News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by hef19898 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @12:25PM (#22558470)
I don't find any differentiation between early stage and later stage nor references to exponential functions:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_modelling_of_infe...

If you find any source, idealy scientific papers on the subject, that shows that contagious diseases can be modelled with simple exponential functions, please share them. I am not an expert on that matter, so I would be really interessted to see some reliable sources confirming the use of exponential functions.

Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by cvwright on Thursday March 12, 2020 @12:39PM (#22558659)
Ok, look at the differential equations on this page about the Kermack-McKendrick model: https://mathworld.wolfram.com/Kermack-McKendrickModel.html

Notice that the rate of change in the infected population (dI/dt) is proportional to the current number of infected (I) and the current number of susceptible (S).

In the early stages, when S is large and I is still small, this acts just like an exponential function in I.

For example, think about what happens when you double I the first several times. S stays relatively unchanged, and so dI/dt roughly doubles each time you double I.

Does that make sense?

Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by hef19898 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @01:14PM (#22559122)
Yeah, exactly. In the beginning exponential, later on not anymore. Without changing the equation. So, no, not exponential. Because, you know, very early on an exponential graph can approximated by something non-exponential. Would be utter BS, sure, so nobody does it.
Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by cvwright on Thursday March 12, 2020 @01:26PM (#22559295)
Exponential growth. It's the growth phase that matters.

People keep mentioning the exponential because both of these curves, at an important point in time, grow very fast. Much faster than anything you're likely to encounter in daily life, so the public really doesn't have the requisite intuition.

But I can see you're not interested in understanding the point. You asked for equations, I gave you equations. Good day sir.

Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by hef19898 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:41PM (#22560210)
We are, I think, not disagreeing at all. May sound crazy, but bear with me a second here. I know that the initial phase of any epidemic is exponential. Key are these three small words, initial growth phase. Because they make all the difference, as every epidemic will ultimately peak.

These three words are simply to often drowned out in discussions about COVID-19. That's we you see extrapolations of this growth against, for example, the population of Italy. And this is dangerous. And I don't think we disagree here, I never disputed the exponential nature of the early phase.

We just shouldn't make the mistake in assuming everybody catches these three little words, especially not online.

The most critical question everybody is trying to answer right now is, when the peak will be. And whether this peak will to high for our medical infrastructure. With all the measures being taken, the conclusion seems to be the point will be too high. Hence the counter measures. So we should all do what we can to flatten the curve as much as possible. I never said anything else, and honestly, I don't see where are disagreeing here.

Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by Certhas on Thursday March 12, 2020 @12:55PM (#22558844)
In your link, look at this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_modelling_of_infe...

S = N - I - R, and lets used normalized ratios, so i = I/N, r = R/N, etc... so the dynamics of i are given by:

di/dt = beta (1 - i - r) i - gamma i

di/dt = (beta - gamma) i - beta (i^2 + ri)

At the beginning of the disease, the ratio of infected and recovered is very small, say 1e-5 for 100 cases in a population of 10 million. So initially the second term is 1e-10 whereas the first is 1e-5. The initial dynamics of a new disease are given by:

di/dt ~ (beta - gamma) i

exponential growth. It will start deviating from exponential growth once i becomes large enough. If 10% of the population have had the disease it will deviate from exponential growth by 10%. Once it gets to half the population being infected or recovered you start seeing a real deviation.

In reality this might never happen, because we are taking a lot of measures to get beta down. So really you have something like

di/dt ~ (beta(t) - gamma) i

where beta(t) will capture all the countermeasures people take. If the countermeasures are effective and manage to push beta(t) below gamma before a large chunk of the population is infected, we might never see non-exponential behaviour from the disease. It will have an exponentially growing phase, and then an exponentially shrinking phase.

---

Here is just one paper I found with two seconds of google that looks at this, very recent, a bit basic:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6962332/

But here is what it says in the abstract:

"The initial exponential growth rate of an epidemic is an important measure of the severeness of the epidemic, and is also closely related to the basic reproduction number."

"Classical compartmental transmission models assume exponential growth during the early phase of a well-mixed population"

Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by hef19898 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @01:17PM (#22559164)
"The initial exponential growth rate"

Key word, initial. Later on, not so much. Which is the whole point, pandemics aren't exponential over the complete run time. So, why not using these formulas at least in the models instead of using exponential equation limited by world population?

Edit:

"It will have an exponentially growing phase, and then an exponentially shrinking phase"

Confirming the point above. Math is a precise science, it's a while since I did stuff like that, but getting equations right or not used to be a big deal back than. And now we talking more serious things than just a grade in an exam.

Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by Certhas on Thursday March 12, 2020 @01:51PM (#22559622)
Okay you're just trolling now. We are very much in the initial exponential phase of Covid-19. As I derived above, once you get to 10% you might start seeing deviations from exponential in the SIR model. The bump that you saw in China is not due to this deviation from exponential growth behaviour. We luckily never got close to 10% infection. It's due to getting to negative exponential growth. The beta(t) part of my answer above.

You're free to use whatever sensible model you want in your analysis, but you are criticising people for using exponential models. You have no arguments for that. Then you throw out Wikipedia, falsely claiming that exponential models are nowhere to be found there. Then you demand peer reviewed studies that use an exponential model, which I provide. But somehow that is not enough either.

In fact there are numerous assumptions in the SIR/exponential growth model. These might not hold. We might get slightly sub-exponential growth in some diseases. There is vast literature on that. But the base line in all the vast literature on this is that the most natural, obvious and common behaviour is exponential.

Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid... by hef19898 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:42PM (#22560220)
See my comment above. I don't think we really disagree.