News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by theli0nheart on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:05PM (#2255570)
It's been a crazy 36 hours since I last posted here about my weekend project. This morning, I woke up to an email from Facebook Platform, saying that the application has gotten disabled.

Full text of the email is at http://lts.cr/PRh

I'm not using stream.publish, and I'm checking for updates as little as possible. Also, it seems it was deleted from my apps...so they didn't just disable it. It's gone for good.

I may open source the code, if anyone wants to run copies. Let me know.

Update 1: I just messaged Zuck, hopefully he can respond with some more details.

Update 2: I tried to appeal the decision using Facebook's little form (http://www.facebook.com/help?faq=17553), but it wouldn't go through for my account. My friend tried it, and it worked. Don't really know what to think about that...

Update 3: Maybe this is a Harvard v Yale thing?

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by jdp23 on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:30PM (#2255667)
So they didn't even give you any notice, just "boom you're gone"? Disappointing.

Some of the suggestions in "How to respond when Facebook censors your political speech" might be helpful -- http://www.talesfromthe.net/blog/?p=28

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by theli0nheart on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:34PM (#2255686)
Nope, zero notice. It was basically "Poof!" and then the app wouldn't work. Doubly annoying since I was sleeping when it was deactivated (4am PST).
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by soulclap on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @04:01PM (#2255784)
"Zero notice" seems to be a common thing at Facebook. Same happened with my personal account, just gone one day.

To be fair, I guess it was because I didn't have my real name on it but it was the name my blog readers know me by. Several thousands of friends - gone, without a warning.

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by calloc on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @06:27PM (#2256264)
I currently have about 15 different Facebook accounts, each under false names. So far none of them have been shut down, or even questioned. Maybe it was because you got to such a high amount of friends that they took notice, mine are rather low, around 50 - 100 friends on each account...
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by soulclap on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @06:43PM (#2256316)
Probably. Or your 'false names' are not as 'flashy' as mine! I still thought it was quite harsh to just delete the account without any warning or notice at all.

And I've got a lot of friends who aren't using their real names either and are getting away with it, no idea how they are tracking you down.

Insisting on real names is a big part of what makes Facebook so uncool and corporate to me. I want the Myspace days back, seriously. They didn't care at all.

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by JonnieCache on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @07:04PM (#2256375)
A lot of people on my list have completely preposterous names that are clearly not real. I've changed mine many times to many stupid things and never had a problem.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by Sticker on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @10:56PM (#2256871)
Let's hope you get busted for missing the whole point of facebook and are quickly removed.

Honestly, how gutless can you be? Quite the charades you got going there, congrats! If that's what interests you...

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by IDisposableHero on Thursday February 24, 2011 @07:41AM (#2257682)
missing the whole point of facebook

That depends on if you consider the point of facebook to give detailed, accurate biographical data about yourself away to a company with which you have no monetary relationship, so that this company can then sell it, or not.

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by nhebb on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @10:43PM (#2256837)
They could at least have sent a Breakup Notification. It only there were an app for that ...
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by alexophile on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @06:12PM (#2256225)
It seems, based on the excerpt in the article and the timing, that it may have been hit by an automatic kill/flag type situation.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by thehotdon on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:50PM (#2255743)
I wouldn't be surprised if facebook just "borrows" the idea and implements it on their own. They would have a significant advantage due to the lack of API restrictions.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by code_duck on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @06:06PM (#2256210)
I think FB would get some bad press if they offered a feature like this directly. Not for screwing over a developer (nobody but other developers care about that), but for the privacy violation/stalking feel the whole thing has.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by bittermang on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @06:26PM (#2256262)
You say that as if bad press or privacy concerns have had any impact on Facebook thus far.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by erikpukinskis on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @11:15PM (#2256896)
Are you serious? Beacon is gone. When the privacy stuff was hitting the fan, they designed/engineered a totally new privacy console in a week.

They ignore bad press and privacy concerns in order to move the project forward in major ways. Like adding News Feeds, or allowing entirely classes of API interaction (Beacon). They don't do it for little features like breakup notifications.

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by jacques_chester on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @05:09PM (#2256037)
Neither would I. And they'd be within their rights to do it: a good idea is a good idea, regardless of whence it came.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by ddkrone on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @05:16PM (#2256069)
I wouldn't say that's why it was shut down but facebook data gurus must be intimately aware of stalking as a huge traffic driver and this app tapped directly into that vein. I think other people have already mentioned this application siphoning traffic from their main user landing pages and that's probably why it was shut down.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by euroclydon on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @04:31PM (#2255905)
Could it work as a browser plugin? And more generally, isn't it nearly impossible for FB or any other website to prevent plugins from accessing data as if they were the user?
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by grigory on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @05:44PM (#2256149)
This was my first thought after reading the title of this thread. Let your users fetch the data for you!
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by atrevisan on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @04:15PM (#2255849)
I find it funny that Facebook can be used as a resource for conducting a political revolution, yet they kill this.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by jayzee on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @05:34PM (#2256113)
They have an advertising model. People who organize political revolts log in and see Che's t-shirts for sale on the right side of the page.

Checking status automatically takes away some incentive from users from logging-on, there by less money for fb. Hence the shut-down.

Somebody else posted a project where they were going to create an app so that people could interact with fb through their email? If that takes off, expect it to be shut-down as well.

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by joebananas on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @05:21PM (#2256086)
A revolution is way less creepy.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by brown9-2 on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @08:27PM (#2256587)
For what it is worth at this point, I heard Breakup Notifier mentioned on a nationally syndicated morning radio show (http://www.elvisduran.com/main.html) while driving to work yesterday (locally it was on Z100 in NYC). A belated congrats!
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by ccorda on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @04:10PM (#2255825)
Would love to see your example of scaling a Facebook app on Appengine if you choose to open source.

To others interested, Facebook has a pretty good tutorial/demo app: https://developers.facebook.com/docs/samples/canvas/

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by justinxreese on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:53PM (#2255754)
"and I'm checking for updates as little as possible." - per user though. Did the gigantic and sudden success of the app perhaps throw out some red flags? It could have been a legitimate automated response by the Facebook system because it wasn't exactly the normal growth rate for an application.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by dailyrorschach on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @04:24PM (#2255880)
Sure, but that would make sense if they just disabled the application and informed that there was a problem. According to the creator it seems not only was it shut down, but completely deleted.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by fwdbureau on Thursday February 24, 2011 @03:01AM (#2257307)
Although your app was an awesome piece of tech, did it come to your mind that they may have disabled it only because it's slightly disrespectful towards people? I mean there are real people behind every FB face, and a breakup can be sad or painful. Maybe for an undetermined percentage of the population, the effect of breakup notifier may be like a knife in the chest?
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by rhizome on Thursday February 24, 2011 @12:47PM (#2258952)
More disrespectful than FB leaking out your entire profile and friend list to every single FB game developer and their third-party ad providers? I'm doubtful that "respect" of users plays a role here, or in FB decisions at all.
Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by zxer on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @04:23PM (#2255873)
The email also says "take user feedback [...] into account". So perhaps the automated system isn't that automated after all.

And frankly, I am not surprised if Facebook isn't comfortable having this app around. If someone finds an exploit, and a "who has a secret crush on who" database gets out, that's a pretty major PR-disaster for Facebook. Non tech-savy Average Joe won't care that it wasn't Facebook's fault.

Re:Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook by potatolicious on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @04:27PM (#2255893)
All you have, as a FB app, are a bunch of UIDs though. Not impregnable security, but stealing that data still puts you a long way from being able to say "Joe as a secret crush on Jane".