News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:50PM (#22496022)
I like being able to run a Linux desktop in a VM on windows and "extend" to another monitor with VM X apps rendering to a Cygwin Xorg instance. Wayland can't do that.
Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by ddingus on Thursday March 05, 2020 @12:55PM (#22496077)
Yup. In my humble opinion, the people who built X really did think through what multi user graphical computing meant.

I like X. Took me a while to understand it, but once I did, I used it hard and appreciated what it allowed me to do.

Doing stuff like dual or multi head computers. Multi users each with their own keyboard and mouse can happen with X. And if one needs another user, doing it via network just works.

X is a powerful thing.

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by Gnurou on Friday March 06, 2020 @12:55AM (#22501290)
> I like being able to run a Linux desktop in a VM on windows and "extend" to another monitor with VM X apps rendering to a Cygwin Xorg instance. Wayland can't do that.

This should be possible with virtio-wayland:

https://alyssa.is/using-virtio-wl/

It's pretty new and not used outside of Chrome OS (to run Linux apps) at the moment though.

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by cycloptic on Thursday March 05, 2020 @01:10PM (#22496246)
There is no reason wayland couldn't do that, other than that your compositor doesn't support the concept of virtual screens. I can't say that this is a very high-priority feature for any compositors at the moment.
Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by ddingus on Thursday March 05, 2020 @01:31PM (#22496470)
And that is why X is kind of amazing. They thought it all through.

Today, it is a game of which pieces make the most sense, and whether multi user graphical computing should be a thing.

We know it can. X did all that.

Should it?

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by cycloptic on Thursday March 05, 2020 @01:58PM (#22496791)
As far as Wayland goes, that is up to the developers and users of those compositors. The protocol itself supports the concept of multiple seats.

I can't speak for all the original X developers but TFA seems to suggest that they didn't think it all through.

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by ddingus on Thursday March 05, 2020 @02:09PM (#22496916)
When X is matched, then we can discuss whether that is true.

Currently, it's not. That does not make current efforts bad. I think they are quite nice.

They just do not yet actualize the vision X did and does today.

Whether that is wanted / needed is also an open discussion at this time.

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by cycloptic on Thursday March 05, 2020 @02:19PM (#22497051)
It won't be matched unless someone sees enough of a need to make it happen. Wayland the protocol doesn't have an explicit goal of doing everything that X did. The design is different.

As far as I can tell, the original vision of X was to unify all the proprietary Unix vendors with a standard windowing protocol. The network capabilities happened because they wanted to support dumb terminals connected to mainframes. Most of those proprietary Unix vendors are now gone. Currently it's not clear to me what role X is supposed to have, if any.

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by ddingus on Thursday March 05, 2020 @02:34PM (#22497216)
The role is multi user graphical computing. I made comments elsewhere in thread about that.

We may find or choose for that to not be a thing.

Ok, fine.

The X window people did make that a thing and the end result is powerful and flexible.

None of that makes efforts like Wayland bad. They aren't.

But they, by your own definition, are a subset of what X is too. They aren't thinking it through, by design. That is OK.

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by cycloptic on Thursday March 05, 2020 @03:58PM (#22498158)
Wayland (the protocol) supports the necessary bits and it's up to the compositors if they want to go the extra mile to support everything.

My own personal take is that most compositors won't because X does not represent multi user graphical computing in the way that most people use it today. That role is fulfilled by web applications.

Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by pjmlp on Friday March 06, 2020 @06:12AM (#22502695)
Commercial UNIX vendors, Xerox, TI, Genera, were already doing that before X was created.
Re:The X-Windows Disaster (1994) by the8472 on Friday March 06, 2020 @12:10AM (#22501142)
The compositor would have to talk to the virtual GPU driver to allocate additional surfaces on the host and make them available to the guest.

The next best alternative currently is looking glass[0]. Linux host with GPU1, Windows guest with GPU2 via pass-through and then copy the framebuffer from the guest to the host.

[0] https://looking-glass.hostfission.com/