News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by lacker on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:27PM (#22587397)
The biggest uncertainty is how many people would die if the virus spreads unchecked. 20,000 Americans? 2 million Americans? Both are possible, but with two orders of magnitude difference in effect, it is nearly impossible to estimate things like net economic impact of doing nothing.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by nullc on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:50PM (#22587562)
The mortality rate will be much higher the more overloaded we allow the hospitals to become. CDC's 'worst case' numbers are 1.7 million dead, but CDC is assuming a 1% CFR which is the rate we observe in places where hospitals are not overloaded.

In Italy-- which has more somewhat more ICU beds per capita than the US does and is a about 1.5 weeks ahead of the bay area in progression-- the current CFR is 6.8% (which is likely an underestimate because exponential growth means that most people who are diagnosed haven't been infected long enough to have died yet) and the resolved CFR is 43% (which is likely an overestimate, in part because people are dying faster than they are recovering in Italy now because they're going untreated). [NOTE: CFR is not IFR, and the CDC analysis uses CFR and separately accounts for the fact that only a small portion of infections result in hospitalizations]

The best way to mitigate economic effects is to act stronger earlier, exponential growth means that little improvements earlier are more impactful than vastly more aggressive measures later.

After halting big public events, bars closures have probably some of the best ratios of reduced communicability to economic harm, especially given the data showing that young people are carriers are much higher rates than older populations.

Many people's informal observations that even last night many bars were very busy. I keep hearing from younger people that if it were an issue 'they' would close down and so concern must be over-hyped. This perception makes it more important to take stronger measures.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by alexis_fr on Sunday March 15, 2020 @08:29PM (#22588353)
I can confirm: Since France’s president has closed bars, the psychosis became widespread, people now take real measures. Before that, everyone was keeping business as usual awaiting instructions, which is the worst way to let the epidemic grow, and they were even mocking those who took precautions as either racists, or weaklings. Ensuring the population is in « concerned » state is the first step, and only closing bars allowed people to visualize the emergency.

Example: For the few hours after announcing, the « McDonnalds » hashtag was trending. Which says a lot.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by xeromal on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:30PM (#22587417)
You can definitely argue that stopping all deliveries in the US could have a more drastic effect. No one is self sustaining any more. No one has a farm. If the grocery stores are empty, more will die. I'm sure of it.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:48PM (#22587543)
That's why neither of these are stopped. In both Wuhan and Italy, the food were and is still available, and deliveries work fine.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by xeromal on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:51PM (#22587572)
I guess I'm speaking from a Los Angeles perspective. Our stores are literally empty for most staples and any reduction in deliveries is going to make this an actual problem.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by yongjik on Sunday March 15, 2020 @07:02PM (#22587657)
But that's not due to delivery disruption - nobody stopped the trucks, and nobody's planning to. It's due to people hoarding (either by panic or greed).

If groceries aren't back to normal in a week, I can easily see state troopers mobilized to guard every supermarket and make sure nobody buys twenty boxes of Bounty. Yes, it would look silly and would grate the nerve of free market enthusiasts, but in an emergency you go for effectiveness, not prettiness.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 15, 2020 @07:10PM (#22587741)
There's so much food people can reasonably hoard, so unless everyone has really large apartments or are stocking personal fallout shelters, if the disruption lasts longer than a week, it suggests the problem lies elsewhere. Possibilities include local supply chain disruption, or abundance of "entrepreneurs" keen to do arbitrage on staples.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:58PM (#22587629)
How long has the panic shopping been going on? In Poland, when it started, it cleared out the basic long shelf life goods (rice, pasta, etc.) and TP from most of the cheaper stores for about two to three days. For some reason, some kinds of meat also disappeared. But it seems to be going back to normal now.

