Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ...
by mehrdadn on Friday March 13, 2020 @06:04PM
(#22571272)
Thanks for the reply! So what I don't understand is, in your explanation, you appear to tacitly assume the rest of the brain matter is (in some sense, maybe statistically) "[mostly] independent" from the electrons we're measuring. As if, maybe they were behaving independently before, and only now have become a teeny tiny epsilon bit entangled due to the entangled electrons they're interacting with. But I don't understand what this assumption is based on; it seems to directly contradict the Big Bang idea. Presumably we all came from the same Big Bang, and were all completely entangled with each other at that point, with everything tied directly to everything else. Why should it be that after the particles got away from each other, this would stop being the case? I just don't understand. To me, if literally everything in the universe was entangled at some point, it will be forever—to my understanding, there's no way to "reduce" entanglement unless you have a source of particles with "less" entanglement to interact with, right? Which I understand would not be the case in this universe, because everything would be fully entangled with everything else.
Entanglement is unstable, and easily swamped. It doesn't go away, but it becomes a very small factor in things. If I had two entangled electrons, and added them to two coins, the two coins are now entangled. But if I flip them, I don't expect the results to be significantly correlated. The classical behavior of the coins massively swamps the entanglement.
So even if you and I were performing a Bell test experiment, and know that the atoms of your brain are somehow entangled to the atoms of mine dating back to the origin of the universe, it's still unreasonable to expect that to lead us to set up the equipment in such a way as to preserve the correlations between two entangled particles in our experiment. There's just too much brain matter, and too much has happened to it from the beginning of the universe until now, for that entanglement to make a difference.