News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by slg on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @05:38PM (#22479408)
I'm not an expert in either this or cryptocurrency, but it always seemed like these two would be a good marriage of technologies rather than having crypto mining rigs waste resources on unproductive proof of work algorithms. Does anyone know why that wasn't feasible or didn't catch on?
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by sjburt on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:03PM (#22479571)
Proof of work relies on computations that are hard to do but easy to check that someone has done. The entire network has to check someone's proposed result. There are very few computations that have sufficient asymmetry to the degree needed to make bitcoin work, and the types of things that SETI@home needs don't fit that bill.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by thaumasiotes on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:17PM (#22479669)
Isn't Folding@Home trying to run an asymmetrical computation, though? The broad strokes as I understand them are that you have a sequence of amines, you arrange them into a three-dimensional protein (the hard part) by whatever method, and then you evaluate the energy bound within your structure (the easier part?). Lower energy is better.

The obvious problem is that there's no judgment of "correct" or "incorrect". Analogizing to a bitcoin proof-of-work, it would be as if a hash beginning with more zeroes always outranked a hash beginning with fewer zeroes, but there was no way to know whether your hash started with "enough" zeroes or not.

Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by wongarsu on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @07:19PM (#22480090)
Protein folding might work as a proof-of-work algorithm. One big problem is of course that it's useful work that could conceivably be monetized.

Proof-of-work works because a theoretical attacker would have to invest huge resources into an attack. For bitcoin it's trivial to say "for attack scenario X an attack has to spend at least Y", and as long as the expected reward is lower than Y the network is safe (that's for example one factor you use to determine how many confirmations you wait before accepting a payment). If the attacker could conceivably gain money outside the cryptocurrency for performing the proof-of-work, that makes the whole calculation less predictable, and likely exposes you to more situations where an attack is actually profitable.

Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by samatman on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @08:26PM (#22480398)
What's needed is a large delta between the value of the work and the value of the currency. It's not a requirement that it be completely wasted computation, that's just how it happens to work right now.

Protein folding, where the value is speculative, cumulative, and difficult to cash out, is an excellent candidate. Especially since the ability to realize the value of a given fold is diminished by openly publishing it, which is a requirement of proof of work; the folding computation thus becomes a positive externality of the cryptocurrency, since everyone can use that knowledge as an economic stimulus.

I'd like to see someone try it.

Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by andai on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @12:13AM (#22481375)
Isn't "maybe I can monetize this protein" less of a sure bet than "I can rewrite these transactions" ?
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by nybble41 on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @10:55AM (#22484765)
An attack on proof-of-work wouldn't let you rewrite arbitrary transactions. At most an attacker could exclude certain recent transactions—most likely their own—reverting payments which were previously deemed "complete" and replacing them with conflicting transactions. All transactions still need to be signed with the proper keys, however, so the attacker can't just lay claim to others' coins.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by tinco on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:28PM (#22479751)
You could incorporate that in a quorum blockchain like Stellar (or Ripple I guess), but the whole point of those is that they remove the need for PoW so that's a bit useless. Maybe it's a cool way to build trust in such a network though..
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by jacobwilliamroy on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:23PM (#22479718)
RE: folding@home, How much money will the medical cartel make off of the fruits of all that free labor? Do users even know what they're folding? How do users know that they're not building bioweapons?
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by dekhn on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:51PM (#22479908)
protein folding simulations don't produce a lot of money for pharma (I say that as somebody with a F@H publication to my name specifically doing research on GPCRs, which are a huge pharma target). users can see what the workunits are doing, and choose subprojects, presumably avoiding bioweapons if that's important to them.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by dmurray on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @08:53PM (#22480538)
How could the average technically savvy user, let's say willing to use Google a bit but not to obtain a biochemistry degree, tell which subprojects are possible bioweapons? Not a rhetorical question.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by dekhn on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @09:13PM (#22480646)
Typically, there is a stated/intended plan for each project. This page lists active projects: https://apps.foldingathome.org/psummary Unfortunately, the project pages return a 502 but Google cache helps: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:q6DvOt...

I'm going to guess that if you inspect each project it has a purported (positive) medical use and you'd have to make a judgement call on each project based on good knowledge of biology as to whether it had a bioweapons application.

I doubt, but cannot say for certain that F@H won't have any projects that are stated as bioweapons and I'm skeptical that somebody working on a bioweapon would try to cloak its intent, and come up with a plausible medical application so they could get free F@H cycles.

I remember the days of logging into national labs supercomputers and seeing the other jobs on the system, such as job_name "submarine_geometry_optimizer" and the user_name was "electric_boat" or something similar.

Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by jacobwilliamroy on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @06:15AM (#22482788)
Thanks for answering my questions which were also not rhetorical.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by ska on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:49PM (#22479893)
For the most part this is fundamental research of the type that is typically funded from public grants, these are not pharma companies... As for what they are contributing too, it's all pretty well documented.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by sprash on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:28PM (#22479750)
The projects Primecoin and Riecoin are digital currencies that try to provide proof of work algorithms with (somewhat) scientific value.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by Forbo on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:37PM (#22479813)
There's GridCoin, as well, which utilizes BOINC for work units.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by tech_man7 on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @11:56PM (#22481315)
Golem (www.golem.network) is building a general-purpose distributed computation platform where people who need compute power pay using cryptocurrency. And developers can build software to run on it (and get paid when it's used).
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by Forbo on Wednesday March 04, 2020 @03:18PM (#22487598)
I vouched for your comment, as it's factually correct near as I can tell. I've been interested in the project, especially since Joanna Rutkowska joined them.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by ahmedbodi on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:32PM (#22479780)
It's already been done in 2 projects. One called Curecoin and another called FoldingCoin, kinda niche i guess. didnt really catch on
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by Forbo on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @06:37PM (#22479810)
There's GridCoin, as well, which utilizes BOINC for work units.
Re:SETI@home shuts down after 21 years by rolltiide on Tuesday March 03, 2020 @09:06PM (#22480616)
There were plenty, basically none of these savants understood economics so they didn't build a demand model, they only built a supply model. So people got paid in coin and just flooded the market until it was worth nothing.

Crypto mining rigs are proving far more productive than Seti or Folding@Home ever did. Economic pressures push the real energy heavy miners into places with renewable energy and also repurposing waste byproducts into electricity, so this is actually one of the most useful and cleanest sector on the planet, ironically the opposite of what people are saying. Protip: Headlines only tell you "how much" energy is being used and not the source, and this is very intentional.