News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by dx87 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:06PM (#22452704)
It's probably for the best now, but it shouldn't have needed to come to this. In "Call Sign Chaos" by Jim Mattis, he talks about how the Bush and Obama administrations both repeatedly ignored the recommendations of military and intelligence officials. The Bush administration was too cavalier and thought they knew best, the Obama administration was too weak and wanted to score political points by not providing the force that was required. When I was in the Marines, they told us that we shouldn't need to be there, but politicians from the 80s/90s left things such a mess after trying to stop the Soviets, that now we had to go try and clean up the mess created 20 years prior.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by paulryanrogers on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:23PM (#22452822)
What were these recommendations that got ignored?
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by dx87 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:31PM (#22452887)
For the Bush administration, they ignored initial recommendations to work with the locals after the initial invasion, creating a lot of unemployed, angry, young people with military training. For the Obama administration, they ignored recommendations to increase the military presence to a level that they could effectively remove the Taliban. Forces were kept low so they could keep saying "we're bringing the troops home" during speaches. It was like quitting an antibiotic treatment too soon; we eliminated the low hanging fruit, but the Taliban that remained had even better training, and could point to our prescence as a recruiting tool.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by heymijo on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:49PM (#22452996)
> to increase the military presence to a level that they could effectively remove the Taliban

This is easier said than done, if it is possible at all.

Having recently taken a dive into the U.S.' involvement in Vietnam, this argument rings eerily similar the one that got us into and led to our escalation in Vietnam.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by mythrwy on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:19PM (#22453577)
I think these things are more possible than people believe.

If it were truly an existential threat the US would remove the Taliban very quickly (that doesn't imply a safe orderly society would result).

But Afghanistan, like Vietnam is an optional and non-essential conflict at this point with unclear definitions of victory. Maybe "victory" is packing up and going home at this point.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by mturmon on Saturday February 29, 2020 @07:25PM (#22454231)
> ... the US would remove the Taliban very quickly...

No, no, no. The Taliban were broadly distributed throughout Southern Afghanistan, and they had a cross border sanctuary in Pakistan.

For its own reasons (Kashmir and the regional rivalry with India), Pakistan didn’t want to alienate the Taliban, and their military and ISI thus had extensive relations with the Taliban.

The US did not have enough leverage to get Pakistan to shut down the Taliban on its side of the border, and likewise did not want the destabilization of a nuclear state with borders on China and India that would accompany violations of Pakistani sovereignty inherent in large scale bombing.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by smt1 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @10:16PM (#22454891)
> No, no, no. The Taliban were broadly distributed throughout Southern Afghanistan, and they had a cross border sanctuary in Pakistan.

I guess it depends on your definition of "remove". I don't doubt that a Taliban government could be very quickly overthrown by the US military. Probably within weeks. Now, the Taliban as an irregular militia is a completely different manner.

I remember watching a Vice documentary on Afghanistan called "This is what winning looks like". The line that struck me was a US Marine saying something like "the average Taliban fighter fights within 15 yards of their home". If that's anything close to true, no wonder the Taliban have been so hard to defeat.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by Spearchucker on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:50PM (#22453758)
The Russians also thought victory in Afghanistan was possible. Their humiliation was absolute.

The US' mistake was not capitalizing on Russia's failure, choosing instead to make exactly the same mistake.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by anarazel on Saturday February 29, 2020 @08:03PM (#22454396)
I don't think that was inevitable. If the Bush admin hadn't fucked up on such a grandiose scale after the invasion the result could have looked quite different (still surely far from pretty).
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by anarazel on Saturday February 29, 2020 @07:46PM (#22454322)
There were over 100k US troops deployed to Afghanistan at the peak (part of 2010-2011). Between 2009 and 2013 it was over 50k.

The Soviet Union deployed over 115k for several years. The amount of fortune spent was a serious accelerator for the decline of the USSR.

Afghanistan is a large, dispersed, and landlocked country. With huge amounts of weapons from many sides. Decades of war. Little trust between population groups.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by onetimemanytime on Sunday March 01, 2020 @12:57AM (#22455376)
>>If it were truly an existential threat the US would remove the Taliban very quickly (that doesn't imply a safe orderly society would result).

