The scam goes like this: WF open large numbers of fraudulent accounts, this pumps up some of their customer stats before the fraud is discovered: They get to claim their customers do more business with them, use more of their products, and that they are seeing growth in various areas (more customers using each product). These stats are flaunted to investors, who assumed that the increase in accounts (a leading indicator) would lead to an increase in profits (a lagging indicator).
The investors would then put in money, boosting the stock price.. allowing the executives to sell their stock at inflated prices, allowing WF to raise money for less stock, etc.
WF committed fraud on their customers so that they could pump up their numbers and fleece money from their investors.
Even after the investigations started and they were notified, they hid it from investors for 6 months... the investors found out when the news picked it up.
The damage they've caused was much more than $3B.
Measuring harm to investors is complicated though. Any investors who bought after the fake gains and did not sell before the scam was exposed have been harmed but other investors have actually gained. I would be interested to see a calculation (by someone other than a prosecutor) of this harm.
Unfortunately there is no way of holding "the bank" accountable for that because the punishment for causing investors to lose money is to fine the bank which is owned by those same-(ish) shareholders.
It is more accurate to ignore the existence of the legal entity "WF" and deal only with the natural persons. Employees / executives conspired on a massive scale to defraud the shareholders by collecting undeserved incentive payments and realising artificial gains on any stocks they sold. Some investors benefits and some lost out depending on timing of purchase and sales of the stock. A small number of customers suffered miniscule and temporary incidental harm to credit scores and an even smaller number suffered actual cash harm through paying account fees for accounts they did not ask for.
Kinda feels like the housing market when loan officers were paid a ridiculous amount for variable interest housing loans versus fixed loans. The banks and everyone were buying them up as that was their top line metrics but ignored how it was actually happening.
I hold the CEO and other top executives there for staying ignorant but I agree, this made minimal money for WF so I don’t think it was the true intent of the CEO to have this happen but they should’ve looked into how markets with not large enough populations had so many accounts. They didn’t and deserve the punishment.
https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/10/07/497084491/epis...
Both are true: WF took $3b, WF made $2m.
This is totally incorrect. The best estimate of how much money was made from the fake accounts scandal is... about $2m gross. That's for a pretty obvious reason which is that it is very hard to secretly charge people money and very easy to secretly open an account for them which then goes unused.
Essentially, WF did not really profit from this, it was the employees and officers who were fleecing the company and fraudulently opening accounts to do so.
Branch employees were incentivised to sell products like accounts and cards to customers on the theory that WF profited from such sales. Compensation for the employees was set based on an assumed / historical profit per cross-sold product. Senior management had incentive packages that were also based on that assumed link. But of course that was calibrated based on real accounts. Shadow accounts that are setup but not used by the customer (because they don't know they exist) do not and cannot produce profit for the bank. What the bank would have seen over time was number of products sold going up but profit per product going down. Since the former is a leading and the latter a lagging indicator, it can be a long time before that becomes apparent.
From the point of view of WF, this was the dumbest possible fraud because it didn't make them money. I bet that $2m in account opening fees actually comes from the less experienced crooked branch staff because it seems like a rookie mistake that would lead to you getting caught.
Of course there is no such person as "Wells Fargo", and from the point of view of the branch and management employees whose compensation depended on these cross-sales numbers, the scam worked just fine until they were caught.