News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by mc32 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:41PM (#22547209)
Good on them.

I don’t know what the hell is happening but I don’t understand how people who support the ACLU and every other 90s liberal who supported free speech unencumbered can now get on board with this censorship which shamelessly hides behind “private cos are not the gov, so it’s not real censorship.

You don’t have to like the people, you can hate them, despise them, shame them whatever, but people should not be silenced.

We’re going to regret this short sighted spiral into self imposed censorship.

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by duxup on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:42PM (#22547227)
Humans of all kinds are bad about seeing beyond their own noses.

Having principles is hard when it might apply to / benefit someone you don't like.

That's not applicable to any particular group, it's a human problem.

I often wonder when talking to folks who I agree with:

How much does this person really think about this topic... and how much do they just think that this bad thing we don't like is bad because that guy did it? And would they be dismissive if someone we agreed with generally did the exact same thing?

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by vorpalhex on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:47PM (#22548966)
Personally, I use the trick of substituting myself or someone I like in the position of the accused when trying to determine ethics/morality.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by thinkingemote on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:27PM (#22548713)
Fundamentally it's the idea that you should not tolerate the intolerant.

This idea is what many people believe who justify the use of this kind of censorship Vs freedom of expression.

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by mc32 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:40PM (#22548876)
That’s problematic. Who decides what’s tolerable and not? Twenty years ago this posture would go contra liberal thought.

Do the accused soon not deserve representation because they’re intolerable?

It’s like show trials are wanting to show their face right around the corner any day soon.

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by pinkfoot on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:47PM (#22548954)
> who decides what’s [intolerable]?

A fantastic first step is to eliminate anyone who reserve the right to unilaterally use violence in the name of religion.

After that, exclude those who want a special deal for their faction that they wont grant others.

See, easy.

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by mc32 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:49PM (#22548986)
The word violence in common usage used to have a meaning. Now it can mean anything you want it to mean. There is no solid ground down this path.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by pinkfoot on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:51PM (#22549003)
Fair enough: actual murders or direct threats thereof.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by mc32 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:04PM (#22549206)
Curious, does it imply people in prison for rape murder and assault should not be able to have a book written, what about providing an interview?
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by pjc50 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:49PM (#22549768)
This is already law in a lot of places. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Son_of_Sam_law
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by mc32 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:53PM (#22549806)
That’s not the same. That says they cannot profit monetarily. So in this case of what’s his face had judgements against him, or indeed was serving a felonious sentence the state could seize proceeds. It doesn’t give them the right to censor publishing.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by monksy on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:55PM (#22549065)
The usage of violence is already illegal.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by strictnein on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @12:49PM (#22547287)
The most disappointing is the XKCD comic, which people still wave around. Being shouted down by the mob on a private platform isn't something to be applauded. And it isn't just "showing someone the door", as the comic puts it.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by lliamander on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:18PM (#22548603)
Indeed, that was the first XKCD I felt strong negative reaction to.

It's sad because it engages in two fallacies:

- The equivocation of the 1st Amendment with free speech

- The assumption that all people being de-platformed are trolls

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @01:57PM (#22548319)
> "I don’t know what the hell is happening but I don’t understand how people who support the ACLU and every other 90s liberal who supported free speech unencumbered can now get on board with this censorship which shamelessly hides behind “private cos are not the gov, so it’s not real censorship."

What makes you think old-school liberals are on board with any of this? I would guess that they, like myself, are lying low to avoid being libeled, harassed, and/or "cancelled" by those who favor those things but they don't support such values.

For those old-school liberals and the rest of the political spectrum out there, just remember that one thing that can't ever be "cancelled" is your vote in primaries and on Election Day. Please go out and vote for what you believe in.

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by monksy on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:57PM (#22549093)
> just remember that one thing that can't ever be "cancelled" is your vote in primaries and on Election Day. Please go out and vote for what you believe in.

I've heard people argue that that's exactly what happened with the Trump win. People voted against the party who brought on "well he's an -ist" [racist, mysogist, etc]

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by pjc50 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @01:17PM (#22547646)
Similarly, once a company has found out (or been reminded) that their author is a sex offender, they should no longer be under contractual obligation to publish it - that would be compelled speech, no?
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by mc32 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @01:29PM (#22547822)
What’s next lawyers and attorneys refuse to represent people of poor moral standing or worse are known felons?

WTF are we coming to?

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by pjc50 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:02PM (#22549175)
Lawyers can and do refuse to represent people who have behaved badly towards them. The rules for criminal defense lawyers are usually much stricter on who they can refuse, but it can still happen. In particular, misconduct towards your lawyer will get you dropped.
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by mc32 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @04:08PM (#22549925)
Ok, but do they with frequency drop clients due to moral incompatibility?
Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by marcus_holmes on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:04PM (#22548428)
> they should no longer be under contractual obligation to publish it

That entirely depends on what the contract says, which is probably why they're adding these clauses to the contracts.

The point is that there's no background "moral clause" in contract law. If you sign a contract, and then discover that the other person is a sex offender/nazi/actually Hitler, that doesn't matter. You still need to fulfil your obligations under the contract.

And we don't want to change this. Because getting on the wrong end of a Twitter dogpile is astonishingly easy to do. If the stakes were higher, and not only future careers but all existing contracts would be ruined, that would just inspire more dogpile. Then no-one wants to say anything in public, or where a journalist might hear of it, and the mob moves onto ever tinier infringements of ever more arcane moral rules.

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by lliamander on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @02:13PM (#22548554)
> Because getting on the wrong end of a Twitter dogpile is astonishingly easy to do. If the stakes were higher, and not only future careers but all existing contracts would be ruined, that would just inspire more dogpile.

IANAL, but this is a good time to remind people that, in the U.S., but actively trying to sabotage a contract between two parties may be tortious interference[1], and something one can be sued for.

If social media platforms made reporting of and discovery for these kinds of behaviors easier, I suspect we would see a drop-off in such dogpiling.

[1] https://smallbusiness.findlaw.com/liability-and-insurance/to...

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by pjc50 on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @03:48PM (#22549739)
Are you arguing that pointing out to Hachette that Woody Allen's daughter accuses him of sexual assault should render someone liable? And this is supposed to be the pro free speech position?

Nobody on Twitter did anything but speech, did they?

Re:We oppose morals clauses in book contracts (2019) by lliamander on Wednesday March 11, 2020 @04:18PM (#22550021)
> Are you arguing that pointing out to Hachette that Woody Allen's daughter accuses him of sexual assault should render someone liable?

I'm not talking about that specific case, but about the problem of twitter mobs in general (which is what the parent comment was talking about). It may apply to that case or not, but I'm not rendering judgement on that here.

> Nobody on Twitter did anything but speech, did they?

Telling the truth is not a tort. Often the behavior of twitter mobs rises above simply "telling the truth" and may involve epithets, slander, etc. which are not protected.

EDIT: Also, saying "break your contract or else we will harass you" is probably a tort