Re:Why some governments appear not to be acting on the Covid...
by Certhas on Thursday March 12, 2020 @01:51PM
(#22559622)
Okay you're just trolling now. We are very much in the initial exponential phase of Covid-19. As I derived above, once you get to 10% you might start seeing deviations from exponential in the SIR model. The bump that you saw in China is not due to this deviation from exponential growth behaviour. We luckily never got close to 10% infection. It's due to getting to negative exponential growth. The beta(t) part of my answer above.
You're free to use whatever sensible model you want in your analysis, but you are criticising people for using exponential models. You have no arguments for that. Then you throw out Wikipedia, falsely claiming that exponential models are nowhere to be found there. Then you demand peer reviewed studies that use an exponential model, which I provide. But somehow that is not enough either.
In fact there are numerous assumptions in the SIR/exponential growth model. These might not hold. We might get slightly sub-exponential growth in some diseases. There is vast literature on that. But the base line in all the vast literature on this is that the most natural, obvious and common behaviour is exponential.
Key word, initial. Later on, not so much. Which is the whole point, pandemics aren't exponential over the complete run time. So, why not using these formulas at least in the models instead of using exponential equation limited by world population?
Edit:
"It will have an exponentially growing phase, and then an exponentially shrinking phase"
Confirming the point above. Math is a precise science, it's a while since I did stuff like that, but getting equations right or not used to be a big deal back than. And now we talking more serious things than just a grade in an exam.