News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Riseup by aneth on Sunday February 20, 2011 @05:06AM (#2241562)
As much as I admire the effort to provide tools to oppressed people, I would strongly oppose this group. Capitalism and market economics are the single greatest tool for raising living standards, liberating people from oppression, and unleashing human creativity for the common good. Destruction of capitalism would bring the worst forms of oppression, from ignorance, to disease, to fascism.
Re:Riseup by Qz on Sunday February 20, 2011 @12:43PM (#2242427)
The single greatest tool for raising living standards is human ingenuity, which has been around for thousands upon thousands of years longer than capitalism has been around. Capitalism has its pros, but it also has substantial cons, and it's dangerous to go around blindly proclaiming capitalism as the solution to the world's woes.
Re:Riseup by aneth on Sunday February 20, 2011 @03:35PM (#2242967)
At it's core, capitalism is an incentive system to innovate and distribute innovation. Human ingenuity is not sufficient in-and-of itself. Without being rewarded for giving your innovations to others, inventions are less likely to arise or be widely adopted.
Re:Riseup by mcantelon on Sunday February 20, 2011 @03:07PM (#2242862)
I think it depends on what kind of capitalism you're talking about. Capitalism in a truly free market, in which all players are equal, is one thing, but crony capitalism, in which oligarchs use the state to keep the game rigged in their favor, is not conducive to innovation. Capitalism without oligarchy seems to me as much of a fantasy as communism without an oppressive state.
Re:Riseup by aneth on Sunday February 20, 2011 @03:28PM (#2242940)
That's corruption, not capitalism. And corruption is far worse in non-capitalist states, although the spoils are much smaller in magnitude. And I'm not opposed to regulation or in favor of pure laissez faire markets.

I would add an important point though. In China, 300 million people have been lifted out of poverty in 30 years, a modern miracle, simply by introducing well regulated capitalism to the economy. This despite the fact that billions are siphoned off through corruption and "crony capitalism." Many will look at this and rightly point out how unfair and unjust this is, however most Chinese would rather have a few, even many, rich corrupt official than the old state run distribution system, because now is overwhelmingly better for most Chinese than then. The overall effect is enormously positive, and nitpicking corruption that falls through the cracks is misguided. Corruption unjustly gives some more wealth than they deserve in every country - capitalism just means the pie is bigger.

Re:Riseup by mcantelon on Sunday February 20, 2011 @07:01PM (#2243605)
True... and as China is lifted out of poverty, the US standard of living is decreasing because those who have capital are leveraging their capital against those without (enabled by a lack of regulation which is, in turn, a result of corruption).

It seems that in speaking of "capitalism", some are speaking of capitalism as a distribution system (which is entirely sensible) and some are speaking of Capitalism as a philosophy (which, more or less, idealizes the law of the jungle). My guess is that Riseup is speaking of "capitalism" in the latter sense (and, if so, adding "unregulated" to their wording would clarify their position).

Re:Riseup by aneth on Sunday February 20, 2011 @08:26PM (#2243837)
I think that might be an ambitious guess regarding Riseup's intentions - they don't make any such distinction. They demonstrate a typical uninformed, knee-jerk, radical anarchist philosophy.

For reference, a definition of capitalism:

"An economic system in which investment in and ownership of the means of production, distribution, and exchange of wealth is made and maintained chiefly by private individuals or corporations, especially as contrasted to cooperatively or state-owned means of wealth."

I don't agree that the US standard of living is decreasing "because those who have capital are leveraging their capital against those without." In fact, the US has an extraordinary high standard of living, far better than 20 years ago (just look at a grocery store, your average automobile or home, or what people do on vacation.) If it is plateauing or declining the last few years, it is for other reasons, including:

- An unrealistic increase over the last 10 years built on credit. It will take a few years before our economy catches up with that. - A wasteful and destructive government education system rotting for lack a free enterprise and undermining our economy as a whole. - Wasteful government spending and borrowing - trillions of dollars spent on corruption and war.

Nobody is using capital "against" anyone - I'm not even sure precisely whbat it means, yet I'm quite sure it's false.

Re:Riseup by mcantelon on Monday February 21, 2011 @02:00AM (#2244573)
>I think that might be an ambitious guess regarding Riseup's intentions - they don't make any such distinction.

Perhaps, although I've never met an anarchist calling for a centrally planned economy. Most anarchists have jobs and use money and some even run businesses. They're primarily against coercion and abuse perpetrated by the state and corporations rather than against people buying and selling things per se.

>the US has an extraordinary high standard of living, far better than 20 years ago

We're a few years into a global recession, with massive job losses and unemployment. It seems counter-intuitive that this leads to an increase in the standard of living.

>Nobody is using capital "against" anyone - I'm not even sure precisely what it means, yet I'm quite sure it's false.

I would say the recent economic collapse is a fairly good example of the use of capital agressively. Those who introduced derivatives into the market did so by more or less paying government representatives to remove legislative barriers.

A less dramatic example would be the stereotypical Wal-Mart using its capital to dominate local markets, wiping out existing local enterprise.

Re:Riseup by jhancock on Sunday February 20, 2011 @10:25AM (#2242023)
I'm with you if you simply take the 'ism' off capital. The ism part implies or at least condones extremism. Capital is a fine tool; one which can and is being abused. A little moderation goes a long way.
Re:Riseup by jscn on Sunday February 20, 2011 @08:59PM (#2243910)
"Free people create free markets. Free markets do not necessarily create free people.” - Gupta’s Libertarian Observation
Re:Riseup by Confusion on Sunday February 20, 2011 @03:45PM (#2243002)
Free reigning capitalism ends in a single party monopolizing essential supplies. Be the first to monopolize drinking water or oil production and most will do your bidding, lest their living standard plummets. You can leverage the power you have gained and obtain more monopolies. It will mean slavery and eugenic programs; the worst of all dystopias combined.

Capitalism is amoral and must be kept in check by a government that looks after its people and upholds their moral standards. Otherwise, it ends in what is essentially a monarchy, but worse, because driven only to acquire more capital, with no regards for any morals at all.

Re:Riseup by aneth on Sunday February 20, 2011 @08:28PM (#2243843)
Yes, regulation and anti-monopoly laws are essential to capitalism. However being in favor of sensible regulation is utterly different from advocating the abolition of capitalism.