News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by bzbarsky on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @10:32PM (#2252885)
> So we pay more money then other countries but > don't get better outcomes?

Yes, exactly.

> Could we save money and get the same outcomes?

That seems like an obvious corollary of the above... But yes, I think we could.

> And since we get worse outcomes then they do

Not necessarily worse; just not better. Measuring and comparing outcomes across different populations is hard enough that it's hard to say more than "our outcomes are not clearly better than theirs".

> could we spend less and still get better outcomes?

This question is based on a premise which doesn't seem to be true, so probably no.

> How do you defined "more health care?"

Number of procedures per capita per year for various procedures is a reasonable measurement (where procedures can be MRIs, surgeries of various sorts, etc, etc). Usually people focus on the expensive end of this, by the way; having more physical checkups won't necessarily blow up your healthcare costs the way that more invasive cancer surgeries will.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by dalke on Wednesday February 23, 2011 @03:53AM (#2253539)
Your logic works both ways. If you say it's hard to measure then how do you know that get the same outcomes?

"Number of procedures per capita per year" is a horrible measure. It assumes that procedures done is a good proxy for overall health, which it isn't. Public health (clean food and water, trash pickup, promoting exercise and outside activities, cutting down on smoking, etc) is also important.

Here's a scenario. Country A and B are identical except that country A has pushed for potable water and B has not. As a result, 10% of the procedures in country B are from dysentery, cholera, and other water-borne diseases which are relatively cheap to treat (keep hydrated with a solution of salts and sugar). As a result, country B has more doctor visits per capita, and on average these costs are cheaper than in country A. Country B also has lower life-expectancy, more days sick per year, and other measurable outcomes.

By your definition, country B has the better health care system but I think most people would prefer the overall health of country A. Therefore your measurement is not so useful as an indicator of overall health outcomes.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by bzbarsky on Sunday February 27, 2011 @01:43PM (#2268490)
> It assumes that procedures done is a good > proxy for overall health

My whole point is that it's not a good proxy for overall health. However it _is_ a good proxy for amount of money spent on the system. Which is how you can end up spending more but not getting better overall health.

Do read what I said again. You're arguing against a strawman.

Which