During peace we can gamble on advanced systems while during conflict production and refitting is king.
Why do anything right the first time if you can get paid twice, thrice, or six times to fix your fuckups later?
P.S. if I buy a bespoke suit, I pay a fixed cost and it’s guaranteed correct — problems are paid for by the maker, not me.
Using materials that have been used for decades.
If you want to create a new nano-fibre fabric in a lab that's never been used before, and will not be purchased by anyone else, why should Henry Pool or Huntsman & Sons be the ones to pay for all the lab equipment?
If the USN wants cheap and cheerful there are OTS options:
* https://products.damen.com/en/clusters/combatants
It's kind of what the USN is doing for the FFG(X):
* https://news.usni.org/2018/02/16/navy-picks-five-contenders-...
Also the ffg/x “competitive” “bidding” process is a joke. They are paying five vendors to make PowerPoint presentations, then whoever made the prettiest slide deck gets billions of dollars.
The folks who run this are sensitive to criticism but also either unwilling or unable to enact any substantial change.
Otherwise, what's stopping a schmuck like me from creating a shell company and promise the navy state of the art ships? Shouldn't there be accountability here?
Btw, the pdf mentions that the military signed off on the purchase after the inspection, so my assumption was that they still could avoid paying.
Nothing is stopping you. But there will (hopefully) be a due diligence phase in which the bidders are evaluated beforehand. It's why there are such a thing as a approved / qualified bidder list:
* https://www.findrfp.com/Government-Contracting/Government-Bi...
Because we're not talking about generic widgets here. It's the difference between buying a bespoke Saville Row suit and a 3-for-1 Suit Warehouse suit.
There are all sorts of off-the-shelf (OTS) designs for general use vessels like tugboats:
* https://ral.ca/designs/tugboats/
And there are some 'generic' designs for combat vessels:
* https://products.damen.com/en/clusters/combatants
But if you purchase a generic design, then you don't have an advantage of your (potential) opponent because they may also have purchased a generic design.
The US military specifically does not want a generic design (at least in some areas) because they want (perceived) advantage with more (supposedly) advanced design. And someone has to pay for the R&D on that advanced design.
Given that the only market for these boats is the USN, why should the builder pay for the R&D? It's their (only?) customer that's asking for this, and they can't use what they learn for any other designs (because of ITAR export restrictions).
When Ford is doing research for a new F-150 they can spread the R&D over millions of units getting economies of scale, but (e.g.) Bath Iron Works can't exactly amortize the fixed costs of the Zumwalt-class destroyer if their only customer, the USN, says they'll buy 32 but then only builds 3. Why should BIW be the ones to pay?
It's the reason why the F-22 and F-35 have different costs: the Raptor is a US-only plane that no one else can touch, the Lightning II is cheaper because it's available for export and gets economies of scale.