News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by bsaul on Sunday February 16, 2020 @05:55PM (#22344249)
This is a blatant act of artificially making old hardware obsolete for no good reason other than force people to purchase new one. I wonder if there isn’t a law against that, at least in the EU.
Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by evilneuro on Sunday February 16, 2020 @10:04PM (#22345276)
They deprecate the feature on Macs without T2 chips because that's where the video stream encoding is done: in hardware. The CPU encoding performance isn't good enough.

Meanwhile, you can buy a Luna Display for your older kit to do the same thing with roughly the same performance, because that also does encoding in hardware.

And adding a new feature to newer hardware doesn't obsolete your old hardware. If Apple release a 5G phone in September, your not-5G iPhone will still work.

Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by diebeforei485 on Sunday February 16, 2020 @06:34PM (#22344403)
It's not making anything obsolete. Nobody is losing anything.

This is a new feature, which they have chosen to make available to recent hardware only.

I suppose you could argue whether the performance features of new devices is really necessary for this new feature to work well (and what does "work well" even mean - is occasional choppiness OK? How low does latency have to be?) but old devices are not losing anything because they never had this feature to begin with.

Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by bsaul on Monday February 17, 2020 @05:50AM (#22346771)
that's not how things work, apple products form an ecosystem, they work together : i buy an ipad pro, now i'd like to use the feature with my 2013 mbp. Oh, but i can't, because it's too old ( or is it ?)

Same thing with apple watch. i "had to" buy an iphone 6 at the time because my 4gs couldn't have the apple watch software installed.

Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by DavideNL on Sunday February 23, 2020 @12:21PM (#22398075)
This is equal to complaining i can't tank electricity with my old Diesel fuel Volkswagen, because the new models can.

It's innovation. There are (hardware, ...) limitations, so you simply cannot run the same software on old hardware.

Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by jsjohnst on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:12AM (#22348656)
> buy an iphone 6 at the time because my 4gs couldn't have the apple watch software installed

Apple Watch supported iPhone 5 and higher. It’s a limitation of the BLE stack on the iPhone 4S (the 4S has BLE, but there were issues with it).

Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by bsaul on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @03:11AM (#22354320)
I agree, it was just an example on how « adding something new » may cause existing hardware obsolete, if you look at it from an ecosystem pov.
Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by thebruce87m on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @05:37AM (#22354954)
They get accused of planned obsolescence either way.

Implement the feature on old hardware, but it’s slow or crippled? Planned obsolescence. Don’t implement the feature... planned obsolescence.

Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by bsaul on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @06:15AM (#22355111)
Well, the solution is easy : implement it everywhere the best you can, and make it optional so that you can disable it on slow hardware.

It's basically the way software updates has worked for ever. Only since apple ( because it controls both the hardware and software) do we see features not deployed on old hardware because it may eventually not give you the best experience.

Re:Apple Sidecar on Unsupported iPads and Macs by chrisseaton on Sunday February 16, 2020 @09:41PM (#22345170)
...it's a new feature.

The features and capabilities on the old device are completely unaffected.

How is adding a new feature to other devices making an old device obsolete?