Note that Amazon has to charge state sales tax these days too, as do many other online retailers. So "buying out of state" is going to be pretty hard. People's eBay or Craigslist game might get interesting though with the new margins.
As much as California is one of the few states that might be progressive enough to attempt this, it'd be far better if a less populated (and smaller) state attempted UBI first. If Montana torches it's economy, it's probably a lot easier to reassemble than California's.
One nice thing about California's economy is that it's robust. There's probably enough economic activity that this wouldn't totally fuck us, but the ramifications are surely much stronger than the legislator who threw this together has considered.
"The bill would authorize the department to adopt regulations to implement the program" makes it kinda sound a bit like a Brexit vote, in that the bill is really only meant to get everyone to vote to agree to do it, and then the precise details of how you'd actually implement it would be attended to later.
UBI is a popular idea, but the way you see it isn't the popular version of it, at least in California. I only know this because I had the same misconception.
I suppose by this you mean that the Californian is going to pay a higher price for out-of-state purchases compared to if they were based outside of California?
I'd be curious to see a way of doing this that didn't depend on the arbitrary "X dollars per month" stipulation and was instead just "we're putting in this tax, whatever we pull in each month will be evenly split among the citizens". If nothing else, it would allow us to get our feet wet with UBI without people worrying about it not being financially feasible.
Giving each adult $1k costs $32 billion a month.
Assuming none of GDP is attributable to the exclusions, the program seems mostly possible, at a cursory glance. Not fully funded, but reasonably close to fully funded.
The state currently spends $220 billion a year. This program would be a substantial increase to the state's expenditures, more than doubling them.
($320 billion x 10% vat = $32 billion revenue / 32 million people = $1000 per person per month)
That just over $3.8 trillion per year of California spending that needs to be taxed at 10%.
So the overall tax impact isn't my concern.
My concern is why do this at all if just routes money through the state treasury then back into consumers' pockets?
Unless, the UBI is highly distributive,taking money from the well-to-do and giving it to the poor.
But...if it's highly re-distribute then that will incentivize the rich to leave the state and incentivize the poor to come, over time that's not sustainable.
Having said all this, I still 100% support the idea behind a UBI, I just don't think we're ready to implement on a national level much less a state level.
s/highly distributive,taking money from the well-to-do and giving it to the poor/Forced wealth redistribution
Buy a $5.50 cup of coffee? You get charged $5.98 (after the existing 8.75% sales tax) and the merchant gets $5 (because 10% of the advertised price is VAT).
That's not how VAT works in any country I'm aware of. As a freelancer I don't pay VAT for any expenses. Practically, companies often pay VAT and collect it from their customers for the government. But if they pay more then they collect they get a refund.
I can't tell if you're hypothesizing about future taxes or just didn't read the bill.
My first thought: can this possibly be solvent? There are apx. 32 million adults in California. Are there $32 billion spent per month in-state on things that aren't those common categories?
Then I realized that this includes business purchases. Everything sold in California would become 10% more expensive. There'd be a huge incentive to buy from out-of-state, and a huge disincentive for out-of-state purchasers to buy from California merchants.
I also wonder what it does to the population/demographics over time. If you're poor in another state, there are 12,000 new reasons per adult per year to move to California.
Including B2B purchases, could the current California economy absorb $32 billion per month in additional taxes? Even if it could, this would pervert the economics of the state so badly it's hard to know what the effects would be over time.