News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by NortySpock on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:45PM (#22572478)
But you can trace all of that after the fact. If you have a positive result you can go prove it later. If you have a negative result you can go prove that later. But you can at least start by acting on the result.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by jayliew on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:52PM (#22572511)
So if you get a negative result from the test-kit, you let the person go, then later after the fact, you realize that it's a false-negative and you shouldn't have let the patient go ... now you've just spread the virus even more
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by hjanssen on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:06PM (#22572564)
The alternative as it seems right now is to not test at all.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by jayliew on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:12PM (#22572585)
I'd argue that that is better. Because if you're not tested, you know that you don't know. But if you get a false-negative (the test tells you're not infected, but you actually are), you think you're not infected, you may go about your daily life infecting other people.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by csnover on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:46PM (#22572760)
You’re assuming that most people will act responsibly and not go about their daily lives infecting other people if they know that they don’t know. This goes against my personal experience of how many humans behave.

It’s equally plausible to me that someone receiving a false negative will take extra precautions in order to avoid becoming sick themselves, instead of deciding (in the absence of a test) that they are infected and so don’t need to be careful about protecting themselves any more.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by masonic on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:19PM (#22572616)
Unfortunately, a no-test is preferable to a false negative.

Even with known good kits, we are getting negative and positive results from the same patient, most often throat- negative and anal-positive.

When a carrier receives a false negative, behavior changes toward risk.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by scotty79 on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:47PM (#22572771)
Maybe in ebola but not flu. And this is more like flu. Eventually almost everyone will get it. Possibly more than once.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by ryandrake on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:54PM (#22572522)
Exactly. At this point only irredeemable bureaucrats care whether a face mask meets ISO-12345 compliance or a test kit has documents stamped by the right government Deputy Inspector of Inspectors. Bring the things in and worry about the right official seals of approval later.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by robomartin on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:10PM (#22572582)
That's insane. If the untraceable masks only block particles larger than 1 micron rather than 0.3 microns, they are useless. If instead of being true N95 they are N80, they are deadly junk.

This isn't about bureaucracy, this is about engineering and science. Junk is junk, and it can kill you when you assume you are being protected (or protecting others) and you are not because they lied to you.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by mythrwy on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:23PM (#22572632)
Pretty quick check that. Your cynicism is astounding.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by robomartin on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:36PM (#22572711)
At least I am not ignorant, or naive. That's dangerous.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by scotty79 on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:51PM (#22572789)
You are ignorant because you assume US tests and masks are vastly superior to Chinese tests and masks for this application. Masks, even perfect ones barely do anything for something that infectious and tests are more for statistics to inform high level decision making than anything else.

Staying away from people is the only thing that measurably does anything.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by robomartin on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:07AM (#22573526)
As I put it in a reply to someone else's honest and intelligent question:

Let's say these masks are going to protect our doctors. The risk is that garbage masks might not protect them at all. Very soon we lose entire hospitals because we used product without traceable and verified specifications and performance.

How many patients die because hospitals go down due to junk masks?

If, on the other hand, these masks are being used while cutting wood on a table saw to keep from inhaling sawdust, well, specifications can be very loose and it will still protect the wearer just fine.

When things matter, adherence to specifications and standards while backed to real and traceable testing matters.

What is ignorant is to not take the time to think, understand and become knowledgeable enough to have an opinion rooted in facts. Please stop using insults in place of doing your homework.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by scotty79 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:10AM (#22574305)
Even perfect mask in practice of intense contact with the infected is barely better than piece of cloth draped over your face.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by labawi on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:10AM (#22574301)
While your arguments have merit, it is notable that China is the country that has infection under control.
[dead]
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by inimino on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:39AM (#22574836)
> The people who are reacting negatively to my comments are doing so while completely devoid of experience and an understanding of the realities in China.

You must know much more than the rest us. How many years do you have in China, 老外?

If you think the richest man in China doesn't know more than you do about "specifications, performance, and quality," you're not just misinformed, and you're not merely ignorant.

If you think "Chinese-made masks given as gifts by some dude" is in any way appropriate in a discussion about a donation by Jack Ma, you know less than nothing about Chinese culture and should remain silent.

If "taking the time to learn something and understand" is a value you hold, now is the time for you to do that. Your xenophobic fear-mongering is a shame to your country.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by scotty79 on Saturday March 14, 2020 @06:19AM (#22574331)
> What I said, very clearly, is that the difference is in TRACEABILITY and, not directly but implied, adherence to REAL SPECIFICATIONS, PERFORMANCE AND QUALITY.

What you don't seem to realize is that any such difference doesn't matter because "The goggles! They do nothing!"

This virus stays airborne for 3 hours after last infected breathed in any given room. Nothing short of full hazmat suit can significantly help. Piece of cloth over your face might reduce infection by 1% and most pristine N95 mask built to most amazing US quality reduces infection by 2%. Would the difference in mask quality really matter if those were the numbers?

When you have diarrhea does it matter if your toilet paper is tracable? You just need a lot of it. Not so much to efficiently help with the disease but mostly for comfort.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by dirtyid on Saturday March 14, 2020 @03:57AM (#22573859)
>Which room do you go into?

Either room is preferable to Room 3: which is no one has any masks.

Or the Chinese made masks in Room 2 would be validated and inspected for compliance state side. Trust but verify etc. The logical scenario is traceable US made masks is triaged for medical workers while patients use Chinese made masks that's undergone some sort of due diligence.

But broadly, you're correct. Extra validation and QC should be emphasized now more than ever, China dramatically ramped up mask production by 10x normal capacity. Factory owners who do not typically make masks are spinning up production lines, raw materials is being sourced from everywhere. There's no doubt a lot of amateur hour happening which is why QC is extra critical with these batches that is at least good enough for Chinese frontline workers.

Unless the risk is China would deliberately send spiked masks via Ma, in which case, why not keep the masks in storage for later propaganda uses. Knowing how heated the rhetoric is going to become, this almost makes Ma's donation a bad move in retrospect. I'd hope the donation is traceable just for that possibility.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by masonic on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:23PM (#22572638)
This attitude resulted in a lot of vision damage from nonspec eclipse glasses from Amazon.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by robomartin on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:18PM (#22572611)
> But you can trace all of that after the fact.

No, you can't. You clearly don't understand the subject.

The most you might be able to do is say "Hmmm, we are getting three times more false positives". By that time you will have wasted a ton of time, overwhelmed hospitals with people who did not need to be there and no, despite your belief, there is no way (or point really) to trace it, at least nothing that is going to help your medical system to avoid collapse.

There is no substitute for quality and traceability when lives matter. None.

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by jessaustin on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:28PM (#22572653)
Why do you believe so strongly that China can't manufacture reliable health products? Most of the health products we've been using for decades are manufactured in China! They are currently operating a fairly successful effort against this disease, and the tests in question are a part of that effort. No one in USA has done the basic work in this field. SMH.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by robomartin on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:34PM (#22572702)
ALL quality medical products and supplies coming out of China, all of them, are made under intense western supervision and quality control. Only after a factory has proven itself that it can be relied upon are they trusted. And, even then, the supervision does not go away.

I would not manufacture coffee mugs in China without supervision. No way.

Has everyone forgotten the iPhone chargers that go up in flames? How do you think that happens?

Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by refurb on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:42PM (#22572742)
You can't sell products in the US, that were made in China, without FDA approval.
Re:Jack Ma to send 500K coronavirus test kits, 1M face masks... by jessaustin on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:57PM (#22572829)
A) FDA has some authority over food and drugs, not "products".

B) No one is selling unapproved products.