That's certainly helpful.
However, both the original memo, and the reddit update have the same sort of condescending/arrogant tone. That probably was as much a factor in why people jumped to conclusions as anything else.
The reddit reply is neither condescending or arrogant. Why do you think so?
The reply is certainly less abrasive than the original memo. I still feel the undertones, but that's my opinion and subjective. I feel it's still self aggrandizing and dismissive of Metcalf's work.
Original memo gives good pointers, references, and ways to improve. It is also very short. I would love this critisizm on my work.
Would you love it arriving as a letter to your boss's boss, with no prior discussion? Also, it includes quite a lot of unneeded pejorative rhetoric that adds no value.
You misspelled "criticism".
This sort of thing is endemic to computing culture. Somebody says that a design is too inefficient or poorly thought out, then a practitioner comes along and crows, of course it works, all we had to do was overdesign it by a factor of ten.
Not reading the follow-up and still criticising/laughing at the original memo is thoroughly unjust. I've submitted[2] the follow-up as a separate item if people want to comment on it.
[0] https://twitter.com/_space_train/status/1236373295429226496
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/1xz13/in_1974_x...
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22517640