To expand on that, Kickstarter is a platform where you get people to give you money so you can make something in the future, which is... fine. But it's more of a bootstrapping platform than anything else, and it suffers from that. Kickstarter exploits people FOMO, but it's hampered by the inherent risk that the thing you're funding might never exist.
I'm working on independent games right now. I haven't chosen to Kickstart them, for a lot of reasons. What I would be curious to do is to pick maybe a smaller title, completely finish it, and then put it on Kickstarter for the full amount of money I wanted to get out of it -- not just to fund it, but including my target returns. The game would be done, it would be reviewable by press, once it got funded I would just immediately put it as a free download. But I wouldn't release it until people pledged enough money to make it worth my while -- meaning not just cost of production, but revenue. In theory, exploiting FOMO but with none of the risks that the game won't be finished or that it'll turn out terrible.
I've gone back and forth about the negatives there. It would be way more expensive than an average Kickstarter goal. You have to decide up-front how much money your game is going to make. And you're still fighting against the fact that fans can just say, "well, someone else should fund it." I'm not sure it's actually a feasible model in practice. But I'm really curious to see how the patron model could evolve; just not curious enough to experiment with bigger games where I need them to do well financially.
I am not a copyright abolitionist. I am really interested in seeing alternative models develop, even interested enough that I might experiment in those areas in the future, but I think that there needs to be more working examples of those models before I'm willing to jump ship on copyright.
Copyright should be looked at as a taxpayer funded limited time monopoly. Unfortunately that monopoly time limit has gone way past the 14 years originally intended. You could double that to 28 years with an extension. But now it's ridiculously long. Meaning the taxpayer never see a return on their monopoly investment in the form of public domain.
>The Congress first exercised its copyright powers with the Copyright Act of 1790. This act granted authors the exclusive right to publish and vend "maps, charts and books" for a term of 14 years. This 14-year term was renewable for one additional 14-year term, if the author was alive at the end of the first time. With exception of the provision on maps and charts the Copyright Act of 1790 is copied almost verbatim from the Statute of Anne.[3]
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_copyright_law_of_...
I understand that. I am also not a fanatic in the sense, that I would fight towards a political change to abolish copyright (would be hopeless anyway with the current state of things). I just want to work and fight for more models of working alternatives.
The linux and blender foundations and wikipedia are the best examples I know of. And I want to add another working example soon.
It's an MMO which was shuttered in 2012 despite a very devoted fanbase. People had been clamoring for any chance to play the thing again for years. As an example of this devotion people were calling it a big deal when a program became available that does nothing but allow players to walk around the first hub world and chat together. It was all they could do.
Then word breaks that there had been a private server running in secret the whole time based on source code that had secretly traded hands a long time ago.
Then, regardless of the moral implications, someone went ahead and leaked the source code. Because of that the general public finally got to play the game for the first time in over six years. Apparently it has 100,000 registrants on the most popular server alone, which I find ridiculous for a game which has resurfaced out of nowhere with no real advertising and whose publisher never intended it to return. Imagine all the revenue they're missing out on.
(Of course, it's only popular today because it was popular in 2012 when it was subscription-based.)
From my limited understanding there doesn't seem to be massive feature updates like new maps or raids when Paragon was developing it. Instead there are minor quality of life perks like making the paid upgrades purchasable with in-game currency or tweaking formulas to align with the playerbase's wants. You don't even have pay for anything to keep playing individually; the server is funded by volunteers with donations. The monthly target seems to be about $5,000, most of which goes to hosting fees. Since enough interested people keep paying, the server stays up. And since the source code is now available there's nothing precluding another party from starting a different server if things go under. All to be able to keep playing the game.
It goes to show that people are happy just being able to play the thing at all. There's no need for large salaries to keep developing content and justify monitization. The code is worked on by a devoted team of people with a very big passion for the former-product, and the devs and users are part of the same community.
In a perfect world this is probably how an MMO could be sustained for years to come. And it's possible primarily because the source is available.
Of course, the only reason any of this is possible is because the parties involved blatantly violated copyright by posting the source code and using proprietary assets like textures and music - but this doesn't matter because, for some reason, nobody cares. Yet. Maybe it's because NCSoft figures they're not competing with anyone since they were the ones to shut it down years ago so there's no harm in letting it stay open. Maybe they just got lucky NCSoft wasn't disingenuous and that they weren't slapped with a draconian takedown demand for a very popular game that would otherwise never be playable by anyone until the end of time. But for some reason, the people with the most interest in where all the development capital went just let it slide - for now.
Also this differs from a lot of open source projects since it's technically illegitimate, none of the code is under an open source license, and the work being done is fairly minor. Basically everyone got a head-start by being able to reuse Paragon's code back when the people writing it were salaried and experts in this kind of thing so the complicated parts of the MMO architecture are already finished and everyone can focus on the small quality of life things.
And yes, this is what I mean. When there are enough people who want something to work, they make it work. And in your story despite copyright. So I believe in an ideal world, allmost everything could be organized that way.
However I actually would love to switch to a more kickstarter/etc like system where fans fund the creation of works they enjoy and then those works are just in the public domain / culture as a result. The creators and everyone else involved would be paid before, not after, making something.
More critical would be medical research, but I believe there is actually already lots of freely donated money for example in cancer research involved.
But surely much more is needed, so the change would be with friction ... but if suddenly all the medicine can be made freely, the benefit for the current world population which mostly cannot afford expensive medicine would outweight it, I believe. (anyway all hypothetically anyway)
But since we live in a world with it by default, it is hard to prove it right or wrong. And it is very hard to prove it small scale, since the big industry woukd just use the work of a small inventor without any compensation if they don't have to, just like with open source.
And to the point of the example of patents and secrecy I would add, that for example Elon Musk decided insome cases to not make a patent, because it is a blueprint for others. (don't have the link right now)
Currently yes. Because the normal person is conditioned to only pay if he or she has to.
But imagine if there is sudddenly no more copyright and ... oh my god, no more episode of series xyz because of no money ... you really believe all those hardcore fans would not quickly adopt to pay freely if the result is more of the content they want, if the alternative is no more content?