Re:Herd Immunity
by dmos62 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:08AM
(#22575367)
There's been talk that previous coronaviruses don't cause immunity and there already seems to have been cases with this one where a person got it twice. Does anyone have insight?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Herd Immunity
by coffeefirst on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:33AM
(#22575558)
I have yet to hear this from a credible source. It appears to be a self perpetuating rumor.
All it would take us a few people who catch Coronavirus in addition to one of the many things floating around with similar symptoms to think they caught it twice. It’s just too easy.
There have only been a handful of such reports with COVID-19, and they’re probably false test results.
> "there already seems to have been cases with this one where a person got it twice"
Just so people know: this has not been confirmed and has been an unsubstantiated rumor for a while. It is pretty unlikely this will happen considering what we know about how things like this function on a physiological level. It is much more likely due to the changes is testing (mostly where on the body samples were taken), confusion about symptoms or false negatives.
I've read that coronavirus is a near relation to the common cold virus. How significant is it that catching a cold doesn't seem to give you immunity from catching another?
That's because the common cold mutates very quickly, so by the time you catch another cold it's effectively a new virus.
Re:Herd Immunity
by DiogenesKynikos on Sunday March 15, 2020 @07:37AM
(#22582875)
The "common cold" is a catch-all phrase for many different viruses, which are not all closely related to one another. The coronaviruses that circulate in humans (other than SARS-CoV-2) are common colds. My understanding is that they do not mutate quickly, but that for whatever reason, one infection does not confer lasting, complete immunity to later reinfection (though later infections may be less severe).
Is coronavirus different in that respect?
Re:Herd Immunity
by AstralStorm on Saturday March 14, 2020 @11:40AM
(#22576035)
If we can use data related to Human Coronavirus strains (HCov), which are responsible for many colds, then not that much different.
Of course, SARS-CoV-2 could be different. For SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV, there was no data on this.
Over 200 different viruses can cause a cold.
Rhinoviruses are a totally different "animal" compared to COVID19.
You can get colds from different viruses.
The second infection is likely about the virus reaching the lungs while it did not make it there previously.
Meanwhile, asymptomatic carriers etc. are still being researched.
We don’t know but it is expected that immunity lasts for at least 6 months. Time will tell, this thing hasn’t been out long enough.
Re:Herd Immunity
by chrisweekly on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:31AM
(#22575549)
citation please
No reported reinfections and we’re 4-5 months in.
Have people actually been infected twice? I know people have been hospitalized for COVID-19, assessed as recovered, and released only to test positive later. But have they proven that's from a second infection, rather than a premature release or residual virus bits?
there may be people who continue to test positive, but there have been no confirmed instances of reinfection.
Re:Herd Immunity
by randomsearch on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:25AM
(#22575489)
Not an expert, but this sounds like social media hysteria rather than science.