News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Visual One (YC W20) – Event recognition for se... by mattlondon on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:44PM (#22562749)
It was more that if my internet connection goes down, are the cameras useless? What if the internet/AWS is just "slow" one day - will the notifications be delayed significantly making any "reactive" integrations pointless/ludicrously delayed? If things can run locally (doing inference for multiple cameras via a single "box" you plug in to your WiFi router etc) then you can be super-fast with IFTTT integrations.

My main line if thought was that I built basically your product for spotting when a cat climbed into my plant pots using ML and a RPi3 - the idea was that when it saw the cat, it would squirt a water pistol at it to scare it away - inference on the RPi 3 was too slow (if I was doing this now I'd use a coral accelerator maybe) and by the time it realised a cat had got into the plant pots, the cat had already taken a shit and left. I worry that your product might suffer from similar end to end latency. Niche use-case? Perhaps. I have Amazon Blink cameras here and the IFTTT integration is delayed by about 30 seconds so by the time you get a notification there is someone at your door it is to late to do anything as they will.have already left/kicked the door in by then etc. Doing all this locally would be super fast

My main concern was not really about privacy - you'll need to cover GRPR if someone from the EU happens to walk into frame of one of your customers' cameras one day in the future anyway (Good luck)

Re:Launch HN: Visual One (YC W20) – Event recognition for se... by mrafiee on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:13PM (#22563030)
Love that use case :) re your point about latency, that is one of the main reasons we are doing all the inference on the cloud. Almost all deep learning models (at least CV models) need GPU to run with low latency. That's true that if you have set up an automated response from another device, it may still work if the internet is down but for alerting the user, you would still need internet connection even with a central hub...
Re:Launch HN: Visual One (YC W20) – Event recognition for se... by pilooch on Saturday March 14, 2020 @02:30AM (#22573597)
FTR, a simple RPi4 yields ~4FPS on a DL object detection model. You may need cloud for your central hub, but neural network inference can be done locally.
Re:Launch HN: Visual One (YC W20) – Event recognition for se... by mrafiee on Saturday March 14, 2020 @10:31AM (#22575546)
By 4FPS do you mean 250ms latency per frame? What OD model specifically did you get that latency from on RPi4?