With what, nukes? Or by sending 5 million soldiers using $400/gallon gasoline https://www.cbsnews.com/news/real-cost-of-gas-at-afghan-base... ? Like them or not, the Taliban are in their country and quite a few Afghani think like them. Let them be, with a major caveat--do not let anyone there attack us or our partners. I think they are rational enough to do that since USA did cause them a lot of problems.

They are so many problems in the world, USA cannot fix them. Not even make a dent.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by taejo on Sunday March 01, 2020 @03:28AM (#22455804)
Just FYI, Afghanis are units of currency; citizens of Afghanistan are Afghans.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by onetimemanytime on Sunday March 01, 2020 @04:55AM (#22456142)
Thanks, didn't mean it as an insult (if it is https://www.thefreedictionary.com/afghanis )
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by dennisgorelik on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:21PM (#22453929)
> Maybe "victory" is packing up and going home at this point.

In case of Afghanistan, it is not just "maybe". Packing up and go home - is a clear win for the US in Afghanistan.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by warlog on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:34AM (#22456264)
Clear win. Like Vietnam.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by throwaway22920 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:50PM (#22452997)
Troop levels in Afghanistan kept increasing for the first decade of the war[1]. If a decade is considered "too soon," what should be considered "too long"?

[1] https://www.npr.org/2016/07/06/484979294/chart-how-the-u-s-t...

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by tmpz22 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @07:43PM (#22454311)
I've picked up a lot of anecdotes from various serviceman about the war in Afghanistan and I wonder how much of it is true.

> work with the locals after the initial invasion

1) Isn't it an ongoing meme in the US military that ANA troops are useless and that the government is corrupt to an unimaginable level?

2) Didn't we also originally burn their opium fields, only to allow it to become once again one of there chief economic exports since it was so vital to the local economies?

3) Is it true we had a formal policy of allowing elder tribal leaders to systematically rape young boys in order to be more accommodating to their local customs? Including trading viagra for tips on insurgent activity?

I realize some of these questions are pretty sensitive and may be uncomfortable to answer. It just seems like it needs to be brought up whenever we talk about the Afghan war (while it's usually swept under the rug...).

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by nradov on Saturday February 29, 2020 @10:55PM (#22455024)
You shouldn't be downvoted. This exactly matches what most experienced troops report.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by jorblumesea on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:11PM (#22453135)
> increase the military presence to a level that they could effectively remove the Taliban

With Pakistan providing huge financial and logistical support to the Taliban, it would never be eliminated. Geopolitical experts understand that so long as Pakistan has the India problem, Afghanistan will have the Taliban as a buffer state.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by smt1 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @10:23PM (#22454916)
Historically, the Pakistani intelligence forces have armed various mujahideen groups, both in Afghanistan, and in Indian Kashmir. Meanwhile, the Afghani government post-911 has been fairly close to India.

This hasn't been true as much recently because the Taliban and other groups became extremely powerful in Pakistan, especially in Pashtun tribal areas, and the Pakistani military was forced to intervene. However, the Pakistani military has never been able to completely corral their intelligence services, which is one reason why there isn't as much cooperation between the US and Pakistan anymore (they were once close allies), with US/India ties becoming closer and closer instead.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by jdeibele on Saturday February 29, 2020 @07:28PM (#22454240)
China is supposed to back North Korea because it acts as a buffer between China and South Korea.

Pakistan is between Afghanistan and India. https://www.atlapedia.com/online/maps/political/Afghan_etc.h... I'm confused as to how it would be a buffer. Can you explain?

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by anarazel on Saturday February 29, 2020 @07:57PM (#22454361)
One of the recurring complains / concerns of Pakistan is/was that Afghanistan post invasion was cooperating too much with India. From what I understand (which is certainly very limited) that was more fear than reality. But from the POV of Pakistan's,hugely anti-India, military, it's not that hard to understand how being encircled by India and a "puppet state" is seen as threatening.

