That said, that's roughly what the ACA ("ObamaCare") will likely end up with, if it doesn't get derailed, except that it'll take a few years to get there because 50 states is more complicated than one.
Actually, it could scale reasonably well, but for political reasons wasn't set up that way. So instead, each state will set up its own exchange; I suspect some will be MA-quality, some will be better, some will be poorer.
Note that the reason you can apply for it right away, unlike other state "benefits", is that it's not really a benefit - there's no subsidy (at least, not for self- or startup-employed folks like me who very well can afford it), so there's no real cost to the state of letting 1, 2, or 17000 more people buy in (and in fact there's an advantage, because you increase the risk pool).
I've thought about this a lot because I could easily be in this situation. If I did anything on my own I would need a group plan quickly. You only need 2 people to create a group.
So you can buy insurance its expensive, here is how you do it.
1) Start a company.
2) Hire another employee (this costs a lot)
3) Make a group health insurance policy for the company.
There you bought insurance.
I know this is stupid, but I'm just the kind of person that when someone says "You can't do XXX" I automatically have to see if I can do it.
Also, if you have a group of 2,5,10 or 20, the insurance company has an easier time denying you because if you get pissed and drop them, its not a big loss for them. In contrast, if you deny the right person at a 10,000 person company, they lose a big account.
Another idea I've kicked around: Create a sort-of incubator where, on paper, all of the startup founders and employees are employees of the incubator group. Then the incubator can handle the whole mess of both insurance and income taxes. (Bonus: Since the "incubator" now has a ton of developers on tap, it could double as a consulting agency.)
We do try to take on companies of a minimum size (10+ employees) but sometimes end up taking on companies with 2 or 3 employees because the owner forecasts explosive growth -- which never happens. All that said, it's a freaking battle with the carriers every year to try to keep the increases at a lower rate. Also, we have "rate buckets" where we place clients according to risk and past medical history of its employees. It still tends to work out better than if they would attempt to get insurance on their own.
shudder This is the part where a small employer can basically be forced to find an excuse to dismiss anyone with a serious illness, who is then doubly screwed. A public option would have been so much more humane.
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2009/7/7/751100/-How-I-lost-my...
Also, there are HR-outsourcing companies like TriNet that negotiate as a group for smaller/startup companies[2].
I think a startup that can help tackle this issue would create tremendous value in the payor / consumer market, but the field is extraordinarly complicated and requires a very rare multi-disciplinary background in individual state law (CA's system alone is very different from, say, MA's bc CA is HMO-based and MA has a public option), behavioral economics, gov't regulation, insurance underwriting methods, insurance administrative practices. Oh, and if it's a tech startup, the team would obviously need web dev / product skills as well.
The problem is, developing a basic mastery of all these subjects takes a lot of time -- reading, thinking, and experiencing to understand the pain points deeply. That tends to cut against the stereotypical startup team of two young twenty-somethings hacking away and living on ramen, who have never studied the insurance industry or directly experienced the pain of searching for or relying heavily on health insurance (bc young 20 somethings tend not to have major health problems). I think that's a key reason why startups haven't done much innovation in the insurance payer market.
My latest line of thinking is about whether there are hacks around the problem that can incrementally chip away at and disintermediate insurance payers as the sole gateway to affordable healthcare.
although this is true, the leverage gained through group is different for other services, where a bulk order is much cheaper. Assuming everyone's making rational decisions, the only people that would want insurance would be the high risk ones. Insurance companies would loss money regardless of the rates they charge because the only rational people that would pay it would be the ones that think they would likely benefit from it, since they have additional information (eating habit, risk level, etc ) over the insurance company. By putting a lot of people (high risk and low risk) in a group, the insurance company can balance out the group and make a small gain on top of the expected payout.
My auto insurance company also runs a savings bank for its members and offers loans at markedly better rates than retail banks.
Consumer cooperatives would seem the simplest way to alleviate this issue--no need for additional legislation. To confirm, I live in the US.
If the Republicans are serious about an economic recovery and want startups to flourish, then universal healthcare is a cornerstone of such an effort. I know of other people too who are afraid of leaving their (big-company) positions because they have a wife + young kids, and lack of health insurance terrifies them.
In California you need at least 2 employees to qualify for group coverage. So you start an actual company, perform business (presumably turning in some money to cover your costs), and also get coverage for your dependents. There's one caveat that the coverage does not start until your company has been around for 6 months (unrelated to the pre-existing 6 months figure above.)
Or was the author's post related to (presumably) retiring earlier and specifically not wanting to start a company again?
I'm going to go out on a limb and say money is not an issue for Donna, yet she still can't even buy insurance if she wants to. I've always thought healthcare access was a bigger hurdle for entrepreneurs than tax rates. If I make a lot of money with my startup, great, I really could care less if I pay 15% or 40% of that to the gov't, because it will be a whole lot more than I make now. But not having health care insurance (or worse, having crappy insurance that denies you all the time like most individual plans do) is so damn risky it makes me afraid to step out on my own.