's fraught with risk (including risks specific to diversifying or m&a), but all NPV-positive opportunities are at least a little risky by definition (no risk, no return).

acquisitions in general are all too often vanity projects, rather than synergistic value creators they're purported to be.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by throw0101a on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @03:11PM (#22608963)
> It’s literally impossible to exhaust R&D Opportunities.

Tell that to AAPL: how many projects got cut when Jobs came back to run the company in the 1990s.

Just because you can spend time on something does not mean you should. A company has a finite amount of employess, who have a finite amount of hours of daylight, with competitors nipping at their heels.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by Loughla on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:38PM (#22607611)
Article Title, "Why Stock Buybacks Are Dangerous for the Economy"

And you say

>I would have liked to see the article address the potential advantages of stock buybacks.

That's a different article. That's just 100% something entirely different than this article was ever meant to be. Why would you even make this comment?

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by airstrike on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:55PM (#22607867)
> That's a different article.

It's a different article, for sure. It's also a better written article that favors balanced, thorough arguments over proselytizing.

> Why would you even make this comment?

It's not your job to police other people's comments. I would expect that to be an axiomatic truth, but here we are.

Re:Stock buybacks are dangerous for the economy by s1artibartfast on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @02:35PM (#22608431)
Simply put, I prefer balanced and educational articles to opinion pieces.

I am receptive and interested in their premise, but don't feel like a robust case was made because no counterclaims were addressed.

I wrote this comment in hopes of discussing the topic with other posters so perhaps we could all expand our understanding of the world we live in.