I think there's pretty good evidence that the ISI has (does?) financed/organized training camps for anti India groups (like Lashkar-e-Taiba) in Afghanistan.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by jorblumesea on Saturday February 29, 2020 @09:17PM (#22454664)
A few reasons.

1) Fear of Indian sponsored proxies and being squeezed from both sides. An India friendly Afghanistan presents an existential danger to Pakistan's interests. Pakistan does not want to be encircled by hostile powers.

2) An unstable Afghanistan means possible anti-Pakistan elements taking root. Better to sponsor known "pakistan friendly" elements like the Taliban instead of unknowns.

3) Defense in depth. Pakistani military and political doctrine would use Afghanistan as a redoubt. Most of Pakistan is extremely flat until you get to the Hindu Kush/Pamir mountains. The idea would be, let India steamroll the flat lands, retreat into the mountains and cross the durand line, coordinate the response from Afghanistan.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by anarazel on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:57PM (#22453045)
Re bush: They also refused to negotiate / reintegrate the Taliban, in particular early on when they were weak (yes, there's a lot of parallels to Iraq). Once the Iraq war started there was very little attention paid to Afghanistan, for several years. Including very little effort building up security architecture.

Re Obama: there clearly was a lot wrong with the Afghanistan policy. But I'm not sure I really buy the "low troop level" argument. Even at peak deployment levels (pretty darn high) under Obama the military operations weren't going particularly well. And that wasn't sustainable.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by jeremysalwen on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:22PM (#22453185)
I mean, 7-15 years after the initial invasion? It's hard for me to believe that after 20 years the recommendation wouldn't still be the same.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by mcguire on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:56PM (#22453419)
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by adultSwim on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:42AM (#22465294)
they ignored initial recommendations to work with the locals after the initial invasion, creating a lot of unemployed, angry, young people with military training

We then saw this play out to devastating effect with the de-Baathication agenda in Iraq.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by empath75 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:57PM (#22453421)
> they ignored recommendations to increase the military presence to a level that they could effectively remove the Taliban

I am extremely skeptical that any feasible amount of troops on the ground could have achieved such a goal.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by vkou on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:00PM (#22453073)
> For the Obama administration, they ignored recommendations to increase the military presence to a level that they could effectively remove the Taliban.

1. Of course the military would ask for this, and complain after the fact.

2. It's easy for generals to make promises, but I have zero confidence that they would have actually delivered any results.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by Balgair on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:52PM (#22454082)
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by anm89 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:22PM (#22452815)
>When I was in the Marines, they told us that we shouldn't need to be there, but politicians from the 80s/90s left things such a mess after trying to stop the Soviets, that now we had to go try and clean up the mess created 20 years prior.

This is of course true but you can play this fallacy out forever. The right thing to do in the 80s was not to meddle. Then after that we should have cut our losses and stopped meddling. And now 40 years later we are cleaning up failed clean up attempts on failed clean up attempts.

At every point in this chain, the correct move is to admit you can't be world police and stop meddling.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ggm on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:27PM (#22452859)
left things such a mess after trying to stop the Soviets

So much contained in this one sentence. People need to go look at what backing an insurgency against a repressive but modernising government does and ask questions.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pjc50 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:36PM (#22453681)
The effect of backing the mujahadeen on the actual Afghans was, I'm sure, never in the picture.

(Anyone remember the Living Daylights where James Bond teams up with the Oxford-educated Afghan head of the local islamists to beat the Russians together?)

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ggm on Sunday March 01, 2020 @02:41AM (#22455699)
One might say the whole effect of the domino theory was to justify US military intervention against Russia and every single place they did, it backfired.

Iran, the oil backed coup of the 1950s led to Pahlavi, hatred and fear which in turn led to Kohmeni in Paris. Simply letting the Iranians nationalise the oil industry would probably have been better long-term.

1953 to 2020, US oil interests stuffing up peace...

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by wahern on Sunday March 01, 2020 @04:17AM (#22455985)
> One might say the whole effect of the domino theory was to justify US military intervention against Russia and every single place they did, it backfired.

