Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by p49k on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:26AM
(#22465148)
We’re not talking about copyright, though - we’re taking about privacy rights, and - even if we discard compelling fair use arguments - everyone who uses Facebook gives them a license to distribute the photos they upload to the site to others for various reasons. Copyright law doesn’t really come into play, and of course much data involved here isn’t even copyrightable.
Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by basch on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:38AM
(#22465247)
its an analogy, im not bringing up copyright law as something that impacts the situation, its an illustration of a similar concept.
Some countries treat photography as copyright as the priority, others let privacy law take precedent.
Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by klingonopera on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:28AM
(#22465162)
I think this is a country- and thus law-specific case.
In Germany, AFAIK, if the picture has less than five people on it, it is considered a photo of you, and both you and the photographer have a copyright on it.
EDIT: Maybe not the entire copyright, but you definitely have a say as the subject in such a photo, including barring it from the public against the photographer's wishes, if you please.
Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by marcus_holmes on Monday March 02, 2020 @11:41AM
(#22465985)
this is true, and we obviously have Model Release Forms for a reason, but the point remains that just because it's a photo of you, it's not your photo.
Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by mcny on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:59PM
(#22471681)
If you explicitly and manually tag me in a photo and it shows up on my profile, it should be a part of my takeout. I don’t understand what you’re having difficulty understanding. I never said use machine learning to comb through all photos ever uploaded to Facebook and add them to my takeout. I don’t think what I’m saying is controversial at all.
Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by LegitShady on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:25AM
(#22465124)
Using the photo commercially may be a breach of copyright. Having a copy I do not think is and likely Facebook could fix that I'm their tos.
Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by marcus_holmes on Monday March 02, 2020 @11:45AM
(#22466020)
The entire music industry fought global legal battles for decades claiming that making a copy of something that someone else holds copyright on, even for your own personal use, is a crime.
I don't think you can waive copyright with a ToS, either. I could be wrong, though.
Re:Facebook's Download-Your-Data Tool Is Incomplete
by icebraining on Monday March 02, 2020 @01:38PM
(#22467307)
You don't "waive" the copyright, you just give Facebook a worldwide, royalty-free, irrevocable, etc, etc license to do whatever they need with the photo, including adding it to the data download archives of the persons pictured.
Our expectations don't match with actual law here.