A little anecdotal but when I was applying for jobs last summer there was a video that was brought up twice during interviews with different organizations. Both times I was told after the fact that it was just to see how I would react, all I did was tell them what happened, not that I was sorry because I wasn't, I told them I stood behind what my actions were and there was nothing I could do about it now (it hit 100k views on Instagram, not a situation where I can contain it). Both companies offered me a job.
I rewrote this a few times and I'm still not sure I got my point across, but I agree with the argument in the The Transparent Society, and I already see it shifting towards that.
I find it interesting that a company would do this instead of silently reject you…
1. If there were videos of everything stupid he did, there would be no way he would ever get hired.
2. It wasn't anything illegal or violent, so he didn't see it as a character issue.
3. I was honest about it.
Still, Hanlon's Razor applies, and you boss is more than likely just telling the truth.
You'd have leverage if there were a reasonable likelihood that you were the only hiring manager to have this information, but if everyone is on a level playing field, the leverage disappears.
When companies (or governments) try to manipulate employees, they frequently rely on some kind of willful ignorance. Wells Fargo is a great example: they set impossible performance targets and turned a blind eye to fraud, then fired and blacklisted whistleblowers - ostensibly for knowing about that same fraud!
If a shady employer wants leverage, even public events can suffice as long as they can claim ignorance. For example, most stock option grants are immediately lost if you're fired, but even at-will employment can't be terminated specifically to deprive someone of their options. So an employer might give a generous options package, then "discover" the IG video and use it for dismissal at just the right time to prevent a profitable exercise. But if that video comes up during hiring, it's no longer a plausible reason for later dismissal, at least without committing perjury regarding the interview.
I can't even work out a scenario where "lots of people know about this including us" is an effective way to manipulate someone.
For a small enough company? It falls in the same category as "diluting out of one guy's shares" - bad morals and bad business, but it still happens.
I was trash-talking one group of internet people with another group, and the trash talk ended up getting indexed by Lycos or AltaVista. They called me out for being a dick, and I realized that I need to be really careful about what ends up attached to me online. (Also not to trash talk people behind their back..)
This idea is explored further in Nick Bostrom's Vulnerable World Hypothesis under "Preventive policing". It's depressing but does walk through this scenario in more detail than most.
> The vulnerable world hypothesis thus offers a new perspective from which to evaluate the risk‐benefit balance of developments towards ubiquitous surveillance or a unipolar world order.
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1758-5899.1...
Because anyone with a hint of a brain should be able to extrapolate the negatives of such surveillance on their lives. We played dumb long enough on that topic.
If you are not up for that, ok, but you also should not work in a capacity that has any access to private information.
If there are companies or people regularly ignoring privacy, which still is enshrined in most countries laws, severe penalties should be applied. That is also true for the executive branch of government, which was severely neglected the last decade because of fear.
IIRC the russian one from https://yandex.com made headlines a few years ago because it scraped https://vk.com/ which is their fb/twitter-combo thing.
When a big Swiss private bank moved into new premises in a skyscraper in Hong Kong, there was a rumour that they had one unmarked elevator avoiding the building lobby, directly from the underground car park to a private lobby within the bank, for UHNWI. Let’s Clearview there, too!
Going by the way online mobs work, availing these tools to all citizens unencumbered makes possible all kinds of abuses.
In a world where network connected cameras are so cheap they're disposable, no top down surveillance becomes harder to imagine. At some point, information gathering systems become so cheap and ubiquitous that telling organizations not to use them for surveillance is like telling people not to look up at the sky.
Banks used to ask your mother's maiden name as a security question because someone trying to impersonate you would have a hard time finding that information. Now it's a Facebook search away, and many entities still want to use personal identifiable information as security questions.
As a society we need to reevaluate what personal information is private and what is public.
While there are efforts to bring more people to engage in civil society, where we don't wear masks, increasing surveillance will have the opposite effect because of basic self defense mechanisms that shouldn't be to hard to understand in my opinion.
> As a society we need to reevaluate what personal information is private and what is public.
I like to decide that myself and for bureaucratic needs I will supply the minimum amount of data needed for processing.
Edit: Since you used the “information wants to be free” phrase - commonly invoked with the copyright enforcement controversies of the 2000s - it’s important to note how that turned out. From where I sit, I see a lot of large, powerful companies stealing ideas and content from small creators with no repercussions while small creators are under the thumb of automated content ID systems (see YouTube). “Fair Use” in video content is effectively dead - YouTube and their large media “partners” hold all the cards.
When information is “free” those with all the lawyers get to set their own rules.
What I'm saying is, you can't solve privacy issue by hiding information. That is not feasible, as technology progresses, its become easier and easier for information to move.
I acknowledge that there are going to be issue due to our information being public and thats what we should fix instead of trying to hide the information.
Right now it is an issue if my ssn or credit card number become public. The fix should not be by making my ssn or credit card number stay hidden. We should fix it so that even if my ssn or credit card number become public it would not cause me harm.
Another example, right now it is an issue if I post something embarrassing on twitter. The fix should not by deleting/hiding my tweet. We should fix it so that even if my tweet become viral it would not cause me harm.
Anonymity can supply that effortlessly. Some will say it is just pseudonymity and no real anonymity, but I think that is wrong.
If you post with your name, you have become a public persona. Just hinting at the fact that public personas often have staff to manage public relations. You could of course kill that, but the repercussions would be quite severe.
Until the real name leaks, which is only matter of time. Anonymity is what i mean by fixing the issue by hiding the information.