A few counter examples: Greece, [South] Korea, Malaysia, Philippines, Indonesia.

Chile is another well known example, though IMO U.S. involvement is wildly exaggerated. AFAIU, it was conservatives in the Chilean Congress that engineered and pushed for the coup. The prospect of American support (e.g. a wink from the CIA) simply made it a marginally easier sell among the people whose heads might roll if it failed.

None of which is a defense of the Domino Theory or a comment on the merits of intervention. The take away from all of this, IMO, is to avoid grand strategic theories and goals--context matters.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ggm on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:03AM (#22456167)
If you think Phillipines or Indonesia worked, I think you're wrong. Both have systemic corruption, massive structural issues and lingering left wing and Islamic rebellion. Indonesia killed millions in their counter communist reaction. Greece I grant you, "worked" within the limits you aren't a left wing Greek. The US wound up having to play in Greece and Turkey simultaneously, nobody is happy in the middle east really.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by wahern on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:48AM (#22456302)
> If you think Phillipines or Indonesia worked, I think you're wrong. Both have systemic corruption, massive structural issues and lingering left wing and Islamic rebellion.

Both of those countries would have had systemic corruption and massive structural issues either way, just as they had before. U.S. intervention doesn't really figure into it. Anyhow, the goal was to stop the spread of communism, not lift people out of poverty.

The genocide of "communists" (i.e. Chinese and other outgroups) in Indonesia was absolutely abhorrent and a gross moral failure on the part of the U.S. But from the perspective of American geopolitical interests intervention wasn't a failure. It almost certainly wasn't even necessary, either, but that's beside the point.

Non-intervention has its own problems, too, as exemplified by Cambodia, Rwanda, and Syria[1]. Intervention vs non-intervention is a false dichotomy. To reiterate, context matters.

[1] I've said before on HN that I think Obama's refusal to directly intervene in Syria showed exceptional leadership, notwithstanding his about-face; indeed, because of his about-face. But that doesn't absolve the U.S. of its sins for having created the conflagration in the Middle East that resulted in the Syrian conflict. What Obama finally accepted, but everybody else refused to admit (including his own advisors), was that the U.S. was politically incapable of making the necessary commitments. Had the U.S. been capable--i.e. if the context were different--then greater intervention would have been the correct thing. What makes his decision so profound to me was that he accepted that reality at a moment when denial was easiest--when everybody felt it was the morally righteous thing to do (and arguably was), everybody wanted it, and when after it inevitably led to more bloodshed nobody would have ever blamed him, neither contemporaneously nor in the future.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ggm on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:24AM (#22456238)
I suppose they "worked" in as much as US economic benefits ensued.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by Udik on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:35PM (#22453265)
> you can't be world police

Off topic, but the whole concept of "world police" is just spin. A police force is one that enforces equally laws established by others. You cannot be at the same time the one who establishes the rules and who decides when and where to use force against those who break them. This is just arbitary use of violence.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by dx87 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:36PM (#22452916)
I don't know if it's really fair to say that after 9/11 we were playing world police when we invaded Afghanistan. They were harboring Al Qaeda who had been carrying out smaller scale attacks on US assets for a while, culminating with 9/11. At that point you can't just ignore them and hope they stop; they'd been escalating violence for years.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by mturmon on Saturday February 29, 2020 @07:33PM (#22454259)
The Bush administration did let the mission in Afghanistan creep from crippling al Qaeda, to reconstructing Afghan society so that al Qaeda could not return. This is what pulled us in to trying to dismantle the Taliban as well. Remember that Taliban and al Qaeda are distinct.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by boomboomsubban on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:52PM (#22453763)
What you describe sounds a lot like the police breaking into a house to arrest an alleged criminal.

>At that point you can't just ignore them and hope they stop; they'd been escalating violence for years.

If you can't ignore the problem, then drastically escalate the violence on your own?

