News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by PaulHoule on Friday February 18, 2011 @09:55AM (#2235586)
Ugh. You can pave the Earth with solar panels and wind farms or you can save the Earth with nuclear energy.

Intermittent renewables aren't a complete solution to our energy needs because they aren't available when we need them. They either need to be supplemented with fossil fuels or we'd need to build an energy storage system that would cost as much, if not more, than the energy production system.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by stcredzero on Friday February 18, 2011 @10:02AM (#2235619)
Intermittent renewables aren't a complete solution to our energy needs because they aren't available when we need them.

In a lot of places in the world, solar energy is more available generally when it's most needed.

That said, I'm all for non-intermittent renewables. Newer geothermal and tide-energy and wave-energy technologies could fit the bill. We could also develop infrastructure that would allow us to lob bulk cargoes cheaply into orbit, which would bypass the unfavorable economics of the rocket equation and enable orbital solar power.

I'm also for saving the earth with newer nuclear technology. (Thorium wouldn't carry the proliferation risk of current breeder reactors.)

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by PaulHoule on Friday February 18, 2011 @12:03PM (#2236211)
A modern FBR that uses commercial plutonium as a starting fuel and with no external blanket could breed with a ratio around 1.0 and, at all points in the fuel cycle, have the Pu be so contaminated with Pu-238, Pu-240 and Pu-241 that weapons use would be impossible.

In fact, sodium cooled cartridge reactors are considered so proliferation resistant that they could be deployed to places where they could fall into enemy hands. Not only is the material inside not usable for weapons, but people trying to get the fuel out would probably be killed by a sodium fire.

Now there's another risk that a government could use FBR technology to construct a system for creating weapons plutonium. For instance, a country like Iran could use an improved version of the EBR-II with integral reprocessing to produce 'supergrade' plutonium. On the other hand, any country that wants weapon grade plutonium can build a graphite or heavy water and use the well-understood PUREX process.

It's too early to compare the proliferation risk of a thorium vs plutonium cycle. Solid fuel thorium systems are highly resistant, but liquid fuel systems are too immature to characterize. If a highly effective system of protactinium removal were perfected, it might be possible to extract weapons grade U-233 from a liquid fuel reactor.

Another problem with liquid fueled reactors is that it isn't easy to verify the fuel cycle. In a solid fuel cycle, every fuel element has a serial number, and a random sample of them can be occasionally looked up to make sure that none have disappeared... Diversion outside of the reprocessing center can be easily detected with only intermittent surveillance. With liquid fuel systems, it's impossible to know exactly how much fissionable material was made and where it ended up.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by stcredzero on Friday February 18, 2011 @01:35PM (#2236619)
What are the disadvantages of solid fuel Thorium reactors?
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by PaulHoule on Friday February 18, 2011 @02:20PM (#2236818)
The advantage is that they really work. A Thorium-U233 core was tested in the Shippingport reactor and demonstrated slightly over-unity breeding without operational problems.

One disadvantage is that fuel cycle costs are higher, a lot higher. Some people estimate the cost of electricity from a Shippingport-style reactor could be 3-4 the cost of electricity from conventional LWRs. U-233 in a Thorium cycle gets contaminated with U-232, which has isotopes in its decay chain that emit nasty gamma rays.

Uranium Oxide or Plutonium-Uranium Oxide fuel can be handled manually, but U233-rich fuel is too radioactive for manual handling. The Japanese have managed to fabricate a few sample fuel elements remotely, but this is far from a mature technology.

Another issue with the Shippingport design is that the fuel assemblies are more more complicated and must be fabricated to more precise tolerances than a conventional LWR because reactivity is managed by moving some of the fuel elements relative to other fuel elements.

I think capital costs suffer too: I'd suspect you'd need a larger pressure vessel to contain the same volume of fuel, and power output won't be as good because heat production will happen predominantly in the U-233 'seed' elements, so power density won't be as good as a conventional LWR.

Now, the folks at Lightbridge

http://www.ltbridge.com/

have been doing some work on a seed and blanket core that puts U-233 into metal fuel elements (which would be easier to fabricate remotely) and puts the Th in oxide fuel elements. The metal fuel does better at transporting heat to the fluid, so power peaking may be less of a problem.

Reprocessing is also more expensive in a sold-fuel Th cycle. Th fuel can handled by the THOREX process, which is a modification of PUREX, but it's harder to dissolve Th fuel than U-based fuel.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by CWuestefeld on Friday February 18, 2011 @10:00AM (#2235612)
I'm also not enamored with the idea of planes flying around with tanks of liquid hydrogen.

