Re:Why the Gov.uk Design System team changed the input type ...
by Dylan16807 on Friday February 28, 2020 @04:08PM
(#22446376)
> Note that my post isn't limited to credit card inputs
Not your entire post, but the part about the '-' key was pretty specific and narrow-scoped.
> What I'm advocating is a focus on ensuring the user's explicit intent rather than attempting to infer intent or making hidden assumptions that either could be wrong or exist to make things easier for the developer.
'explicit intent' sounds like a nice goal but asking the user inside the form is not going to give you good info, and it will very often annoy them.
> only to discover the sanitizing/filtering rules were wrong and the original data provided by the user was lost because the only thing stored was the result of those rules
It wouldn't hurt to store the original. Even if the user told you what they meant, they might have said the wrong thing.
Not your entire post, but the part about the '-' key was pretty specific and narrow-scoped.
> What I'm advocating is a focus on ensuring the user's explicit intent rather than attempting to infer intent or making hidden assumptions that either could be wrong or exist to make things easier for the developer.
'explicit intent' sounds like a nice goal but asking the user inside the form is not going to give you good info, and it will very often annoy them.
> only to discover the sanitizing/filtering rules were wrong and the original data provided by the user was lost because the only thing stored was the result of those rules
It wouldn't hurt to store the original. Even if the user told you what they meant, they might have said the wrong thing.