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pjc50 on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:51PM (#22454080)
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by craftinator on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:43PM (#22452966)
We invaded Iraq because of 9/11, not Afghanistan. That came later.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by aibara on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:49PM (#22452994)
What? The U.S. invaded Afghanistan first, in 2001. Iraq came in 2003.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by krapp on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:57PM (#22453047)
We were always going to invade Iraq, as soon as GWB and Dick Cheney were elected it was inevitable. 9/11 just provided a convenient opportunity to manufacture the pretext by implying links between Iraq Intelligence and the hijackers.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by clarkmoody on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:09PM (#22453119)
The only winning move is not to play.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ghisler on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:12PM (#22453538)
Thanks for registering WinRAR. <3
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by pbhjpbhj on Sunday March 01, 2020 @05:03AM (#22456168)
"World police". I used to buy that, but the more I've learnt the more it seems it was just "corrupt this country for our own ends", covert control seemingly to support megalomania.

USA has certainly done a good job of pretending to be the good guy, whilst simultaneously arming bad guys and killing to support Capitalist and tyrannical goals.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by m0zg on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:37PM (#22452925)
Not just for now, it's the best decision the US government has made since 1973 Vietnam War withdrawal. Not one, but _three_ superpowers were defeated in Afghanistan: Britain, USSR and the US. You can't win a land war against insurgents who are spread out, have religious zeal about their fight, and don't mind dying. Or to be more precise you can, but you'd have to raze everything to the ground and kill everyone, which, while doable, does not seem like a good idea in this day and age.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by jmpman on Sunday March 01, 2020 @11:00AM (#22457378)
Maybe if you raze everything to the ground, and kill everyone, you can then offer the land to the Russians.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by AndrewKemendo on Saturday February 29, 2020 @03:31PM (#22452882)
I've been totally demoralized over nearly two decades of being AD, reserve and a civilian, at the level to which appointees and senior defense civilians just completely ignore those of us who have actual, ya know, experience with war.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by dehrmann on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:46PM (#22453736)
> the Obama administration was too weak

In hindsight, withdrawing from Iraq left a void that ISIS filled.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by ajross on Saturday February 29, 2020 @05:58PM (#22453804)
Seems like invading and destroying the pre-existing government of Iraq left the void, no?

I mean, if you drill a hole in the bottom of a bathtub and then stand there with your thumb in it to hold the water in, you don't blame the fact that it drained on your getting tired and pulling out your hand.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by dehrmann on Saturday February 29, 2020 @07:01PM (#22454134)
The US filled enough of the void, especially post-surge, for things to be stable.

When the US invaded Iraq, there were a decent amount of protests against it, and generally, Americans grew to see it as a mistake. What's different here is this connection gets a lot less attention, and it was arguably worse for the region.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by SlowRobotAhead on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:16PM (#22453907)
Hussein did a good job of keeping his thumb on the region, yes. But... when we took Iraq and Afghanistan, it was farmers with AK47s, Toyota Hilux trucks, and fertilizer IEDs.... when we “left” Iraq under Obama, we came back to ISIS with US military M16s, US Humvees, and high grade explosives.

We didn’t make ISIS... we just armed them very well (via Iraqi “security”).

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by xzel on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:28PM (#22453226)
I'm not a picking sides politically, but I see this as a perfect microcosm of problems of those two presidencies. I always thought during Obama's term it was a problem we got ourselves into and couldn't just leave, however much I don't think we should be interfering/policing other countries the way we did in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by anarazel on Saturday February 29, 2020 @08:02PM (#22454393)
It doesn't seem surprising that it's portrayed that way, given that it's from a (former) high up member of the military. It's not like failures tend to be popular. There's plenty accounts describing it largely as a failure of the military too.

Found the two Afghanistan books by Steve Coll interesting. Certainly not flattering of any group involved.

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by lonelappde on Saturday February 29, 2020 @06:31PM (#22453976)
I'm curious which military thinks their executive is a great strategist, and in general who thinks their non-techie boss knows better than they do.

Did Mattis also disagree with bombing weddings and assassnating "males of fighting age"?

Re:U.S. Signs Peace Deal with Taliban by almost_usual on Saturday February 29, 2020 @04:09PM (#22453120)
Thank you for your service!