If after couple of days your stores are still empty of most staples, it suggests some serious problems higher up in the supply chain.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by nullc on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:51PM (#22587568)
It takes a pretty long time to die from starvation. Doubly so for your average American. :)
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by woodandsteel on Sunday March 15, 2020 @07:47PM (#22588041)
But the weaker people are from starvation, the more likely they are to die from the coronavirus.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by xeromal on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:53PM (#22587585)
haha ya. I'm seeing this as a potential diet. :P
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by nwallin on Sunday March 15, 2020 @07:10PM (#22587743)
No one is suggesting food deliveries should stop. If you deliver food, lockdowns don't apply to you, not even in Wuhan. Same with medical personnel. If you work for the water or electric company, you'll still be going to work.

On the other hand, nobody's gonna die from the lack of a haircut anytime soon. Lots of people (myself included) can work remote.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by duckMuppet on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:34PM (#22587438)
Yet they close NCAAA and NBA games while an airport like JFK still passes 2 million passengers a month, let alone transit centers such as Amtrak, greyhound, or local subway stations.

Even at a 2 - 4% mortality rate, the sheer panic over this is nonsense

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by nostromo on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:37PM (#22587466)
People are now panicking about the panic and subsequent overreaction.

I must say in Seattle it’s a little alarming to go to the store and to literally see no meat, no bread, no milk, no soap. And I’ve already had friends in hospitality lose their jobs.

I think the UK’s keep calm and carry on approach is the right way - but it’s hard to turn back from a panic.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by tanilama on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:42PM (#22587499)
UK approach is suicide, their health care system is going to break down magnificently under the pressure of swarm of sick people, or they are going to ask people to stay at home and pray once sick.

I don't see that works, people will riot.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by dillonmckay on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:52PM (#22587580)
Honestly, I think the people losing their jobs now are in a much better position than those facing uncertainty or not realizing it could happen to them.

Start getting unemployment now before that system becomes overwhelmed. I am not optimistic for state and local government to implement remote work.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by ptero on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:39PM (#22587478)
And somehow there is a very aggressive group trying to stifle any debate on the topic. Making a similar case in a friendly gathering early this week got me labeled as an anti-vaxer and trump fan (I am neither). It is "with us or against us", not a topic for discussion:(.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by marcinzm on Sunday March 15, 2020 @07:00PM (#22587649)
I mean, if you put it like the guy you replied to then I'm not surprised. The potential for 6+ million deaths over the course of a half a year is beyond horrifying to anyone whose is not a sociopath.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by pretendscholar on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:49PM (#22587553)
If 4 percent of the people who got it died that would absolutely be a crisis. That would be somewhere around 2 percent of the us population dying over the next few months. Even disregarding the number of people with irrevocable organ damage that live through lung failure, how can you say that millions of people dying over a short span would be nothing? How would that not cause a huge strain on the hospital system, utilities, and general state of the country?
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by TeMPOraL on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:47PM (#22587538)
In other countries, closedowns and event cancellations were enacted simultaneously with, or quickly followed by, locking down borders - making the airport issue mostly moot.

Beyond that, while it's unrealistic to immediately eliminate all mixing of people, you can vastly reduce it, and it makes a difference. That's the point of #StayTheFuckHome. Much less people on public transit, much less people in stores means much slower spread of the virus.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by marcinzm on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:39PM (#22587477)
>Even at a 2 - 4% mortality rate, the sheer panic over this is nonsense

The fear is that if the health system collapses the mortality rate could be even higher.

Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by sidlls on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:46PM (#22587528)
If? Our health care system isn't equipped to handle a large-scale outbreak. People are panicking, and in really dumb ways, but there are two rational fears right now: 1) fear of our health care system not being able to cope; 2) fear of the idiot-panickers hoarding everything for no good reason and leaving others unable to buy even basic necessities.
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by justaq320 on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:44PM (#22587514)
Unchecked, that means 750k - 1.5M people die from just this virus...that doesn't take into account running out of hospital beds for all other patients and seeing a spike in flu deaths, etc. Very serious question...at what number would you be ok letting it go unchecked? Or alternatively, do you think some other approach is better than shutting down sports games, etc.?
Re:California Governor calls for home isolation for seniors,... by ptero on Sunday March 15, 2020 @06:33PM (#22587433)
Anything is possible, but unless this batch has been scientifically engineered for maximum impact, killing 3 times more people than the spanish flu seems unlikely. My 2c.