Re:The flying taxi market may be ready for takeoff: study
by rlpb on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:49AM
(#22558045)
> You don't have to worry about any pedestrians or unpredictable drivers...
Actually you do. Most airspace is uncontrolled, where the collision avoidance algorithm is "see and avoid". There are plenty of airspace users who do not broadcast any kind of beacon apart from being visible to other pilots.
You could demand that they all wear electronic beacons. Such technologies do exist. However they aren't currently predicted to work well enough in the expected congestion created by large numbers of autonomous aircraft in the future. And it faces most of the same practical challenges as putting beacons on pedestrians and all other road users.
Re:The flying taxi market may be ready for takeoff: study
by nradov on Thursday March 12, 2020 @02:20PM
(#22559927)
That is not fair. Autonomous flight is just as hard as autonomous driving due to the need to handle mechanical failures. If something breaks in the air you can't just pull over and stop. Current autopilots are generally unable to cope with failures and rely upon a qualified human pilot being ready to take back control within a few seconds.
Re:The flying taxi market may be ready for takeoff: study
by zhoujianfu on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @11:01PM
(#22553265)
Yeah, I don’t think we’ll ever have autonomous driving... mostly because we’ll have autonomous flying first and it’ll be way better!
Re:The flying taxi market may be ready for takeoff: study
by gambiting on Thursday March 12, 2020 @09:31AM
(#22556591)
Flying is an order of magnitude worse than driving energy-wise. Even with electric motors it's still going to be a problem. Tesla travels for about 300Wh/mile, I doubt any flying machine would be within 10x of that.
Re:The flying taxi market may be ready for takeoff: study
by kaiabwpdjqn on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @09:39PM
(#22552668)
The sky is mostly empty space when, and only when, there are not flying taxis at sufficient scale for society to bat an eye
Re:The flying taxi market may be ready for takeoff: study
by allovernow on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @09:41PM
(#22552681)
That's why I mentioned beacons for collision avoidance. They wouldn't be expensive. If we're about to build this industry from the ground up I would expect to see something like that done anyway.
The sky is mostly empty space and landing zones are clearly marked and purpose built. You don't have to worry about any pedestrians or unpredictable drivers or roads.