News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by PaulHoule on Friday February 18, 2011 @12:03PM (#2236211)
A modern FBR that uses commercial plutonium as a starting fuel and with no external blanket could breed with a ratio around 1.0 and, at all points in the fuel cycle, have the Pu be so contaminated with Pu-238, Pu-240 and Pu-241 that weapons use would be impossible.

In fact, sodium cooled cartridge reactors are considered so proliferation resistant that they could be deployed to places where they could fall into enemy hands. Not only is the material inside not usable for weapons, but people trying to get the fuel out would probably be killed by a sodium fire.

Now there's another risk that a government could use FBR technology to construct a system for creating weapons plutonium. For instance, a country like Iran could use an improved version of the EBR-II with integral reprocessing to produce 'supergrade' plutonium. On the other hand, any country that wants weapon grade plutonium can build a graphite or heavy water and use the well-understood PUREX process.

It's too early to compare the proliferation risk of a thorium vs plutonium cycle. Solid fuel thorium systems are highly resistant, but liquid fuel systems are too immature to characterize. If a highly effective system of protactinium removal were perfected, it might be possible to extract weapons grade U-233 from a liquid fuel reactor.

Another problem with liquid fueled reactors is that it isn't easy to verify the fuel cycle. In a solid fuel cycle, every fuel element has a serial number, and a random sample of them can be occasionally looked up to make sure that none have disappeared... Diversion outside of the reprocessing center can be easily detected with only intermittent surveillance. With liquid fuel systems, it's impossible to know exactly how much fissionable material was made and where it ended up.

Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by stcredzero on Friday February 18, 2011 @01:35PM (#2236619)
What are the disadvantages of solid fuel Thorium reactors?
Re:Alternative energy can power the world in 20-40 years by PaulHoule on Friday February 18, 2011 @02:20PM (#2236818)
The advantage is that they really work. A Thorium-U233 core was tested in the Shippingport reactor and demonstrated slightly over-unity breeding without operational problems.

One disadvantage is that fuel cycle costs are higher, a lot higher. Some people estimate the cost of electricity from a Shippingport-style reactor could be 3-4 the cost of electricity from conventional LWRs. U-233 in a Thorium cycle gets contaminated with U-232, which has isotopes in its decay chain that emit nasty gamma rays.

Uranium Oxide or Plutonium-Uranium Oxide fuel can be handled manually, but U233-rich fuel is too radioactive for manual handling. The Japanese have managed to fabricate a few sample fuel elements remotely, but this is far from a mature technology.

Another issue with the Shippingport design is that the fuel assemblies are more more complicated and must be fabricated to more precise tolerances than a conventional LWR because reactivity is managed by moving some of the fuel elements relative to other fuel elements.

I think capital costs suffer too: I'd suspect you'd need a larger pressure vessel to contain the same volume of fuel, and power output won't be as good because heat production will happen predominantly in the U-233 'seed' elements, so power density won't be as good as a conventional LWR.

Now, the folks at Lightbridge

http://www.ltbridge.com/

have been doing some work on a seed and blanket core that puts U-233 into metal fuel elements (which would be easier to fabricate remotely) and puts the Th in oxide fuel elements. The metal fuel does better at transporting heat to the fluid, so power peaking may be less of a problem.

Reprocessing is also more expensive in a sold-fuel Th cycle. Th fuel can handled by the THOREX process, which is a modification of PUREX, but it's harder to dissolve Th fuel than U-based fuel.