>If you post with your name, you have become a public persona. Just hinting at the fact that public personas often have staff to manage public relations. You could of course kill that, but the repercussions would be quite severe
Yes, right now it is an issue with using real name. We should not fix it by hiding the name, we should fix it so that using real name would not cause harm.
In other words, we should take the information being public as the base condition and solve the problem that arise from that.
That we currently speak very openly on the net is such a treasure. With an open ID it would just end like China. There would be topics you just don't speak about because reputation damage wouldn't make it worth it. That would be a significant loss.
I don't really see problems with anonymity. Privacy is a human need, I certainly will not share it with the world. In fact I actively disengage from any intimacy if a larger public is involved, naturally I would assume. There is little incentive to change that.
I have a public persona that is neatly compartmentalized. With effort you could connect that of course, but in practice nobody has access on the whole. I tend to keep it that way.
Not saying that having a facebook account with all your family photos is equivalent of total transparency. Clear names just don't work that well because numerous practical reasons.
Of course there could be an AI that analyses my writing style or simply has access to all relevant network information. But until that time I hope legislative measures are in place. They already are and companies tread very lightly on handling personal information. It could cost them.
Ok, people said mean things under the veil of anonymity. Big deal. But recent evidence suggests they would do it with their ID in the open just as well.
So yes that is need to be fixed so that we can speak openly even with open ID without the damage you mentioned. Thats the solution that we need to find.
>I have a public persona that is neatly compartmentalized. With effort you could connect that of course, but in practice nobody has access on the whole. I tend to keep it that way
You could but the cost and effort to do that is going to be higher and higher. Not everyone want that, I certainly don't. I don't want to have to compartmentalized my information or hiding my information. It's sucks.
>Clear names just don't work that well because numerous practical reasons.
Yes, I agree right now it is not practical, so that need to be fixed, instead of trying to hide the name.
>Ok, people said mean things under the veil of anonymity. Big deal. But recent evidence suggests they would do it with their ID in the open just as well
Then this issue is nothing to do with privacy.
That is like saying that we have to find a solution to crime and fraud so that we will not have to rely on physical locks, spamfilters, etc.
It would be nice, but it will never happen.
Meanwhile anonymity can work well.
How about we first change the world so that everyone can speak freely without fear of anything. And when that is accomplished to everyones satisfaction then we can consider total transparancy.
That would be great.
>It would be nice, but it will never happen.
Sure, if that the attitude.
>Meanwhile anonymity can work well.
Until it leaks, which only matter of time.
>How about we first change the world so that everyone can speak freely without fear of anything. And when that is accomplished to everyones satisfaction then we can consider total transparancy
You have it backward. To accomplish that goal, one way to achieve that is by total transparency.
Why do you think there is growing acceptance of LGBT? its because growing transparency.
Not just recent evidence. This has been well established by multiple studies over many years now.
I don't see how that is even in the realm of the possible. The issues around this go far beyond the simply reputational.
- total surveillance, of everybody by everybody
- surveillance only by authorities, of the rest of us
The book's premise is that these will be the only choices. The premise may not be correct. But if you start from it, clearly total transparency is better than the alternative.
I do not believe it is correct.
> But if you start from it, clearly total transparency is better than the alternative.
Maybe, but that fact is nearly meaningless. Nobody will have anything like freedom in such a world, regardless of which way it works. Saying that one is better than the other is like saying that this deadly toxin is marginally less effective than that deadly toxin. It's a distinction without a meaningful difference.
I disagree with him on this point. Neither choice he presents is compatible with freedom.
"Welp, we just invented the machine gun. It's so easy to mow people down now we might as well just embrace this new post-machine-gun reality!"
I think it would be very interesting to see what would happen if everyone's financial comings and goings were public information.
Not only would that be dystopian in it's own way (think gossipy small town plus professional trolls powered by big data plus the digital marketing/propaganda industry), but an egalitarian panopticon is just outright fantasy. The rich and very tech savvy have the resources or expertise to cheat. It would not stay egalitarian long.
Arguing that everyone should have those means at their fingertips, in practice, will mean the likelihood of this being used on you goes way up, and that there's no longer even the theoretical oversight that police use would have.
Missed out on a job opportunity or social interaction unfairly? That sucks.
But here we are talking potential for wrongful incarceration. And since some places still have the death penalty, theoretically it could lead to the state killing people based on misidentification.
Really, no, I think this is a fundamentally bad idea. The idea of everyone surveiling everyone else can only be remotely appealing if you pretend there are no power differences in the world and everyone is equal - a fiction that the tech works for whatever reason loves to subscribe to.
In the real world, people will have vastly different amounts of understanding for whatever weird sides you have and their knowledge can have serious consequences. Only because your boss may have some weird sides himself does not necessarily mean that he will be understanding of yours - or that whatever he did will be as equally relevant as what you did.
If everyone else in the world is doing it too, things would be radically different.
Also, how does the power differential not actually equalize? If a cashier at McDonalds can see everything Jeff Bezos does, and Jeff Bezos can see everything the homeless person does, you really think Jeff Bezos is the one getting the better end of the deal?
The arguments traditionally used to prevent private ownership of the kind of arms that let you go toe to toe with a modern military don't really work very well for software.
Maybe I should register forgotten-algorithms.com only my ponytail isn't as long as Ian's
I'm fairly convinced by David Brin's argument that this is exactly the wrong approach. In The Transparent Society he argues that privacy is no longer an option; our choice is between a society where the police surveil us all, and one where we all surveil each other. He says only the latter is compatible with freedom. We have to be able to monitor the cops and the powerful, just like they monitor us.
Maybe we need our own Clearview, with open source face recognition and data on the darknet.