From what the article says, it seems that the paper hasn't considered very much of the follow-on effects.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by stcredzero on Friday February 18, 2011 @12:52PM (#2236441)
It's not as if planes flying around with tanks of jet fuel are much better. I've read many folks' comments that hydrogen is better, since it tends to float up, out of the way of everything heavier than air.
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by fauigerzigerk on Friday February 18, 2011 @10:23AM (#2235708)
So you think the solution to the intermittency issue outlined in the article isn't workable? Why?
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by PaulHoule on Friday February 18, 2011 @11:42AM (#2236096)
Although hydroelectric power is cheap and carbon-free it causes serious habitat destruction. It's unlikely that significant new hydropower facilities are going to be built in the developed world, and in fact, the ability to produce hydropower is endangered by siltation and climate change.

The availability of hydropower might be enough to use as a buffer, given favorable assumptions, but note that this would cause violent fluctuations of water level downstream of the dams... And many dams are already facing criticism of the water-level fluctuations they cause today. The level of habitat disruption involved is in the "pave the earth" category.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by Retric on Friday February 18, 2011 @12:40PM (#2236386)
Most of the issues with renewable can be solved using pumped storage hydroelectric which has minimal environmental impact. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity

PS: If you simply covered every road in the world with mid range solar panels you meet the worlds current energy needs. EX: The 160,000 miles (260,000 km) of NHS include only 4% of the nation's roads so call it 4,000,000 miles with an average width of say 10 feet. 4,000,000miles * 10 feet (which is vary conservative) = 7,575 square miles or 19,621,122,048m^2. At 750w/m^2 * 15% efficient solar cell * 8 hours a day * 365 days a year * 19,621,122,048m^2 = ~6 * 10^12kwh vs 4 * 10^12kwh actually generated in the USA.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by Semiapies on Friday February 18, 2011 @01:53PM (#2236690)
"If you simply covered every road in the world with mid range solar panels you meet the worlds current energy needs"

Ponder the immense amount of effort, cost, and trouble it took to build every road in the world. Even the massive Interstate Highway system only constitutes a fraction of US roads. Now, instead of laying down inert asphalt, blacktop, concrete, or gravel, what you suggest as an encouraging example involves laying down a much more complicated and expensive infrastructure.

There's no "simply" here, despite the breezy phrasing. (Which is of a piece of all grandiose plans that require only "political will" and umpteen trillions of dollars.)

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by Retric on Friday February 18, 2011 @05:38PM (#2237589)
You know we have the ability to build structures above ground, with the added benefit of reducing the need for snow removal etc. Clearly it's not the cheapest solution, however roads already cover far more land than any reasonable collection of solar power plants so it's useful to add an idea of the scale we are talking about.
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by PaulHoule on Friday February 18, 2011 @02:32PM (#2236874)
Pumped-storage hydro tends to be staggeringly expensive, because you've got all the capital costs of building the dam and then the pumps to pump water up, and then you've got to spend energy pumping water uphill.

Note that the reservoir for a pumped-storage hydro system will be environmentally degraded because water levels are going to fluctuate drastically.

Also, a pumped-storage system failed in the Ozarks, sending a wall of water downstream and nearly killing a family.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taum_Sauk_Hydroelectric_Power_S...

Although fossil fuel pollution kills millions of people a year, hydroelecticity is the most dangerous form of power when one considers catastrophic fatalities:

Workers at the plant were killed in this case:

http://www.unspillable.com/oil-alternatives/hydro-power/russ...

but a dam failure near Rapid City, SD killed nearly 250 in 1972 and the failure of Vajont Dam killed about 2000 people:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vajont_Dam

Some large dams are situated in places where 10,000-100,000 people could be killed in a failure.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by Retric on Friday February 18, 2011 @05:43PM (#2237612)
Umm, I would rather risk x lives once every 100 years than know I am going to kill 10x that every year. (Or did I miss read what you just said.)
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by fauigerzigerk on Sunday February 20, 2011 @06:35AM (#2241674)
I think his main argument was that the sun always shines somewhere and the wind always blows somewhere so if you build a good enough grid you can balance it all out. I don't know how much energy is lost in long distance transmission though.
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by stellar678 on Friday February 18, 2011 @01:55PM (#2236695)
The whole point of their study was to determine what kind of mix would work. They made no claims that intermittent renewables could provide 100% of energy needs all the time.

Intermittent production is why they include hydro as one of the technologies: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity

If there is a strong shift to grid-charged electric vehicles (as opposed to hydrogen fuel cells), that also holds great potential as a buffering mechanism for intermittent energy production. Just because we don't do it now doesn't mean it can't be done.