Re:Working as a programmer - is it what you thought it would...
by aswanson on Friday June 20, 2008 @08:09PM
(#223366)
Wow. This is really enlightening; I thought that the computational method was going to open a new phase in disease treatment, but you seem to say here that the empirical method is on its way to making it useless. So the Pande group at Stanford is wasting their time. Interesting.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Working as a programmer - is it what you thought it would...
by timr on Friday June 20, 2008 @08:26PM
(#223381)
"So the Pande group at Stanford is wasting their time."
I wouldn't go quite that far. The research is definitely speculative, but lots of interesting things can come from speculative research. My point is that you don't do research into protein structure prediction with the intent of finding anything useful. It's basic science.
We can (and occasionally do) learn things from computer models of proteins. But the PR in this field has been seriously exaggerating the results of a few of the more prominent researchers. We're a long way from curing diseases or designing drugs with this stuff.
Re:Working as a programmer - is it what you thought it would...
by aswanson on Friday June 20, 2008 @10:21PM
(#223431)
Is it the weakness of the modeling or the lack of computational horsepower that limits the research in this area? And would you mind linking to your papers?
Re:Working as a programmer - is it what you thought it would...
by timr on Friday June 20, 2008 @10:45PM
(#223446)
That's a matter of debate. Some people think that the problem is search limited, others think that the current models are bad. In my opinion, the bulk of the evidence supports the latter conclusion.
Backchannel me, and I'll be happy to provide you with references to the papers I wrote/helped write. Most of them aren't open access, unfortunately.