California has 39,512,223 people and 441,900 homes sold in 2018. https://journal.firsttuesday.us/home-sales-volume-and-price-...
Texas has 28,995,881 people and 344,030 homes sold in 2018. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/texas-housing-marke...
Florida has 21,477,737 people and 277,827 homes sold in 2018. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/flas-housing-market...
New York State has 19,453,561 people and 134,066 homes sold in 2018. https://www.democratandchronicle.com/story/news/politics/alb...
I used 2018 data because I couldn't find consistent 2019 data for all those states.
California has 1 house sold for every 89 people and Texas has 1 house sold for every 84 people, Florida has 1 house sold for every 77 people and New York state had 1 house sold for every 145 people.
Per capita, the rate of housing sales in California is not so disparate compared to the other large states, so anti-Prop 13 people need to come up with real data to show how Prop 13 is actually affecting things instead of whining about how existing home owners don't pay their fair share.
There's nothing to suggest that Prop 13 has affected real estate transactions in California. And especially in the Bay Area, the amount of turnover is healthy. In my city alone, I used Redfin to calculate that about 50% of the homes changed hands over the last 10 years. That means that the property tax was getting reset to more current levels.
If you look at the property tax rate that California pays, it's higher than Florida and New York, but less than Texas. However, Texas doesn't have state income tax, so overall the taxes being paid in California are exorbitant compared to other states.
I don’t want to imply that you are being intentionally withholding of data, as I don’t believe that — what I’m saying is that this type of analysis is quite hard to do correctly, accounting for all the factors in play!
There is real research and data backing my statement. This kind of stuff has been published in serious economics journals for years now. There's no reason to rely on back-of-the-envelope estimates of housing turnover. Please take a look:
Do some people have a massive advantage? Sure, just like everything else. But I prefer to have property tax stability because as I get older, if I get priced out of my house because I can't afford my property tax because Googlers and Facebook employees are raising the house prices, that would be completely unfair.
10% for homeowners, hardly the smoking gun.
It’s not clear how an extra year of ownership between sales would cause home prices to skyrocket, especially compared with the dramatic imbalance between new development and in-migration to California’s urban centers!
SF, for example, built 24k new units since 2010, but added 83k new people. I’m willing to bet that more than 83k people would’ve moved in had SF built more housing!
To fetch rent, you typically need to build something, which requires capital. Even if you have capital, opportunity cost might make it more profitable to invest it in something else. Even if building something is best alternative at the moment, expectations of change in future market conditions might make the risk-adjusted return too low to justify the opportunity cost. If you don’t have capital, you need to take a loan, which might not be possible depending on your personal financial situation and credit worthiness, but even if it is, it makes the whole business even more risky.
Now, given it’s California, even if you have capital and actually want to build something, it might as well turn out that your development efforts might be stuck in a local planing and zoning committee limbo for a decade, and often be ultimately unsuccessful, which results in lots of money lost and opportunity cost paid.
As you can see, there are plenty of reasons why you might forgo potential rent.
Say your property tax should be $10,000 per year, but you're paying $1,000 because of Prop 13.
If you were to put an addition on, with a value of $200,000, you'd have to pay property tax on that ($2,000 per year), but they wouldn't reassess the whole property and make you pay $12,000, I assume?
They only assess the changes.
It makes sense.
Otherwise if you're paying $1000 per year in property taxes (instead of $12,000) and you put new countertops in, you'd be hit with a massive reassessment.
They even give an example in their fact sheet[2]. Adding two bedrooms would add $200,000 to your base assessment which is set by Prop 13.
[1]https://www.sfassessor.org/property-information/homeowners/n... [2]https://www.sfassessor.org/sites/default/files/uploaded/ARS_...
Kitchen - structural changes, upgrading of plumbing and/or electrical systems, changing the floor plan, increasing the size, replacing cabinets, countertops, flooring or built-in appliances with upgraded material and finishes
Replacing old countertops with same material, but new, would trigger an assessment, but upgrading them would.
Prop 13 is not why California doesn't have enough housing. This is a lie propagated by teachers unions who flood internet forums with falsehoods.
California's problem is there are hundreds and hundreds of little "cities" each with their own restrictive zoning laws.
They need the state to overrule zoning laws and allow denser housing.
These local cities also cut "sweetheart deals" for companies and give them property tax breaks. So Apple or Facebook or anyone building a new campus pays bargain rates -- not because of Prop 13, but because the local cities have the ability to negotiate tax rates for these companies to encourage them to move in.
Also, I'll add that these places are often owned by a trust. Someone in Florida is getting a check (they need) every month, and they aren't bothering the trustees to maximize the investment potential.
These houses alone aren't enough to solve the housing crisis, but they are a symptom of the disastrous tax policy.
It's enough to make me into a full Georgist, and hope for all land rents to be taxed away.
If you're only paying $5000 per year in property taxes on a plot of land worth $2M and going up, why not?
A single property with a long-term lease signed during an economic boom can pay the taxes for many vacant properties. That’s my guess as to why property owners insist on charging high rents even if it contributes to the epidemic of vacant storefronts in my neighborhood.
https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/opinion/commentary/sd-u...
No reason to give corporations preferential treatment on property taxes
> meant that new housing could cost cities more in services than it would bring in through taxes.
New or resold houses reset tax to current rate. Yes, there is this provision to transfer low prop tax to another house elsewhere in the state/county if you are above 55, but that is unrelated to Prop 13
Prop 13 is evil, it helps prop owning businesses mainly and makes it slightly more affordable for a bunch of folks to keep the house as a rental unit instead of selling. But in the end, state/schools lose the most.
Which means the house is taxed appropriately 1 year in 13. The rest of the time? The city's underwater.
https://www.valuepenguin.com/how-long-homeowners-stay-in-the...
https://www.lincolninst.edu/research-data/data-toolkits/sign...
I believe we have the most powerful notion of direct democracy which is why our voting demographics get the biggest tax cuts
Good take right here but it's not the main reason that prop 13 is making housing expensive imo. The insane market distortions causing landowners to never sell and instead stay put and NIMBY like mad is a larger reason that Prop 13 makes housing more expensive.